Rank the Top 12

[Shasta357]

This is a hard one because overall I think it is a strong Top 12 but some of my favorites during Hollywood kinda faltered in top 24.. but then did great again last night. Be consistent fools. 

 

Love

1. Grace

2. Beane

3. Hunter

4. Ava

5. Casey

 

Really Like

6. Cassandra

7. Willie

8. Chayce

9. Madison

 

Like but inconsistent/boring

10. Alyssa (Girl dropped a lot of spots this week. TGLOA was terrible imo..)

11. Caleb

12. Deshawn

[CrystalXx]

1. Casey

2. DeShawn

3. Willie

4. Beane

5. Hunter

6. Grace

7. Madison

8. Ava

9. Cassandra

10. Chayce

11. Alyssa

12. Caleb

[iloveadam]

1.  Casey

2. Ava

3. Grace

4. Chayce

5. Beane

6. Hunter

7. Alyssa

8. Cassandra

9. Caleb

10. Madison

11. DeShawn

12. Willie

 

 

[Yvette5151]

Casey Bishop 

[aaronjudge]

casey

[Guest]

Grace / Chayce / Chayce 

[Angeles]

Love

• Cassandra  - She's inconsistent, but her tone is gorgeous 
• Casey 
• Hunter 
• Grace
• Madison - She surprised me & I'm so glad she made it through.  

Enjoyable

• Ava 
• Beane 
• DeShawn 
• Willie 

Meh

• Alyssa
• Chayce
• Caleb 

[Bk1234]

1. Madison Watkins (probably out next week, but girl has been slaying!!!) 

2. Grace Kinstler (consistent, but she needs to have another moment like she did with “Father.”)

3. Hunter Metts (never got the hype before, but he’s been slaying some of my favorite songs.) 

4. Casey Bishop (pretty overrated on here imo, but she’s still good.) 

5. Alyssa Wray (inconsistent, but her good performances have been really good.)

6. Cassandra Coleman (I feel like I’ve been too critical with her performances, love her tone.) 

7. Willie Spence (consistent, but a little boring.) 

8. Caleb Kennedy (underrated on here, love his rasp and originals.) 

9. Beane (never got the hype till his wildcard performance, he needs to work on song choice and genre identity.) 

10. DeShawn Gonclaves (good singer, but doesn’t really stand out.) 
11. Ava August (cool tone, but I haven’t been loving her performances.)

12. Chayce Beckham ()

[Someone648]

Personally, I enjoy this top 12 a lotmore than last year although there's a lot of middle tier for me.

 

My winner:

1. Cassandra Coleman - TONE.

-

Good:

2. Hunter Metts

3. Chayce Beckham

4. Casey Bishop

5. Madison Watkins

6. Grace Kinstler

7. Willie Spence

-

I used to like them more but they slipped through the cracks for me and I don't particularly care anymore:

8. Ava August

9. Alyssa Wray

10. DeShawn Goncalves

11. Beane

-

I genuinely forgot this man existed:

12. Caleb Kennedy

 

[CarmenSandiego]

1.  Willie — the front runner so far!

2.  Ava — my new favorite.

3.  Casey — the most likely to dethrone Willie.

4.  Alyssa — I still love her but her song choices are hurting her.

5.  Grace — she’s a fine singer but she’s doing too many pop songs that don’t totally suit her.

6.  Hunter — he’s improving since the Top 24.

7.  Madison — she’s able to put on a show if she needs to.

8.  Cassandra — I still think that she’s very good but her nerves are destroying her chances of winning.

9.  Beane — he’s good but not really great.

10.  DeShawn — he’s cannon fodder, sad to say.

11.  Chayce — sorry, Chayce fans, but I just don’t like his voice.

12.  Caleb — weakest singer.

[Stacey.]

1. Hunter Metts

2. Ava August

3. Grace Kinstler

4. Casey Bishop

5. Cassandra Coleman

6. Willie Spence

7. Caleb Kennedy

8. DeShawn Goncalves

9. Beane

10. Madison Watkins

11. Chayce Beckham

12. Alyssa Wray

God this top 12 is absolutely tragic overall lmao. It had so much potential as well