Rank the Performances - S19, Top 10: Personal Idol / Coronation Single / Reprise / Duets

[Elliott]

Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

Casey Bishop – “Love Me, Leave Me” (Casey Bishop)

Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)
Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

[ShortstopVM]

Personal Idol:

1. Willie

2. Grace

 

3. Casey

4. Chayce

 

Originals:

1. Willie

2. Grace

 

3. Chayce

4. Casey

 

Reprise:

1. Grace

2. Willie

 

3.Casey

4. Chayce

 

Duet:

1. Willie

2. Grace

3. Casey

 

4. Chayce

 

Overall:

1. Willie/Grace

 

3. Casey

4. Chayce

Edited May 17, 2021 by ShortstopVM

[ScarletDevilCCX]

1. Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

2. Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

3. Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

4. Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

5. Casey Bishop – “Love Me, Leave Me” (Casey Bishop)

6. Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)

7. Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

 

8. Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

 

9. Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

10. Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

11. Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

12. Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

 

13. Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

 

14. Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

 

Overall:

 

1. Casey Bishop

2. Willie Spence

3. Chayce Beckham

4. Grace Kinstler

 

 

[taylorkat]

1. Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

2. Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

3. Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

4. Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

5. Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)

6. Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

7. Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

8. Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

9. Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

10. Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

11. Casey Bishop – “Love Me, Leave Me” (Casey Bishop)

12. Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

13. Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

14. Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

[m1key]

1. Casey Bishop - Live Wire

2. Grace Kinstler - Father

3. Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence - What They'll Say About Us

4. Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham - Break My Heart Again

5. Willie Spence - Glory

6. Grace Kinstler - A Moment Like This

7. Willie Spence - I Was Here

8. Casey Bishop - wish you were gay

--------------------------------------------------------

9-14. The rest

 

Originals were too short to judge IMO, and I didnt care for any of Chayce's songs. 

Edited May 17, 2021 by m1key

[sublymonal]

Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)

Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

Casey Bishop - "Love Me, Leave Me" (Casey Bishop)

Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

 

[Elliott]

Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)

Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

Casey Bishop – “Love Me, Leave Me” (Casey Bishop)

Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

[wgm]

Round 1:

1. Grace

2. Willie 

3. Chayce

4. Casey

round 2:

1. Grace 

2. Chayce 

3. Willie 

4. Casey

[Daillon]

Personal Idol

1. Willie

2. Casey

3. Grace

4. Chayce

 

Reprises

1. Casey

2. Grace

3. Willie

4. Chayce

 

Didn’t care for any of the originals.

Edited May 17, 2021 by Daillon

[redwood79]

1. Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

2. Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

 

3. Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

4. Casey Bishop – “Love Me, Leave Me” (Casey Bishop)

5. Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

6. Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)

 

7. Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

8. Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

9. Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

10. Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

11. Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

12. Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

13. Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

14. Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

[iloveadam]

 

4/10 Chayce Beckham – “Colder Weather” (Zac Brown Band)

4/10 Casey Bishop – “wish you were gay” (Billie Eilish)

3/10 Grace Kinstler – “A Moment Like This” (Kelly Clarkson)

8/10 Willie Spence – “Glory” (John Legend & Common)

6/10 Chayce Beckham – “23” (Chayce Beckham)

5/10 Chayce Beckham - “Wish You Would Leave” (Chris Stapleton)

5/10 Casey Bishop – “Love Me, Leave Me” (Casey Bishop)

6/10 Casey Bishop - “Live Wire” (Mötley Crüe)

6/10 Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence w Finneas – “What They’ll Say About Us” (Finneas)
5/10 Grace Kinstler – “Love Someone” (Grace Kinstler)

7/10 Grace Kinstler - “Father” (Demi Lovato)

7/10 Willie Spence – “Never Be Alone” (Willie Spence)

6/10 Willie Spence - “I Was Here” (Beyoncé)

9/10 Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham – “Break My Heart Again” (Finneas)

 

 

Willie slayed the night and Casey and Chayce should have done BMHA solo srsly. The duet is fantastic, such a great song.

Edited May 17, 2021 by iloveadam

[*Wallace]

Top 4 Solo Performances:

1. Grace Kinstler - Father
2. Willie Spence - Glory
3. Casey Bishop - Live Wire
4. Willie Spence - I Was Here
5. Grace Kinstler - Love Someone
6. Willie Spence - Never Be Alone
7. Grace Kinstler - A Moment Like This
8. Casey Bishop - wish you were gay
9. Chayce Beckham - 23
10. Casey Bishop - Love Me Leave Me
11. Chayce Beckham - You Should Probably Leave
12. Chayce Beckham - Colder Weather

 

Duets

1. Grace Kinstler & Willie Spence - What They’ll Say About Us
2. Casey Bishop & Chayce Beckham - Break My Heart Again