Jump to content

Who Sang It Best - Top 16


thevoiceisthetop
 Share

Recommended Posts

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach(The only time I liked Kat)

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16) Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach(The only time I liked Kat)

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16) Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

my choice would be the same.

also, Kat's performance was underrated! I agree it was her best showing in the lives imo, the rests were boring

Edited by Ottoxxx
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

 

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

 

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

 

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

 

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

 

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

 

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

 

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin' on a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer: Caroline Glaser(s4), Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5), Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5), Nolan Neal (s11), Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10), Ashley Levin (s12), Reid Umstaddt (s14), Brooke Stephenson (s17), Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10), Jacob Maxwell (s16), Kat Hammock (s17), Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1), Lisa Ramey (s16), Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9), Bryce Leatherwood

 

Just wanted to add a few comments:

  • Nolan Neal's "Tiny Dancer" has been one of my all-time favorite auditions for a long time.
  • For "Here and Now," I absolutely loved both performances, but I have to give Justin extra points and some credit for doing his live - especially doing such an incredible job during the universally shaky Live Playoffs.
  • Like everyone else, I wish we could've heard Reid's full "Let Him Fly." But based on what is available, Alisan definitely wins for me.
  • Admittedly, I slightly preferred Mathai's "Rumour Has It" on a musical/vocal level, but I'm such a fan of Eric Who's stage presence.
  • Didn't particularly like either "I'm Gonna Be Somebody."
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado (also adding the American Idol S18 Oscars Promo, and also adding part of the Brown Brothers’ AGT S17 audition where Gabe sang “Tiny Dancer” while doing a Kermit the Frog impression)

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Edited by JodiRose
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Living on a Prayer: Sa'Rayah (based on her studio only though, I don't remember how she was live)

Tiny Dancer: Katie Kadan and Destiny Rayne

Here and Now: Justihn Aaron

Let Him Fly: Brooke Stephenson (Alisan was great too!)

Rumor Has It: Mathai

You're Still the One: Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: I loved Zach and Tyler's battle!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Livin´ On a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer:Caroline Glaser(s4),Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5),Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5),Nolan Neal (S10),Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10),Ashley Levin (s12),Reid Umstaddt (s14),Brooke Stephenson (s17),Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10),Jacob Maxwell (s16),Kat Hammock (s17),Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1),Lisa Ramey (s16),Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9),Bryce Leatherwood

Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, Bouli said:

Livin' on a Prayer: Jermaine Paul (s2), Sa'Rayah (s11), Omar Cardona

Tiny Dancer: Caroline Glaser(s4), Brandon Chase vs Emily Randolph (s5), Will Champlin with Adam Levine (s5), Nolan Neal (s11), Katie Kadan vs Destiny Rayne (s17), Sasha Hurtado

Here and Now: Paris Winningham vs Jonathan Mouton (s21), Justin Aaron

Let Him Fly: Alisan Porter (s10), Ashley Levin (s12), Reid Umstaddt (s14), Brooke Stephenson (s17), Rachel Mac (s20), Morgan Myles

Rumour Has It: Mathai (s2), Eric Who

You're Still the One: Brittany Kennell (s10), Jacob Maxwell (s16), Kat Hammock (s17), Kate Kalvach

Sex on Fire: Nakia (s1), Lisa Ramey (s16), Devix

I'm Gonna Be Somebody: Zach Seabaugh vs Tyler Dickerson (s9), Bryce Leatherwood

 

Just wanted to add a few comments:

  • Nolan Neal's "Tiny Dancer" has been one of my all-time favorite auditions for a long time.
  • For "Here and Now," I absolutely loved both performances, but I have to give Justin extra points and some credit for doing his live - especially doing such an incredible job during the universally shaky Live Playoffs.
  • Like everyone else, I wish we could've heard Reid's full "Let Him Fly." But based on what is available, Alisan definitely wins for me.
  • Admittedly, I slightly preferred Mathai's "Rumour Has It" on a musical/vocal level, but I'm such a fan of Eric Who's stage presence.
  • Didn't particularly like either "I'm Gonna Be Somebody."

Also, RIP to Nolan, he sadly passed away in July of this year 😢

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...