Jump to content

The Voice Season 21: Idolforums' Ratings


David68
 Share

Recommended Posts

Bella DeNapoli vs Katie Rae - No More Tears - 10

KJ Jennings vs Samuel Harness - I Know What You Did Last Summer - 8.75

Girl Named Tom vs Kinsey Rose - Seven Bridges Road - 8.0

The Joy Reunion vs Peedy Chavis - Joy to the World - 7.25

Chavon Rodgers vs David Vogel - Sugar We're Goin Down - 7.0

Jeremy Rosado vs Jershika Maple - Hold On - 9.25

 

Hailey Green vs Lana Scott - GIRL - 8.5

Katherine Ann Mohler vs Vaughn Mugol - Dilemma - 7.5

Brittany Bree vs Samara Brown - Giving Him Something He Can Feel - 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A little bit late, but here are my rankings for the auditions. Most of the people with a 7.5 I forgot, but just remembered liking them originally.

  1. Holly Forbes - Rocket Man: (Legendary.) 10
  2. Girl Named Tom - Helplessly Hoping: (Perfect harmonies) 10
  3. Raquel Trinidad - I Wish: (LOVED her on Idol and love her here. She sounded so great!) 10
  4. Lana Scott - Hole in the Bottle: (OBSESSED with her voice, such a fun performance) 9.5
  5. Samara Brown - Sweet Thing: (Amazing. Would've liked if she stuck to the original song a bit more, but still great) 9.5
  6. BrittanyBree - Call Out My Name: (So powerful, loved this): 9.5
  7. Tommy Edwards - Drops of Jupiter: (Really interesting cover, love his tone): 9
  8. Jershika Maple - Can You Stand the Rain: (I loved all her modulations, so many great moments!)
  9. Carolina Alonso - El Triste: (The ending was so great) 9
  10. Samuel Harness - Two Doors Down: (His tone>>>) 9
  11. Aaron Hines - Heartbreak Anniversary: (His voice is so smooth and amazing) 9
  12. Bella DeNapoli - Damaged: (AMAZING) 9
  13. Wendy Moten - We Can Work it Out: (AMAZING) 9
  14. Shadale - That's What I Like: (So powerful and confident!) 8.5
  15. LiBianca - Good Days (Lots of great moments) 8.5
  16. Jeremy Rosado - Here Comes Goodbye: (Was a fave on Idol, but this song is hard since Brynn put it to rest) 8
  17. Carson Peters - Tulsa Time: (Really solid, esp for his age) 8
  18. Hailey Mia - You Broke Me First: (Don't love the song, but she made it work) 8
  19. Katie Rae - Bones: (Love her voice, but the song wasn't the best) 7.5
  20. Jonathan Mouton - Leave the Door Open: (Great song, lots of good moments) 7.5 
  21. Jim and Sasha - Leaving on a Jetplane: (Lots of nice moment) 7.5
  22. Paris Winningham - Superstition: (Solid) 7.5
  23. Vaughn Mugol - The A Team: (Solid) 7.5 
  24. Keilah Grace - Never Tear Us Apart: (Solid) 7.5
  25. David Vogel - Breathin: (Solid) 7.5
  26. Clint Sherman - Brown Eyed Girl: (Sounded super fun in the clip) 7.5
  27. Gymani - POV: (Didn't love the first half) 7 
  28. Wyatt Michael - Mack the Knife: (Not rly my style, but still liked him) 7
  29. Jack Rogan - House of the Rising Sun: (Nice voice, but didn't feel like he brought enough intensity) 6.5
  30. Peedy Chavis - Heartbreak Hotel: (Kinda boring) 6
  31. Sabrina Dias - Garota de Ipanema: (Hard to judge, but she sounded good!) 6
  32. Xavier Cornell - Teenage Dream: (Showed lots of potential!) 6
  33. Ryleiegh Plank - Anyone: (Not perfect, but not bad) 5.5
  34. Katherine Anne Mohler - We Don't Have to Take Our Clothes Off: (Nobody compares to Ellie) 
  35. Berritt Haynes - Mercy: (Sounded good in the clip, but I have a feeling the rest of it was rocky) 5
  36. Joshua Vacanti - Into the Unknown: (Thought it was a bit cheesy) 5
  37. Janora Brown - Angel of Mine: (Good song, but felt a bit karaoke. Didn't really stand out) 5
  38. Manny Keith - Break My Heart: (Don't love the song) 5
  39. Hailey Green - Home: (Felt like she was overdoing it a bit) 4.5
  40. The Joy Reunion - Boondocks: (One of my fav songs, but I didn't love their rendition) 4.5
  41. KCK3 - No Tears Left to Cry: (A couple good moments, but overall weak) 4
  42. Kinsey Rose - Cowboy Take Me Away: (Biased bc Destinee Quinn put this song to rest, but her voice was a bit weak) 4
  43. The Cunningham Sisters - Never Alone: (Sounded really immature, didn't love this) 3.5
  44. Chavon Rodgers - Driver's License: (Hate the song especially for him) 3
  45. Parker McKay - Slow Hands: (Thought she was really boring) 3
  46. KJ Jennings - Put Your Records On: (Too many runs that didn't go anywhere, her head voice was a bit rocky as well) 3
  47. Kaitlyn Velez - Please Don't Go: (Thought this was a bit boring, don't love her tone either) 3
  48. Sophia Bromberg - Heather: (Genuinely the only part I liked was the little riff she did before she sang) 1.5

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bella DeNapoli vs Katie Rae - No More Tears - 9.9

KJ Jennings vs Samuel Harness - I Know What You Did Last Summer - 7.5

Girl Named Tom vs Kinsey Rose - Seven Bridges Road - 8.9
.9The Joy Reunion vs Peedy Chavis - Joy to the World - 7.1

Chavon Rodgers vs David Vogel - Sugar We're Goin Down - 8.4

Jeremy Rosado vs Jershika Maple - Hold On - 8.5

 

 

Hailey Green vs Lana Scott - GIRL - 8.0

Katherine Ann Mohler vs Vaughn Mugol - Dilemma - 6.5

Brittany Bree vs Samara Brown - Giving Him Something He Can Feel - 8.7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/11/2021 at 5:12 PM, Anybody354 said:

I didn’t comment on here last season, but I actually really liked Christine’s audition (even if it took a little while to grow on me). I would have probably given it a 8.

Agree. Her performance didn't stand out, but it's not like it was offensively bad or anything and she has a pretty nice tone. Solid 6 or 7 IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/20/2021 at 5:35 PM, David68 said:

Blinds:

 

1. Wendy Moten - We Can Work It Out 9.42

2. Holly Forbes - Rocket Man 9.22

3. Gymani - pov 9.02

4. Girl Named Tom - Helplessly Hoping 8.89

5. Bella Denapoli - Damaged 8.88

6. Samuel Harness - Here Without You 8.8

7. LiBianca - Good Days 8.6

8. Brittany Bree - Call Out My Name 8.57

9. Samara Brown - Sweet Thing 8.53

10. Shadale - That’s What I Like 8.27

11. Jeremy Rosado - Here Comes Goodbye 8.22

12. Jershika Maple - Can You Stand the Rain 8.13

13. Hailey Mia - you broke me first 7.93

14. Aaron Hines - Heartbreak Anniversary 7.84

15. David Vogel - breathin 7.67

16. Katherine Ann Mohler - We Don’t Have To Take Our Clothes Off 7.48

17. Joshua Vacanti - Into the Unknown 7.35

18a. Peedy Chavis - Heartbreak Hotel 7.33

18b. Kinsey Rose - Cowboy Take Me Away 7.33

18c. Paris Winningham - Superstition 7.33

21. Hailey Green - Home 7.28

22a. Jim and Sasha - Leaving on a Jet Plane 7.26

22b. Ryleigh Plank - Anyone 7.26

24. Wyatt Michael - Mack the Knife 7.23

25. Parker McKay - Slow Hands 7.22

26a. Keliah Grace - Never Tear Us Apart 7.21

26b. The Cunningham Sisters - Never Alone 7.21

28. Raquel Trinidad - I Wish 7.16

29. Janora Brown - Angel of Mine 7.1

30. Lana Scott - hole in the bottle 7.01

31. Jonathan Mouton - Leave The Door Open 6.99

32. Tommy Edwards - Drops of Jupiter 6.96

33. Carolina Alonso - El Triste 6.93

34. KJ Jennings - Put Your Records On 6.9

35. Vaughn Mugol - The A Team 6.87

36. Jack Rogan - House of The Rising Sun 6.83

37. Katie Rae - The Bones 6.73

38. The Joy Reunion - Boondocks 6.64

39. Manny Keith - Break My Heart 6.54

40. Kaitlyn Velez - Please Don’t Go 6.52

41. Carson Peters - Tulsa Time 6.09

42. KCK3 - no tears left to cry 5.87

43. Chavon Rodgers - drivers’ license 5.53

44. Sophia Bromberg - Heather 4.78

 

No offense, but who ranked the Cunningham Sisters and Parker McKay over Raquel, Jonathan, Katie, and Carolina :wacko:

  • Like 1
  • Confused 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/12/2021 at 9:51 PM, ikwonic said:

A little bit late, but here are my rankings for the auditions. Most of the people with a 7.5 I forgot, but just remembered liking them originally.

  1. Holly Forbes - Rocket Man: (Legendary.) 10
  2. Girl Named Tom - Helplessly Hoping: (Perfect harmonies) 10
  3. Raquel Trinidad - I Wish: (LOVED her on Idol and love her here. She sounded so great!) 10
  4. Lana Scott - Hole in the Bottle: (OBSESSED with her voice, such a fun performance) 9.5
  5. Samara Brown - Sweet Thing: (Amazing. Would've liked if she stuck to the original song a bit more, but still great) 9.5
  6. BrittanyBree - Call Out My Name: (So powerful, loved this): 9.5
  7. Tommy Edwards - Drops of Jupiter: (Really interesting cover, love his tone): 9
  8. Jershika Maple - Can You Stand the Rain: (I loved all her modulations, so many great moments!)
  9. Carolina Alonso - El Triste: (The ending was so great) 9
  10. Samuel Harness - Two Doors Down: (His tone>>>) 9
  11. Aaron Hines - Heartbreak Anniversary: (His voice is so smooth and amazing) 9
  12. Bella DeNapoli - Damaged: (AMAZING) 9
  13. Wendy Moten - We Can Work it Out: (AMAZING) 9
  14. Shadale - That's What I Like: (So powerful and confident!) 8.5
  15. LiBianca - Good Days (Lots of great moments) 8.5
  16. Jeremy Rosado - Here Comes Goodbye: (Was a fave on Idol, but this song is hard since Brynn put it to rest) 8
  17. Carson Peters - Tulsa Time: (Really solid, esp for his age) 8
  18. Hailey Mia - You Broke Me First: (Don't love the song, but she made it work) 8
  19. Katie Rae - Bones: (Love her voice, but the song wasn't the best) 7.5
  20. Jonathan Mouton - Leave the Door Open: (Great song, lots of good moments) 7.5 
  21. Jim and Sasha - Leaving on a Jetplane: (Lots of nice moment) 7.5
  22. Paris Winningham - Superstition: (Solid) 7.5
  23. Vaughn Mugol - The A Team: (Solid) 7.5 
  24. Keilah Grace - Never Tear Us Apart: (Solid) 7.5
  25. David Vogel - Breathin: (Solid) 7.5
  26. Clint Sherman - Brown Eyed Girl: (Sounded super fun in the clip) 7.5
  27. Gymani - POV: (Didn't love the first half) 7 
  28. Wyatt Michael - Mack the Knife: (Not rly my style, but still liked him) 7
  29. Jack Rogan - House of the Rising Sun: (Nice voice, but didn't feel like he brought enough intensity) 6.5
  30. Peedy Chavis - Heartbreak Hotel: (Kinda boring) 6
  31. Sabrina Dias - Garota de Ipanema: (Hard to judge, but she sounded good!) 6
  32. Xavier Cornell - Teenage Dream: (Showed lots of potential!) 6
  33. Ryleiegh Plank - Anyone: (Not perfect, but not bad) 5.5
  34. Katherine Anne Mohler - We Don't Have to Take Our Clothes Off: (Nobody compares to Ellie) 
  35. Berritt Haynes - Mercy: (Sounded good in the clip, but I have a feeling the rest of it was rocky) 5
  36. Joshua Vacanti - Into the Unknown: (Thought it was a bit cheesy) 5
  37. Janora Brown - Angel of Mine: (Good song, but felt a bit karaoke. Didn't really stand out) 5
  38. Manny Keith - Break My Heart: (Don't love the song) 5
  39. Hailey Green - Home: (Felt like she was overdoing it a bit) 4.5
  40. The Joy Reunion - Boondocks: (One of my fav songs, but I didn't love their rendition) 4.5
  41. KCK3 - No Tears Left to Cry: (A couple good moments, but overall weak) 4
  42. Kinsey Rose - Cowboy Take Me Away: (Biased bc Destinee Quinn put this song to rest, but her voice was a bit weak) 4
  43. The Cunningham Sisters - Never Alone: (Sounded really immature, didn't love this) 3.5
  44. Chavon Rodgers - Driver's License: (Hate the song especially for him) 3
  45. Parker McKay - Slow Hands: (Thought she was really boring) 3
  46. KJ Jennings - Put Your Records On: (Too many runs that didn't go anywhere, her head voice was a bit rocky as well) 3
  47. Kaitlyn Velez - Please Don't Go: (Thought this was a bit boring, don't love her tone either) 3
  48. Sophia Bromberg - Heather: (Genuinely the only part I liked was the little riff she did before she sang) 1.5

 

Clint over Gymani?

  • Haha 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, ikwonic said:

Agree. Her performance didn't stand out, but it's not like it was offensively bad or anything and she has a pretty nice tone. Solid 6 or 7 IMO.

I think if it wasn’t in the premiere (which was hella stacked), people would have liked it more. Her low notes were really cool.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

 

and they were the one complaining about TCS and Parker being above some people :giggle:

Admittedly, I can understand their opinion on TCS and Parker being above some other people, but putting Clint over Gymani is a choice when a montaged audition with an accidental chair turn that was probably just good at best gets ranked above an audition that was a creative and powerful take on an Ariana Grande song. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, ikwonic said:

I liked his whole 10* seconds, while I only liked half of Gymani's performance 😐

 

Can you really grade something if you've only heard 1/9th of it, though?

 

Like, if the teacher could only read 1/9th of your test because you spilled something over the rest, she's not going to give you a mark based of the amount she can read.

 

The part about Gymani is your opinion, and I don't believe I should critique others opinions, however, let's look at it like this.

 

You liked the second half of Gymani's performance. Let's say she was montaged, and 10 seconds of the best part was shown. Does that mean Gymani's audition is a 10 in your eyes? No, because the rest lowers its mark for you. 

 

You don't know about a majority of a performance that would potentially drastically change your mark, so it's not fair to give it a mark. That's why we don't mark montages.

  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, British Man said:

 

Can you really grade something if you've only heard 1/9th of it, though?

 

Like, if the teacher could only read 1/9th of your test because you spilled something over the rest, she's not going to give you a mark based of the amount she can read.

 

The part about Gymani is your opinion, and I don't believe I should critique others opinions, however, let's look at it like this.

 

You liked the second half of Gymani's performance. Let's say she was montaged, and 10 seconds of the best part was shown. Does that mean Gymani's audition is a 10 in your eyes? No, because the rest lowers its mark for you. 

 

You don't know about a majority of a performance that would potentially drastically change your mark, so it's not fair to give it a mark. That's why we don't mark montages.

Obviously it's not fair to judge montages, I totally agree. However, I want to at least give the montaged people some attention because they deserve to not be completely overlooked, therefore I decided to include them in my rankings 🙂

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bella DeNapoli vs. Katie Rae - 9.5
Bella DeNapoli - 9.5
Katie Rae - 9.5
 
KJ Jennings vs. Samuel Harness - 8
KJ Jennings - 7.5
Samuel Harness - 8.5
 

Girl Named Tom vs. Kinsey Rose - 9

Girl Named Tom - 9
Kinsey Rose - 8.5
 
The Joy Reunion vs. Peedy Chavis - 7.5
The Joy Reunion - 7
Peedy Chavis - 7.5
 
Chavon Rogers vs. David Vogel - 8.5
Chavon Rogers - 8
David Vogel - 8.5
 
Jeremy Rosado vs. Jershika Maple - 9
Jeremy Rosado - 9
Jershika Maple - 9.5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...