If Grace wins, ABC Idol’s first 4 seasons parallel Fox’s first 4 seasons?

[countrynineteen]

This may not age well after tonight, but if Grace wins, the first 4 season winners would be comparable to the first 4 of Fox Idol. Here is why:

 

Season 1: Kelly/Maddie: The girl next door, consistent throughout the competition, not as pimped in the early rounds but becomes the obvious frontrunner later. Both 20 when they won.

 

Season 2: Ruben/Laine: Yeah this one is probably stretching it because these two could not be more different. I guess the big similarities is they were the first male winners of their respective networks and the first all male F2s. Their respective runner-ups (Clay/Alejandro) had hardcore fans, and were seen as “robbed.”

 

Season 3: Fantasia/Just Sam: “Rags to riches” type R&B singer. Both had the inspiring story with the big ol’ voice. 
 

Season 4: Carrie/Grace????: Remains to be seen, but if she wins I think she could be somewhat compared to Carrie. Different genres, but both blonde girls with powerful voices. Also both with the “girl next door” vibe. 
 

What do you think? Don’t be too mean.

Edited May 16, 2021 by countrynineteen

[MargoK]

43 minutes ago, countrynineteen said:

This may not age well after tonight, but if Grace wins, the first 4 season winners would be comparable to the first 4 of Fox Idol. Here is why:

 

Season 1: Kelly/Maddie: The girl next door, consistent throughout the competition, not as pimped in the early rounds but becomes the obvious frontrunner later. Both 20 when they won.

 

Season 2: Ruben/Laine: Yeah this one is probably stretching it because these two could not be more different. I guess the big similarities is they were the first male winners of their respective networks and the first all male F2s. Their respective runner-ups (Clay/Alejandro) had hardcore fans, and were seen as “robbed.”

 

Season 3: Fantasia/Just Sam: “Rags to riches” type R&B singer. Both had the inspiring story with the big ol’ voice. 
 

Season 4: Carrie/Grace????: Remains to be seen, but if she wins I think she could be somewhat compared to Carrie. Different genres, but both blonde girls with powerful voices. Also both with the “girl next door” vibe. 
 

What do you think? Don’t be too mean.

I want Grace to win but what if Casey wins?

[miss denise]

Interesting comparisons.  

 

Putting those vibes out into the universe for Grace.