Jump to content

Rank the Top 9 Performances


David68
 Share

Choose your favorite.  

59 members have voted

  1. 1. Favorite (solo) performance?

    • Victor Solomon - I Can Only Imagine
      0
    • Jordan Matthew Young - Rose Colored Glasses
      0
    • Pia Renee - Turn Your Lights Down Low
      3
    • Rachel Mac - Human
      4
    • Corey Ward - Arcade
      4
    • Gihanna Zoe - Reflection
      18
    • Dana Monique - Leave the Door Open
      1
    • Cam Anthony - It's So Hard to Say Goodbye to Yesterday
      27
    • Kenzie Wheeler - He Stopped Loving Her Today
      2
  2. 2. Favorite (trio) performance?

    • Cam, Corey, Kenzie - Fooled Around and Fell in Love
      18
    • Dana, Pia, Victor - Shining Star
      34
    • Gihanna, Jordan, Rachel - Go Your Own Way
      7


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Cam

Victor

Pia-Gihanna

Gihanna-Pia

Jordan

Corey

Kenzie

Rachel

Dana

 

Dana, Pia, Victor>>>>Cam, Corey, Kenzie>>>>>>>>>>>>Jordan, Rachel, Gihanna

Edited by pauwis
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Cam

(Dana’s trio)

2. Gihanna

3. Pia

4. Dana

5. Victor

(Cam’s trio)

6. Rachel

7. Jordan

8. Corey

9. Kenzie

(Gihanna’s trio)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Soloes:

1. Gihanna 10/10: Pretty much a perfect performance, very strong vocals and a very smart song choice.    
2. Cam 9/10: Pretty good performance, easily my favorite from him so far.  Liked his runs and high notes.
3. Rachel 8.5/10: Pretty meh start but it really picked up at the end and she stayed in pitch this time around.  Not her best showing but probably her best ending moment of a performance yet.
4. Kenzie 8/10:  This was pretty similar to Rachel's where the beginning was boring but he popped off at the end.  This wasn't enough to completely secure the PV though he will still probably get it.

5. Corey 8/10: Solid vocal but wasn't as good as some of his other performances.  I hope he has something better in the IS as he still has my favorite performance in the entire competition (Already Gone).
6. Dana 8/10: Dana still doesn't miss, but got messed up by song choice.  Still a good vocal though and she did the best she could for what she got.
7. Pia 8/10:  She surprised me with a pretty good performance and a huge improvement over anything she's done in the past.  Thought she would have gotten crushed by Victor but now she's my PV prediction.
8. Jordan 7/10: He also got messed up by song choice though his tone was very nice.
9. Victor 6.5/10:  Pretty smart song choice but he didn't deliver that well and gave a boring performance.  Wasn't as bad as his performance last week but he sounded like he was sick in his higher notes.  

 

Trios:

1. Dana/Victor/Pia: All 3 of them were amazing and their voices really blended together well.  Great performance and one of the best of the night overall

2. Corey/Kenzie/Cam: Good performance that was carried by Corey's high notes, though Kenzie and Cam were solid as well.  Cam sounded kinda soft here though.

3. Jordan/Gihanna/Rachel: Jordan hard carried this, wish this was his solo performance instead of that boring one he gave tonight.

Edited by Anonnymoose
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Cam

2. Dana,Pia, Victor

3. Gihanna

4. Corey

5. Pia

6. Dana

7. Victor

8. Kenzie

9. Cam,Corey,Kenzie

10.Rachel

11.Gihanna,Jordan,Rachel

12.Jordan

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Cam (Yeah, if he doesn`t win it`s ridiculous. One of the most excellent runs I`ve ever seen on the show, assuming he doesn`t fall in the finale. This was all around levels of excellent)

2. Gihanna ( I`m not her biggest fan, but goddamn did she show up tonight. Loved the clarity and precision of her voice. Her choices were creative too. Great job)

3. Pia ( This won`t please Minivan, but she did her thing and I loved it. The rapping was a nice touch. She felt right at home on that stage).

4. Victor ( His strongest showing since the blinds. Finally doing something that fits him well. While I do prefer Pia, I`ll be content with him on the finale either way)

5. Jordan ( Controversial, but I enjoyed this. Yes, I would have much rather preferred to see him rocking out, but I loved his tone here. Way better than his audition if we`re talking about him doing classic country)

6. Dana ( A bus, but she did manage to give some great moments right there. Doubt this will be enough to get her to the finale, but I`d say she earned if we take in account her competitor)

7. Kenzie ( What could have been the biggest moment of the night fell flat for me. I get it now. Kenzie is a fantastic vocalist, he sings with ease and is in tune. But he just doesn`t have "it" that made the other country singers on this show the favorites. This song was a tall order, and he didn`t really pull it off. We`ll see how it goes for FB)

8. Rachel (Shaky start, great middle, and it went off the rails completely by the end for me. She`s had a beautiful growth arc and is very easy to root for, but tonight wasn`t her night).

9. Corey (This was not the man that slayed "Already Gone" and "Lose You To Love Me")

 

Trios

1. Dana/Pia/Victor (LOVED it. They should collaborate in the future for sure)

2. Cam/Corey/Kenzie ( I enjoyed this. Cam lead well , and Corey and Kenzie held their own. I ended up liking Kenzie better here than in his actual performance lol)

3. Gihanna/Rachel/Jordan (Jordan. That is all. Glad he got to do a bit of lead guitar work here though.)

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Close to Flawless

1. Gihanna

Good

2. Dana 

3. Pia

Eh...

4. Cam

5. Kenzie

6. Rachel

7. Victor

Not Good

8. Corey

9. Jordan

 

1. Dana's Trio

2. Cam's Trio

3. Gihanna's Trio

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not exactly how I expected tonight's ranking to go... like at all. Everyone but Cam and Pia were letdowns for me lol.

 

Two Standouts:

1. Cam Anthony (9.5) - I have Corey as my favorite and he's who I'm rooting for overall - but this guy right here deserves the win.

2. Pia Renee (9) - She was in her element tonight! Loved to see that. She was honestly the only one I was a bit hesitant on making the semifinals but she proved tonight that she earned her spot!

 

 

Middle Tier/Moderately Disappointing

3. Kenzie Wheeler (8) - Was anticipating a bigger moment for Kenzie tonight. With that song I expected a lot more but it wasn't perfect.

4. Gihanna Zoe (8) - She did the best she could with the song for sure. Didn't hear many issues, but didn't hear anything that made me say WOW either.

5. Corey Ward (7.5) - His shakiest thus far but I did enjoy him! Nothing was bad here, but it definitely wasn't perfect. Here's hoping viewers recall his entire run as well.

6. Victor Solomon (7.5) - Glad to see him return somewhat to what he's best at. Definitely think it was his best since blinds, but it still left a lot to be desired.

7.  Dana Monique (7.5) - Goodness Dana, why did they pick this for her. For what it's worth, she did the best she possibly could and served. It's just so wrong to give her this song... the disrespect!

 

Nah

8. Jordan Matthew Young (7) - This was fine but went nowhere.

9. Rachel Mac (6) - A couple really solid notes throughout, but this whole thing was messy, sorry Rachel.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Victor was actually good , iffy at the beginning but recovered well .8/10

jordan was actually decent. 6.5/10

Pia was really good , and she slayed the rap part. 8/10

corey, IDK what happened. 5/10

rachel was good , not better than last week but still good. 8-8.5/10

Gihanna just slayed periodtttt, guys Xtina is not easy to cover , and she is 17 , WHAT. To be 17 and slaying an Xtina song like that , your not normal . Gihanna SNAPPED. My fave semifinals performance. 10/10, actually no a 10000000000000000000000000/10

Dana even with that bus , she still slayed 8.8/10

Cam was great vocally, but a tad bit boring  and toooooooo many runs, I wish he had more of a stronger build up and gave us something other than just runs . 7.5 - 8.5/10

Kenzie was actually great , like from reading IDF comments I expected him to do okay at best , but he slayed, 9/10

Edited by Mohammad
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, it's pretty much Cam > Gihanna > everyone else, but here goes:

 

1. Cam A near-flawless performance. He came to slay, as usual.

2. Gihanna This song was either going to be a capital-m Moment for her or a huge fail, and I'm so glad it was the former! She killed this.

3. Pia Super strong, if not as exciting as she needed to be. She was awesome in the trio performance, though

4. Victor This should have been a slam dunk, but it was just fine. 

5. Kenzie A little pitchy and disappointing, but only compared to how strong he's been before this. Definitely enough to get him the PV (even though it should be Gihanna)

6. Corey Shakier than usual, and the song choice didn't allow for as much emotion. Still, he leaves it all on the stage, and that counts for something

7. Rachel A few impressive moments, but messy overall. 

8. Dana Yikes. She deserved the PV last week, so I hoped she would get it now, but this wasn't it.

9. Jordan Vocally he was better than Dana and Rachel, but I totally forgot about him, which might be worse

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Cam Anthony - It's So Hard to Say Goodbye to Yesterday
2. Pia Renee - Turn Your Lights Down Low
3. Gihanna Zoe - Reflection
4. Rachel Mac - Human
5. Victor Solomon - I Can Only Imagine
6. Dana Monique - Leave the Door Open
7. Corey Ward - Arcade
8. Kenzie Wheeler - He Stopped Loving Her Today
9. Jordan Matthew Young - Rose Colored Glasses


1. Dana, Pia, Victor - Shining Star
2. Gihanna, Jordan, Rachel - Go Your Own Way
3. Cam, Corey, Kenzie - Fooled Around and Fell in Love

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

1. Cam - "It's so hard to say goodbye to yesterday"

 

(gap)

 

2. Gihanna - "Reflection"

 

(Grand Canyon

Pacific ocean depth

Mount Everest

K2

Burj Khalifa

Shanghai Tower

Makkah Royal Clock Tower

Empire State Building)

 

The rest....

Edited by Jordan Smith Fan
  • Like 2
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 
 

Not at the top of their game tonight

9.  Rachel Mac

8. Jordan Matthew Young

7. Kenzie Wheeler

6. Victor Solomon

5. Dana Monique

 

As consistent as ever

4. Cam Anthony

 

Criminally underrated

3. Pia Renee

 

OK, I see you

2. Gihanna Zoe


.....and what about it?

1. Corey Ward

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They slayed

1. Gihanna - My unexpected best of the night. She showed up and brought the power, the emotion.... This is her best performance of the season for me, no doubts about it.

 

2. Cam - Even though I didn't like this as much as I wanted to, this should tell the audience who really deserves to win this season. Such a perfect vocal.

 

3. Pia - I barely got to hear this due to my stream, but after a rewatch, this was actually very good. If she's out tomorrow, this is a good performance to end on. 

 

Clear issues, but not that bad

4. Victor - After finally getting the gospel song we wanted from him all season, I'm kind of underwhelmed. He was much better last week, and in the trio. Both upbeat songs, hmm.

 

5. Kenzie - This bored me for a little bit before finally picking up at the end. The audience will love this, but it's not a performance that will 100% secure the win for him.

 

6. Corey - Honestly? Not as bad as I remember. The pitch issues were there, and very blatant, but I still found it more enjoyable than the 3 below.

 

7. Dana - I love this song, and she did not bring the level of passion, intensity, and smoothness that the original had. She is a very talented vocalist, but this song is so wrong for her. This might also be the only time I've heard an off note from her all season.

 

Kind of hard to sit through

8. Rachel - I agree with what has been said. Shaky beginning, good middle portion, but she went completely off the rails at the end and it was kinda painful.

 

9. Jordan - I'm sorry, this was just such a snoozefest that I couldn't even finish my rewatch. Again, WRONG SONG.

 

 

Trio Performances:

1. Pia, Dana, Victor - AMAZING. All three SLAYEEEED. That felt like a true throwback performance.

2. Cam, Corey, Kenzie - Not the most exciting song choice, but everyone did well for the most part. Kenzie sounded really weird on it though.

3. Jordan, Rachel, Gihanna - 😬😬😬

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5/10 Victor Solomon - I Can Only Imagine

4/10 Jordan Matthew Young - Rose Colored Glasses

5/10 Pia Renee - Turn Your Lights Down Low

7/10 Rachel Mac - Human

1/10 Corey Ward - Arcade

5/10 Gihanna Zoe - Reflection

4/10 Dana Monique - Leave the Door Open

7/10 Cam Anthony - It's So Hard to Say Goodbye to Yesterday

0/10 Kenzie Wheeler - He Stopped Loving Her Today

 

4/10 Cam, Corey, Kenzie - Fooled Around and Fell in Love

7/10 Dana, Pia, Victor - Shining Star

4/10 Gihanna, Jordan, Rachel - Go Your Own Way

 

 

Okay, what a underwhelming night, only liked Rachel, Cam and the Shining Star gruop.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, iloveadam said:

5/10 Victor Solomon - I Can Only Imagine

4/10 Jordan Matthew Young - Rose Colored Glasses

5/10 Pia Renee - Turn Your Lights Down Low

7/10 Rachel Mac - Human

1/10 Corey Ward - Arcade

5/10 Gihanna Zoe - Reflection

4/10 Dana Monique - Leave the Door Open

7/10 Cam Anthony - It's So Hard to Say Goodbye to Yesterday

0/10 Kenzie Wheeler - He Stopped Loving Her Today

 

4/10 Cam, Corey, Kenzie - Fooled Around and Fell in Love

7/10 Dana, Pia, Victor - Shining Star

4/10 Gihanna, Jordan, Rachel - Go Your Own Way

 

 

Okay, what a underwhelming night, only liked Rachel, Cam and the Shining Star gruop.

Rachel was better than Gihanna and equal to Cam??? imao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, Jordan Smith Fan said:

Rachel was better than Gihanna and equal to Cam??? imao

 

Srsly, everyone has their own preferences, it doesn't show how you really have taste when laughing at the actual thoughts of someone else.

 

What I think about Gihanna's performance is that was just a decent rendition of the song, nothing special, not as powerful as other versions and the arrangement is the same old. And it's okay you can all love her or others, and I respect that.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, iloveadam said:

 

Srsly, everyone has their own preferences, it doesn't show how you really have taste when laughing at the actual thoughts of someone else.

 

What I think about Gihanna's performance is that was just a decent rendition of the song, nothing special, not as powerful as other versions and the arrangement is the same old. And it's okay you can all love her or others, and I respect that.

Fair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a very clear Top 3 today.

 

Slay

1. Cam (It's still a mystery why his studios feel underwhelming to me, but dang the live performance was amazing. So beautiful)

2. Gihanna (Pretty as always, but this time she really knocked it out of the park)

3. Pia (She's so underrated it hurts. Not only she slayed but she's the most unique contestant left)

 

Yay, you didn't flop!

4. Dana (I actually dig this Dana performance, it was fun and as great of a vocal as always)

 

Meh

5. Corey (Pitchy, by far his worst performance. I still enjoyed it tho, which I can't say for the people below)

6. Kenzie (I liked this better after a rewatch, but it's still a no from me dawg)

7. Rachel (Messy)

8. Jordan (Snoozefest and a disappointment after last week)

9. Victor (Something here didn't work for me at all. Maybe he should stick to the uptempo after all)

 

As for the trios...

 

1. Shining Star (Don't know what happened to Victor in the solo, but he slayed here. Dana and Pia as good as always)

2. Fooled Around and Fell in Love (This was fun)

3. Go Your Own Way (Nope)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...