Jump to content

The Voice Season 22: Idolforums' ratings


Gustavo527
 Share

Recommended Posts

THE VOICE: S22 IDOLFORUMS RATINGS!

 

Grade the each performance from 0 to 10 

(Artist - Song - Rating) 

 

 I will calculate the average of everyone's ratings for each performance and compile it.

 

You can rate performances to the hundredths place (7.25, 9.75, 6.66, 0.01, 9.99) or just as whole numbers.

 

Anyone can put in their rankings (They need to rank every performance of a night, though). The deadline will be the Sunday immediately before the kickoff of the next round. So all the blinds are due on the day before the premiere of battles.

 

The NUMBER ONE RULE is that NOBODY IS ALLOWED to create multiple accounts with the intention to throw the ratings off. Istersay will find out who you are and your main account and alts will be banned or suspended. We will be able to tell if there is suspicious activity.

 

Be confident about your ratings when you post them. Relisten over and over if needed, because I would prefer you not to change your ratings after you post them (it makes it harder).

 

You are free to rate however you want, and people have their ways of rating performances, but just don't be too absurd with low ratings (giving performances 0.01s for no good reason)

 

To any contestants: This is completely for fun. I wouldn't read too much into a rating. You got chairs to turn for a reason! Maybe I would advise you to exit this page now.

 

 As quoted from last season's topic of this, "Discussion is allowed and encouraged, as long as everyone is respectful. If you can't handle an opinion, go take a walk or something and then come back. The ignore button is also an option if you can't stand another user."

 

That being said, rate away, users of Idolforums!! 

 

(Credits to @David68 for the OP)

Edited by Gustavo527
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah -

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways -

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met -

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin -

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart -

David Andrew - Falling -

Jay Allen - Til You Can't -

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow -

 

You can start now

Edited by Gustavo527
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 8

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 8

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 5

David Andrew - Falling - 5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 7

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 6.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9.2

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9.5

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 9.3

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 9.3

David Andrew - Falling - 7.6

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7.0

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 10

Omar Jose Cardona - Separate Ways - 10

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 8.2

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin' - 10

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 7.8

David Andrew - Falling - 6.5

Jay Allen - Till You Can't - 10

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for being the OP of this.

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 10(And still much more in her tank, I'm very excited for her)

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 5(sorry, I even watched with my sister and mom who agreed on it being meh)

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 4

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 5

David Andrew - Falling - 3

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 6.5

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 7.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 8.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 6

David Andrew - Falling - 6.5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 7.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 8

 

 

I enjoy this thread but I've always wondered if it would be necessary/beneficial to clarify/define what each number represents. I see these smaller numbers like 3 and 4 here which I get, but like in my mind, a 3 or 4 represents somebody that didn't even deserve to turn a chair. I feel the contestants I don't like but did turn a chair are usually a 6 at worst (unless it's like Caribbean Queen level of bad). So I know my 6 might be a lot different than somebody else's 6

 

Edited by Someone648
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 8.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 6.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 4.5

David Andrew - Falling - 5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9.5

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 8

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 6

David Andrew - Falling - 5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 7.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 7

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 7

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 8

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 5

David Andrew - Falling - 6

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 6

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 8

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.25

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 6

David Andrew - Falling - 5.5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Someone648 said:

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 7.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 8.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 6

David Andrew - Falling - 6.5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 7.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 8

 

 

I enjoy this thread but I've always wondered if it would be necessary/beneficial to clarify/define what each number represents. I see these smaller numbers like 3 and 4 here which I get, but like in my mind, a 3 or 4 represents somebody that didn't even deserve to turn a chair. I feel the contestants I don't like but did turn a chair are usually a 6 at worst (unless it's like Caribbean Queen level of bad). So I know my 6 might be a lot different than somebody else's 6

 

Yeah that wouldn't be a bad idea.

I wouldn't be opposed to a tier rating system either.

 

Put each performance into categories from perfect to putrid and everything in between..

 

 

Edited by Hsamid
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 8.7

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met -8

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin -7.9

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart -5

David Andrew - Falling -5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't -7

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow -8.9

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tbh idk if I would personally give any of tonight's performances higher than an 8.

 

(edit: I'm bumping Morgan's scote, after relistening I thought she was clearly better than everyone else lol)

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 7.5

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7.75

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 6

David Andrew - Falling - 5.5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - (the original would've been rated higher)

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7

Edited by FloorWax
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 8.75 (easily the standout of the night and mostly avoids being over a 9 because I’m sick of Hallelujah on singing shows)

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 8.5 (Freddie Mercury comparisons were a bit much + the last note was a touch iffy, but tackling Steve Perry and doing it well is a feat)

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7.75 (lots of character in his voice, but I would’ve liked to see something with a tad more dynamic interest)

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - (I wasn’t expecting the vocal power she showed here, and though Camila had a point about “yelly” spots it was still a very enjoyable listen)

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - (the beginning was good, but it got messy as he got more growly/gritty during the chorus)

David Andrew - Falling - (points for tone, but the arrangement was weird + I don’t think this was quite the right song for him)

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - (very pleasant listening experience, though I did prefer the original song he sang post-chair-turns) 

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7.5 (gorgeous tone, though it did veer into sleepy territory a couple of times)

 

[NOTE: I try not to go below a 5 for blinds, but in later rounds below a 5 is fair game since by that point we have a previous body of work to base contestant performance off of]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9.0

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 6.5 (sorry but Leah Marlene outsold)

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 8.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 8.5

David Andrew - Falling - 6.0

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8.0

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 9.0

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 8.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 5

David Andrew - Falling -6

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7.25

Edited by Misirlou
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 8.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 8

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 7.75

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.75

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 7

David Andrew - Falling - 6

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 7.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 8.25

Edited by indodol
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah-9

Omar Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The night we met -8

Emma Brooke- California Dreamin- 7.5

Orlando Mendez- Beer never broke my heart-7

David Andrew- Falling- 7

Jay Allen-till you can’t - 8.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow-8

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 9.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 7.5

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 6.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 7.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 4.5

David Andrew - Falling - 5

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 6

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1 

 

Morgan Myles - Hallelujah - 8.5

Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 9

Ian Harrison - The Night We Met - 8.5

Emma Brooke - California Dreamin - 5.5

Orlando Mendez - Beer Never Broke My Heart - 3

David Andrew - Falling - 3

Jay Allen - Til You Can't - 8.5

Kate Kalvach - Rainbow - 7.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Reina Ley - Cielito Lindo - 

Bryce Leatherwood - Goodbye Time - 

Alyssa Witrado - Don't Speak - 

Devix - Heat Waves - 

Chello - Just the Two of Us -

Kevin Hawkins - Isn't She Lovely -

Sadie Bass - Stupid Boy -

Brayden Lape - This Town - 

Peyton Aldridge - Can't You See - 

Edited by Gustavo527
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...