Rank the Seasons (S1 - S20)

[Dai]

I don’t like to do repeats of older threads, but I’m really curious to see where people rank S20 (it seems some people are ready to compare it to S5 and S13, so this should be interesting)

Edited June 6, 2021 by Daillon

[Dai]

Legendary
S5

Great

S4

S8

S13

 

Solid overall
S10

S20

S17

S9

 

Boring but had some great moments

S12

S7

S6

S18

 

Not a fan
S15

S19

Tragic, almost made me quit the show
S14

S11

S16

Edited June 6, 2021 by Daillon

[Bk1234]

The top tier for me would be S4, S5, and S13. Below that, I would put S12, S15, and S20.

[Hamza Tufail]

s5 is still the best for me. s4, s9, and s20 are next in line.

Edited June 6, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[Hamza Tufail]

iirc S20 was only two or three votes behind s13 for the top 9. I guess the eliminations of Corey, Dana, Gihanna, Pia really hurt it's chances(For IDF).

[Misirlou]

S17 is still the season I enjoyed the most. After that comes S5, S13 and S15. Then come the rest.

[Jordan Smith Fan]

Legendary:

s5

s20

 

Amazing:

s9

s7

s4

 

Great:

s18

s10

s17

s3

 

Good:

s13

s12

s6

s16

 

Trash:

s15

s19

s14

 

Didn't watch the first two seasons live.

[Dai]

1 hour ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I guess the eliminations of Corey, Dana, Gihanna, Pia really hurt it's chances(For IDF).

 

It has probably more to do with the awful format than anything else.

 

Personally can't really put S20 in the same conversation as S4, S5 and S13 when we only had three weeks of lives (and two of them weren't that great anyways)

[Gustavo527]

I didn't follow the show between season 1-4, so i won't rank them.

 

Trash

16. Season 16

15. Season 11

14. Season 19

 

Not my cup of tea

13. Season 7

12. Season 9

11. Season 12

10. Season 14 

 

Solid overall

9. Season 18

8. Season 15

7. Season 20

6. Season 6 

5. Season 17

 

Probably the ones i enjoyed the most since beggining to end

4. Season 8

3. Season 10 

2. Season 13 

1. Season 5

[Mistake006]

Out of the season I’ve seen in full

 

 1. Season 20

 2. Season 13

 3. Season 19

 4. Season 17

 5. Season 15

 6. Season 14

 7. Season 18

 8. Season 16

If I judged them by pre-lives only, that changes a lot

 

 1. Season 15

 2. Season 20

 3. Season 13

 4. Season 19

 5. Season 17
 6. Season 14
 7. Season 16

 8. Season 18

 

Edited June 8, 2021 by Mistake006

[Cookie73]

Sorting by formats to make it easier (T5 and B5 last)

 

Double elimination era

Season 5 is the best season here. Most of these seasons would be in the top half overall. Don’t remember many of the Live shows that well. Best format out of all seasons

 

Bloodbath Era

1. Season 13

2. Season 10

3. Season 9

4. Season 17

5. Season 12

6. Season 16

7. Season 15

8. Season 11

9. Season 14

 

I have better memories of the Lives in all seasons. I like 1-5 here but found the others either frustrating or underwhelming. 

Quotas Era

1. Season 20

2. Season 18

3. Season 19

 

Season 20 would be in my top half and the others would be above the bottom 4 of the bloodbath era. The format is the worst in this era.

 

Overall

 

Best

1. Season 5

2. Season 13

3. Season 10

4. Season 20 (could be higher if more lives)

5. Season 7 or 9

 

Worst

1. Season 14

2. Season 11

3. Season 15

4. Season 16

5. Season 19

 

1 and 2 are excluded because I didn’t watch them