Jump to content

IDF Rates the DWTS30 Routines!

*Wallace

By *Wallace
in Dancing With The Stars

 Share

Recommended Posts

*Wallace

*Wallace

Posted
Posted

Welcome to the IDF Rates the Dancing with the Stars Routines game! This is of course one of my favorite DWTS games to host on here where we get to act as the judges and score routines on how we see them. We have been doing this for 6 years now. Although ugh IDF losing all of those past games we worked so hard on.  But we will make new memories here. You all know the rules so I will break them down below.

 

- We will score the routines on a scale of 1 to 10 (with no half points).

- Please score the routines objectively and based on how the dance was performed/dance. Don’t give high scores just for the celeb being your favorite or low scores because of you not liking the celeb. Base it purely on the dance.

- You are allowed to edit and change your scores throughout the week. I just ask that you re-quote your previous vote and let me know which changes you made as I usually update the scores as they are posted.

- I don’t have a specific post count but I’d say have at least 50 posts in order to vote. Although if you were a regular voter in the past then I could make changes.

- Debates and conversations are welcome. Just don’t bash anyone with their scoring.

- Lastly have fun!

 

 

Voting form will be posted after the first show tomorrow night!

 

STATS:

Week 1: https://idolforums.com/topic/744115-idf-rates-the-dwts30-routines/page/2/#comments

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 273
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

ungodlyhour
ungodlyhour

the real robbery is the 7s for suni  

*Lily
*Lily
ungodlyhour
ungodlyhour

& back again with these! wasn't sure whether to do them on a 30 or 40 point scale (i prefer 30 because it feels like classic dwts) so i did both! not sure which one to stick to for future weeks th

*Wallace

*Wallace

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Now, it is our time to rate the routines! Please vote fairly and honestly solely on the dance performed (with no outside of the dance feelings interfering). Voting will be open for a full week and will close before next week's show.

 

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa):

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango):

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango):
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango):

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango):

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble):
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango):

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ILuvCarrie4eva  

ILuvCarrie4eva

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 6

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 6
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 6

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 3
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 6

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 6
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites
*Diana

*Diana

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 7

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 7
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 6

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 1
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot):  7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites
CarmenSandiego

CarmenSandiego

Posted
Posted (edited)

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha):  7.  Great beginning.
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha):  6.  Not as good as Mel C. but not bad.

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive):  5.  Surprisingly good for a basketball player but that 7 was way too high.
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa):  6.  Looks like picking her for the draft was a good idea.  Very good.

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango):  6.  Not quite as good as Olivia Jade. Tango just isn’t his dance.

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango):  6.  It was pretty close to being a 7, however.
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive):  7.  Would have been an 8 had she been more expressive.  Still best so far.

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango):  6.  Surprisingly stiff.  I thought he would do better.

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango):  7.  She won the battle of the Tangos.  Great job!

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble):  3.  Well, at least he tried.
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot):  6.  Pretty good but I didn’t think that it deserved 7’s.

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango):  6.  Hmm, surprisingly good.

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha):  6.  Good but not great.  The Miz was better.
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot):  6.  He was good but very nervous.
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep):  7.  Would have been an 8 had Jenna not stumbled.

Edited by CarmenSandiego
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Linds  

Linds

Posted
Posted

 

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 6

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 6
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7 sunis dance was beautiful tho 

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 6

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 4
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot):  6

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7(sorry I’m not gonna give an 8 with a slip lol)

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Zoey

Zoey

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 6
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 4

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 6
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 5

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 4
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 5

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 4

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 3
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 5

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot): 3
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites
m1key

m1key

Posted
Posted (edited)

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 6

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango):  6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 6
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 6

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 3
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 6

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 5

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Edited by m1key
Link to comment
Share on other sites
taylorkat

taylorkat

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 5

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 4
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 8

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 5

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 8
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 8

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 8

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 8

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 2
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 8

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 5

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 7
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Shake" (Foxtrot): 5
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 9

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ariel1989

Ariel1989

Posted
Posted

Fixing Brian’s song from “Shake” to “Skate”. 


Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 6
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 5

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 5

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 7
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 5

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 8

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 2
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 6

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 7

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skake" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
*Lily

*Lily

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 6

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 6
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 5

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 6
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 5

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 8

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 3
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 6
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rpryor03  

rpryor03

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 7

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 7
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive):  7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 6

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 3
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 6 
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ungodlyhour  

ungodlyhour

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 6
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 5

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 6
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 5

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 5

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 6
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive):  7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 5

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 6

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 3
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 6 
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites
*Chris

*Chris

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 7
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 7

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 5

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 6
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive):  7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 7

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 8

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 2
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 6

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 5
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Alex95

Alex95

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 6
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 5

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 6

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 5

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 7
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 5

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 7

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 1 (BUT A 10 IN MY HEART!!!!!)
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 5
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 5
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites
.Rei

.Rei

Posted
Posted

Melanie C & Gleb Savchenko - "Wannabe" (Cha-Cha): 6
Mike "The Miz" Mizanin & Witney Carson - "Butter" (Cha-Cha): 6

Iman Shumpert & Daniella Karagach - "Hey Ya!" (Jive): 5
Olivia Jade & Val Chmerkovskiy - "Juice" (Salsa): 7

Jimmie Allen & Emma Slater - "The Way I Are" (Tango): 6

Melora Hardin & Artem Chigvintsev - "Simply Irresistible" (Tango): 7
Suni Lee & Sasha Farber - "Stay" (Jive): 7

Cody Rigsby & Cheryl Burke - "Physical" (Tango): 6

Amanda Kloots & Alan Bersten - "Dance Again" (Tango): 8

Martin Kove & Britt Stewart - "You're the Best" (Paso Doble): 2
Kenya Moore & Brandon Armstrong - "Kiss Me More" (Foxtrot): 7

Christine Chiu & Pasha Pashkov - "Glamorous" (Tango): 6

Matt James & Lindsay Arnold - "Give It To Me Baby" (Cha-Cha): 4
Brian Austin Green & Sharna Burgess - "Skate" (Foxtrot): 6
JoJo Siwa & Jenna Johnson - "Are You Gonna Be My Girl?" (Quickstep): 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...