Jump to content

The Voice 'What If' Scenarios


Mistake006
 Share

Recommended Posts

33 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

Two scenarios:

 

What if Carson didnt mess up his KO, and instead did good with (take this in account) the George Strait song, winning it and advancing to POs?

 

And now lets go back to reality, where he did mess up his KO, what if Blake had picked him either way due to being a 4 chair turn and the voting potential?


His reception was rather mixed. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 11/27/2021 at 6:02 PM, VoiceFan! said:

What if Blake wasn't blocked for Kenzie and Kelly turned for Cam Anthony?
Cam's second choice of coach was actually Kelly, not Nick...

And I'm 99.99% sure that Kenzie would've gone with Blake in a heartbeat

 

Kenzie and Cam would PROBABLY still be the top 2. But would Kenzie win, given Blake's backing/fanbase and success with country artists?

I feel like Kenzie would have won and a part of that would be I think that Blake would know what to do with Kenzie a bit more than Kelly but I do believe cam would have been 2nd plus Kenzie would have been pimped more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, thevoiceisthetop said:

What if the knockout steals switched

 

Team Kelly

Holly

Jeremy

Raquel

Hailey

Gymani

 

Team John

Joshua

Paris

Ryleigh

Shadale

Samuel

 

Team Ariana

GNT

Katie

Bella

David

Jim and Sasha Allen

 

Team Blake

Peedy

Jershika

Wendy

Lana

LiBianca

Assuming the songs stayed the same this is my bet

 

Team Kelly

PVs: Jeremy and Hailey

CS: Gymani

WC: Holly

 

Team Legend

PVs: Joshua and Paris

CS: Shadale

WC: Samuel

 

Team Ariana

PVs: GNT and Jim & Sasha

CS: Bella

WC: David

 

Team Blake

PVs: Wendy and Jershika

CS: Lana

WC: Peedy

 

WC winner: Holly

 

Basically the same top 13 except Bella replaces Ryleigh lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, TheVoiceFan2 said:

Assuming the songs stayed the same this is my bet

 

Team Kelly

PVs: Jeremy and Hailey

CS: Gymani

WC: Holly

 

Team Legend

PVs: Joshua and Paris

CS: Shadale

WC: Samuel

 

Team Ariana

PVs: GNT and Jim & Sasha

CS: Bella

WC: David

 

Team Blake

PVs: Wendy and Jershika

CS: Lana

WC: Peedy

 

WC winner: Holly

 

Basically the same top 13 except Bella replaces Ryleigh lol


I can see this happening, but I would have been mad at Ariana results because of their playoffs, though those artists weren’t very popular.

 

All that would really change at this point is that Holly wouldn’t be pushed as Ariana’s finalist, since she would have Girl Named Tom (who could potentially get Ariana her first win). Blake would probably have a greater chance of getting shut out of the Top 2. I still think Paris would make finale, though his placement might be more limited, and the fifth finalist could be more open

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, thevoiceisthetop said:

What about in s20 if they switched and had a top 9

 

Team Kelly

Ryleigh Modig

Anna Grace

Kenzie Wheeler

Rachel Mac

 

 

Team Nick

Zae Romeo

Pete Mroz

Dana Monique

Jose Figueroa Jr.

 

Team John

Pia Renee

Corey Ward

Victor Solomon

Zania Alake

 

Team Blake

Jordan Matthew Young

Gihanna Zoe

Cam Anthony

Andrew Marshall

Team Kelly

PV: Kenzie

CS: Ryleigh

WC: Rachel

 

Team Nick

PV: Pete (?)

CS: Dana

WC: Zae

 

Team Legend

PV: Victor

CS: Pia

WC: Corey

 

Team Blake

PV: Cam

CS: Jordan

WC: Gihanna

 

No idea who'd win the wildcard but considering Legend was pimped irl imma go with Corey? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if S20 had a top 13?
 

Team Kelly

PV = Kenzie, Corey

CS = Gihanna

WC = Zae

 

Team Legend

PV = Ryleigh, Victor

CS = Pia

WC = Zania

 

Team Nick

PV = Rachel, Dana

CS = honestly...probably Jose

WC = Andrew

 

Team Blake

PV = Jordan, Cam

CS = Anna 

WC = Pete

 

WC Winner= Pete

 

T13 eliminations: Anna, Jose, Pia

T11 eliminations: Ryleigh, Anna

T10 eliminations: Dana, Ryleigh, Pete

T8 eliminations: Bottom 2 - Dana (robbed), Gihanna/Corey

IS: Rachel, Victor (robbed), Gihanna/Corey

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if S19 had a Top 13?

 

Team Kelly

PV: DeSz

PV: Cami Clune/Tanner Gomes

CS: Cami Clune/Tanner Gomes

 

Team Gwen

PV: Carter Rubin

PV: Payge Turner

CS: Ben Allen

 

Team Legend

PV: John Holiday

PV: Tamara Jade

CS: Bailey Rae

 

Team Blake

PV: Ian Flanigan

PV: Jim Ranger

CS: Worth the Wait

 

Wild Card:

Winner: Sid Kingsley/Taryn Papa???

Eliminated: Chloé Hogan, Madeline Consoer, Joseph Soul, Sid Kingsley/Taryn Papa

 

 

 

What if S18 had a Top 13?

 

Team Kelly

PV: Micah Iverson

PV: Megan Danielle

CS: Cedrice (I wouldn't put it past Kelly to pick Cedrice over Mandi. It'd be similar her to her picking Cami over Madeline and Tanner in S19).

 

Team Nick

PV: Thunderstorm Artis

PV: Allegra Miles

CS: Arei Moon

 

Team Legend

PV: CammWess

PV: Zan Fiskum/Mandi Castillo

CS: Zan Fiskum/Mandi Castillo

 

Team Blake

PV: Todd Tilghman

PV: Toneisha Harris

CS: Joanna Serenko

 

Wild Card:

Winner: I could see any one of Mandi Thomas, Michael Williams, or Joei Fulco winning

Eliminated: Mike Jerel, Roderick Chambers, Mandi/Michael/Joei

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 hours ago, TheVoiceFan2 said:

Team Kelly

PV: Kenzie

CS: Ryleigh

WC: Rachel

 

Team Nick

PV: Pete (?)

CS: Dana

WC: Zae

 

Team Legend

PV: Victor

CS: Pia

WC: Corey

 

Team Blake

PV: Cam

CS: Jordan

WC: Gihanna

 

No idea who'd win the wildcard but considering Legend was pimped irl imma go with Corey? 


I think Corey would have gotten PV because his stats were the third best that week. Rachel vs Gihanna in the save would be very rough though, but at least Ryleigh would have advanced after that performance
 

All of Team Kelly’s performances were good, so this would still be difficult. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, Kyn65 said:

What if S19 had a Top 13?

 

Team Kelly

PV: DeSz

PV: Cami Clune/Tanner Gomes

CS: Cami Clune/Tanner Gomes

 

Team Gwen

PV: Carter Rubin

PV: Payge Turner

CS: Ben Allen

 

Team Legend

PV: John Holiday

PV: Tamara Jade

CS: Bailey Rae

 

Team Blake

PV: Ian Flanigan

PV: Jim Ranger

CS: Worth the Wait

 

Wild Card:

Winner: Sid Kingsley/Taryn Papa???

Eliminated: Chloé Hogan, Madeline Consoer, Joseph Soul, Sid Kingsley/Taryn Papa

 

 

 

What if S18 had a Top 13?

 

Team Kelly

PV: Micah Iverson

PV: Megan Danielle

CS: Cedrice (I wouldn't put it past Kelly to pick Cedrice over Mandi. It'd be similar her to her picking Cami over Madeline and Tanner in S19).

 

Team Nick

PV: Thunderstorm Artis

PV: Allegra Miles

CS: Arei Moon

 

Team Legend

PV: CammWess

PV: Zan Fiskum/Mandi Castillo

CS: Zan Fiskum/Mandi Castillo

 

Team Blake

PV: Todd Tilghman

PV: Toneisha Harris

CS: Joanna Serenko

 

Wild Card:

Winner: I could see any one of Mandi Thomas, Michael Williams, or Joei Fulco winning

Eliminated: Mike Jerel, Roderick Chambers, Mandi/Michael/Joei


I’m guessing all of the coach saves would get PV. Every single one of them deserved the semis that season, and Joanna as a CS would work. 
 

I have a feeling Roderick would get the CS over Arei under this format. Also, there could be a 5 person save under this format, since it would be too brutal to prevent only one singer in the T17 from winning the wildcard. 
 

As for S19, I think Ben would actually get a PV over Payge, who would clearly be the save, and I think Sid would win the Wildcard, because I’m the most confident in him delivering out of everyone remaining.

Edited by Cookie73
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What About S19 and S18 if the knockout Steals switched and it still was a top 9

 

 

S19

Kelly

Sid Kingsley

Madeline Consoer

John Holliday

Tanner Gomes

 

John

Tamara Jade

Bailey Rae

Carter Rubin 

Cami Clune

 

Gwen

Payge Turner

Worth The Wait

Joseph Soul

Chloe Hogan

 

Blake

Ben Allen

DeSz

Jim Ranger

Ian Flanigan

 

Would John Win with Carter then?

 

 

 

S18 

 

Kelly

CammWess

Micah Iverson

Mandi Thomas

Toneisha Harris

 

Nick

Roderick Chambers

Mandi Castillo

Arei Moon

Allegra Miles

 

John

Megan Danielle

Mike Jerel

Joanna Serenko

Thunderstorm Artis

 

Blake

Joei Fulco

Todd Tilghman

Zan Fiskum

Cedrice

 

 

How would the formats work with these teams

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been thinking of this a lot: what if Holly had NOT been sick on Monday night?

  • Would she have ended up in the Bottom 3?
  • Would she have performed better on her Instant Save?
  • Or would her Monday night performance have been as awkward as "Caribbean Queen" or "Fancy" anyway?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 12/1/2021 at 11:26 AM, Bouli said:

I've been thinking of this a lot: what if Holly had NOT been sick on Monday night?

  • Would she have ended up in the Bottom 3?
  • Would she have performed better on her Instant Save?
  • Or would her Monday night performance have been as awkward as "Caribbean Queen" or "Fancy" anyway?

Had she not been sick, I think Holly would’ve still wound up in the bottom 3 (she struggled a LOT with the faster part of the song, but tbh I think most people would when there’s that much of a tempo change) since disco hasn’t done well on the show, although I’d argue that she would’ve had a better shot at the save since she would’ve likely been able to better handle the higher/floatier parts of her save song that she struggled with. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if S16 had Knockouts? Bonus points if you predict how the playoffs would have gone if it had the same format as this season.

 

Team Adam:

-Domenic Haynes

-Celia Babini

-LB Crew

-Mari

-Kalvin Jarvis

-Andrew Jannakos

-Rod Stokes

-Kendra Checketts

 

Team John:

-Shawn Sounds

-Maelyn Jarmon

-Julian King

-Lisa Ramey

-Jacob Maxwell

-Kayslin Victoria

-Beth Griffith-Manley

-Jimmy Mowery

 

Team Kelly:

-The Bundys

-Jej Vinson

-Presley Tennant

-Abby Kasch

-Rebecca Howell

-Karen Galera

-Matthew Johnson

-Betsy Ade

 

Team Blake:

-Gyth Rigdon

-Dexter Roberts

-Kim Cherry

-Andrew Sevener

-Selkii

-Carter Lloyd Horne

-Oliv Blu

-Karly Moreno

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's literally so impossible to predict how S16 would have played out had it been a normal season, especially because of how STACKED it was. Still, I wanted to try to predict it anyways lol. Crazy to think that realistically, Blake never would have kept all the country guys on his team. I seriously think that if Blake was being strategic as he usually is, he would've for sure sent Carter home in the KOs, and quite possible Andrew, which totally would've shaped the trajectory of the rest of the season.

 

KNOCKOUTS:

 

Night 1: 

B: Dexter Roberts vs. Andrew Sevener

A: Mari vs. Kalvin Jarvis - Kalvin stolen by John

J: Jacob Maxwell vs. Kayslin Victoria

K: The Bundys vs. Matthew Johnson 

B: Selkii vs. Karly Moreno

J: Maelyn Jarmon vs. Julian King - Julian stolen by Adam

 

Night 2:

A: LB Crew vs. Domenic Haynes

K: Presley Tennant vs. Betsy Ade

J: Beth Griffith-Manley vs. Lisa Ramey - Lisa stolen by Kelly

 

Night 3:

K: Rebecca Howell vs. Abby Kasch

A: Celia Babini vs. Kendra Checketts

B: Kim Cherry vs. Oliv Blu

K: Jej Vinson vs. Karen Galera

J: Shawn Sounds vs. Jimmy Mowery

B (Montage): Gyth Rigdon vs. Carter Lloyd Horne

A: Andrew Jannakos vs. Rod Stokes - Rod stolen by Blake

 

PLAYOFFS:

 

Team Adam:

PV1: LB Crew

PV2: Andrew Jannakos

CS: Mari

WC: Celia Babini

Eliminated: Julian King

 

Team John:

PV1: Maelyn Jarmon

PV2: Shawn Sounds

CS: Beth Griffith-Manley

WC: Jacob Maxwell

Eliminated: Kalvin Jarvis

 

Team Kelly:

PV1: The Bundys

PV2: Presley Tennant

CS: Jej Vinson

WC: Rebecca Howell (WC winner)

Eliminated: Lisa Ramey

 

Team Blake:

PV1: Gyth Rigdon

PV2: Dexter Roberts

CS: Kim Cherry

WC: Rod Stokes (WC winner)

Eliminated: Selkii 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, WastedinMemphis said:

GNT said they came in thinking to pick Blake but Kelly won them over. Assume GNT went with Blake and Wendy went with Kelly.

 

How would this season be different?


There’s a possibility that Wendy would have needed the save.

 

Also, either Peedy or LiBianca wouldn’t have won their Knockout

 

Meanwhile on Team Kelly, Hailey would have probably gotten a PV and Holly may have won her Knockout. 

Edited by Cookie73
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if each of the coaches teams in the top 20 was exchanged like this Blake had Kelly’s team. Kelly had John’s team. John had ariana’s team and Ariana had Blake’s team. Meaning the trans would be

 

Blake:

-Jeremy Rosado 

-Hailey Mia

-Girl Named Tom 

-Gymani

-Katie Rae

 

Kelly:

-Joshua Vacanti 

-Jershika Maple 

-David Vogel

-Shadale 

-Samuel Harness

 

Ariana Grande:

-Wendy Moten

-Paris Winningham 

-Lana Scott

-Peedy Chavis

-Libianca 

 

John:

-Ryleigh Plank

-Raquel Trinidad 

-Jim and Sasha Allen 

- Bella DeNapoli 

-Holly Forbes

 

Would song selection be different on the nights where coaches chose for contestants? Would coach biases of contestants change who’s saved? 
what would the order be from play offs to top 8?

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/5/2021 at 1:51 AM, Mistake006 said:

I'll start with "What if Gwen saved her steal for Marisa Corvo, like she was originally supposed to?

 

Gwen's PO team would have been

 

Carter Rubin (PV)

Payge Turner

Joseph Soul

Marisa Corvo

 

Gwen's CS would be Payge, and Marisa would compete for WC, but would lose to Bailey Rae

Or if she would’ve saved Julia in the battles instead of Joseph.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 12/2/2021 at 10:45 PM, ikwonic said:

What if S16 had Knockouts? Bonus points if you predict how the playoffs would have gone if it had the same format as this season.

 

Team Adam:

-Domenic Haynes

-Celia Babini

-LB Crew

-Mari

-Kalvin Jarvis

-Andrew Jannakos

-Rod Stokes

-Kendra Checketts

 

Team John:

-Shawn Sounds

-Maelyn Jarmon

-Julian King

-Lisa Ramey

-Jacob Maxwell

-Kayslin Victoria

-Beth Griffith-Manley

-Jimmy Mowery

 

Team Kelly:

-The Bundys

-Jej Vinson

-Presley Tennant

-Abby Kasch

-Rebecca Howell

-Karen Galera

-Matthew Johnson

-Betsy Ade

 

Team Blake:

-Gyth Rigdon

-Dexter Roberts

-Kim Cherry

-Andrew Sevener

-Selkii

-Carter Lloyd Horne

-Oliv Blu

-Karly Moreno

 

I have a note in my notes app with this LMAO I'm such a geek

 

Anyways, using the Cross Battles as their KO performances I'd say this is how it would go

 

Taping 1

B: Kim Cherry vs Karly Moreno

K: The Bundys vs Betsy Ade. Betsy STOLEN by Adam

A: Mari vs Domenic Haynes. Domenic STOLEN by Kelly

B: Selkii vs Oliv Blu. Oliv STOLEN by John

J: Beth Griffith-Manley vs Lisa Ramey. 

K: Presley Tennant vs Karen Galera

 

Taping 2:

A: Celia Babini vs Kendra Checketts. Kendra STOLEN by Blake 

K: Jej Vinson vs Matthew Johnson

J: Jacob Maxwell vs Kayslin Victoria

B: Gyth Rigdon vs Andrew Sevener. 

A: Rod Stokes vs Andrew Jannakos

J: Maelyn Jarmon vs Jimmy Mowery

 

Taping 3

A: LB Crew vs Kalvin Jarvis

J: Shawn Sounds vs Julian King

K: Rebecca Howell vs Abby Kasch. 

B: Dexter Roberts vs Carter Lloyd Horne 

 

Top 20

 

Adam:

Celia Babini

LB Crew

Mari

Rod Stokes

Betsy Ade (steal)

 

Legend:

Beth Griffith Manley

Jacob Maxwell

Maelyn

Shawn Sounds

Oliv Blu (steal)

 

Kelly:

Jej Vinson

Presley Tennant

Rebecca Howell

The Bundys

Domenic Haynes (steal)

 

Blake

Dexter Roberts

Gyth Rigdon

Kim Cherry

Selkii

Kendra Checketts (steal)

 

 

Playoffs

 

Adam

PVs: LB Crew and Rod Stokes

CS: Celia Babini

WC: Mari (winner) (tbh idk but considering she got more votes than Selkii and Oliv in two different rounds I'm going with her)

Eliminated: Betsy Ade

 

Legend

PVs: Maelyn and Shawn Sounds

CS: Beth Griffith-Manley

WC: Oliv Blu

Eliminated: Jacob Maxwell

 

Kelly

PVs: Jej Vinson and Presley Tennant

CS: Rebecca Howell

WC: Dominic Haynes

Eliminated: The Bundys

 

Blake

PVs: Gyth Rigdon and Dexter Roberts

CS: Kim Cherry

WC: Selkii

Eliminated: Kendra Checketts

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Keeping in mind they had a steal AND save in S16:

(And not basing on how they performed that night bc it was god awful)

 

Team Adam:

Domenic Haynes vs. Kalvin Jarvis - STOLEN by John

Rod Stokes vs. Andrew Jannakos -

Celia Babini vs. Kendra Checketts - STOLEN by Blake

Mari vs. LB Crew (SAVED)

 

Team John:

Maelyn Jarmon vs. Jacob Maxwell - STOLEN by Adam

Lisa Ramey vs. Jimmy Mowery

Julian King vs. Kayslin Victoria

Shawn Sounds vs. Beth Griffith-Manley (SAVED)

 

Team Kelly:

Rebecca Howell vs. Abby Kasch

The Bundys vs. Betsy Ade 

Presley Tennant vs. Karen Galera (SAVED)

Jej Vinson vs. Matthew Johnson

 

Team Blake:

Gyth Rigdon vs. Carter Lloyd Horne (SAVED)

Dexter Roberts vs. Andrew Sevener - STOLEN by Kelly

Kim Cherry vs. Oliv Blu

Selkii vs. Karly Moreno

 

Team Adam:

Domenic Haynes

Rod Stokes

Celia Babini

Mari

LB Crew (Save)

Jacob Maxwell (Steal)

Predicted top 3: Rod Stokes, Domenic Haynes, Mari (Save)

 

Team John: 

Maelyn Jarmon

Lisa Ramey

Julian King

Shawn Sounds

Beth Griffith-Manley (Save)

Kalvin Jarvis (Steal)

Predicted top 3: Maelyn Jarmon, Shawn Sounds, Beth Griffith-Manley (Save)

 

Team Kelly:

Rebecca Howell

The Bundys

Presley Tennant

Jej Vinson

Karen Galera (Save)

Andrew Sevener (Steal)

Predicted top 3: Jej Vinson, Rebecca Howell, The Bundys

 

Team Blake:

Gyth Rigdon

Dexter Roberts

Kim Cherry

Selkii

Carter Lloyd Horne (Save)

Kendra Checketts (Steal)

Predicted top 3: Gyth Rigdon, Dexter Roberts, Kim Cherry

 

Top 12: 

Rod Stokes

Domenic Haynes

Mari

Maelyn Jarmon

Shawn Sounds

Beth Griffith-Manley

Jej Vinson

Rebecca Howell

The Bundys

Gyth Rigdon

Dexter Roberts

Kim Cherry

 

We were doomed for a country season from the start :haha:

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, VoiceFan! said:

I have a good one

 

What if Gwen was in S21 instead of Ariana?
 

Would all the pop girls go to Team Kelly then? What genres would Gwen get...and WHO specifically?

 

 

Depends because maybe several of them auditioned just because they knew Ariana would be a coach . Bella, Ryleigh, Hailey , Sophia , possibly Raquel would have went with Kelly , while Samuel and David would have went with Gwen .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...