Who did you prefer between Matthew/Will, CWB/Anita, Amy/Madi???

[Hamza Tufail]

Discuss.

[Someone648]

Matthew - Easy win

Craig - ugh neither. Anita's was a bit of a hot mess though.

Amy - #1 favorite of all time. Madi's KO was top 10 of all time.

[erik g]

Matthew

Craig- i hate that i'm saying this i loved Anita's auditon

Madi, but Amy was amazing too 

[FloorWax]

Matthew and Amy

[Gustavo527]

This is the only one where i picked the popular opinion on every question 

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Matthew - it was really tough tho.

2. CWB - An easy choice!

3. Madi - see #2

[Misirlou]

1. Both killed it. Matthew was more bombastic and Will more understated. I'm leaning Matthew by a bit here.

 

2. I love reggae and did enjoy some of Anita's work on the show, but this didnt do it for me. Easy win for Craig, it helps that I love southern rock as well, and this performance put him on the map. Love the power and personality he put on that one.

 

3. Tough one, since I really enjoyed both, but I felt Madi was more connected, and that's a key aspect when singing Joni. She wins for me, but both deservingly advanced.

Edited December 31, 2021 by Misirlou

[Cookie73]

1. Both really delivered here. Matthew was fantastic here and delivered another amazing performance and Will had a really good performance as well. I would pick Matthew here because he was on another planet.

2. Craig. This was definitely his breakout performance and I don’t remember Anita being as impactful.

3. Madi. Again, a breakout performance from her. I don’t remember Amy’s doing as much for her

 

[Yti]

1. Matthew 

2. Anita (I'm not picking Craig I physically can't)

3. Amy delivered a great performance as she usually did, but Madi was on another level.