Which type of singer do you prefer?

[QueenCami]

Another one of these polls, but I'm actually curious to see what y'all prefer in a singer. Also, I'd love to hear who y'all think fits into each category.

Edited June 12, 2021 by QueenCami

[Cookie73]

I’d go with someone who is more inconsistent because I will remember their run better. I generally like the contestants that have performances that stick out. If someone is never bad, but never has moments, I will not get into them. However, if someone has a few duds, but a lot of great performances, I will find them more interesting. I can’t think of too many contestants that alternated between great and bad but some contestants alternated between great and meh (Ex: Chloe and Jake Hoot. I loved a few performances from them but didn’t care for some others). The biggest example of okay but consistent to me is Chris Kroeze. I didn’t hate his performances, but I didn’t find them interesting.

[Someone648]

I stan Will Breman so my vote goes to "inconsistent"

[Jordan Smith Fan]

My top choice would be excellent and consistent but since it's not here so I chose "Excellent and inconsistent"

[AliXRose]

How many bad performances are we talking about ? I can't handle more than one lmaoo

 

I'll go with consistency 

[VintageVoice]

6 hours ago, Someone648 said:

I stan Will Breman so my vote goes to "inconsistent"

Taste

 

Voted for “inconsistent” because most who are less consistent don’t go between great and terrible (and the really great performances are memorable, as are the really terrible ones).

[Misirlou]

I´ve liked several contestants that had both types of runs on the show. But I´m actually gonna go with consistent here. Trainwrecks can eventually become too much.