Rank the Performances - S19, Top 24 (Group A)

[Elliott]

Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia)

Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradey Cooper & Lady Gaga)

Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie)

Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic)

Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood)

Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston)

Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae)

Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector)

Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa)

Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight)

Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish)

Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan)

DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan)

DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic)

Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff)

Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector)

Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia)

Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael)

Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence)

Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley)

Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler)

Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Cèline Dion)

Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J)

Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips

[ShortstopVM]

Solos:

 

1. Willie

2. Alyssa

3. Grace

4. Deshawn

5. Andrea

6. Anilee

7. Alanis

8. Wyatt

9. Cassandra

10. Graham

11. Alana

12. Cecil

 

Duets:

 

1. Willie

2. Grace

3. Alyssa

4. Deshawn

5. Wyatt

6. Cassandra

 

7. Andrea

8. Graham

9. Anilee

10. Alana

11. Alanis

 

 

12. Cecil

 

Overall:

1. Willie

2. Grace

3. Alyssa

4. Deshawn

5. Andrea

6. Wyatt

7. Cassandra

8. Anilee

9. Alanis

10. Graham

11. Alana

12. Cecil

 

EDIT: I like Alanis, but she pretty much got outsung by most everyone else, especially in the duets

Edited April 5, 2021 by ShortstopVM

[ScarletDevilCCX]

1a. Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J)

1b. Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips

3. Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael)

4. Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia)

5. Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa)

6. DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan)

7. Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight)

8. Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish)

9. Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston)

10. DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic)

11. Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff)

12. Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector)

13. Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae)

14. Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler)

15. Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Cèline Dion)

16. Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood)
17. Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie)

18. Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradey Cooper & Lady Gaga)

19. Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley)

20. Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic)

21. Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia)

22. Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence)

23. Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector)
24. Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan)

[taylorkat]

1. Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips
2. Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Celine Dion)
3. Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler)
4. Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J)
5. Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan)
6. Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish)
7. Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood)
8. Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston)
9. DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan)
10. DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic)
11. Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia)
12. Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael)
13. Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie)
14. Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic)
15. Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradley Cooper & Lady Gaga)
16. Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia)
17. Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight) 
18. Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa)
19. Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector)
20. Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae)
21. Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff)
22. Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector)
23. Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence)  
24. Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley)  

[*Wallace]

I can’t rank duets and solo performances together so I’ll do them separately. 

 

Solos:

1. Grace - Queen

2. Alanis - Alive

3. Willie - Wind Beneath My Wings

4. Alyssa - Something in the Water

5. Anilee - my future

6. Alana - Blow Your Mind (Mwah)

7. DeShawn - Forever Young

8. Andrea - La Vos A Olvidar

9. Cassandra - Find Me

10. Wyatt - rubberband

11. Graham - Raye

12. Cecil - Paint Me a Birmingham

 

Duets:

1. Grace & Joss Stone - Midnight Train to Georgia

2. Willie & Katharine  McPhee - The Prayer

3. Alyssa & Katharine McPhee - I’m Your Baby, Tonight

4. Cassandra & Ryan Tedder - Apologize

5. Andrea & Brian McKnight - Careless Whisper

6. Alanis & Jimmie Allen - Shallow

7. DeShawn & Ryan Tedder - I Lived

8. Anilee & Joss Stone - Tell Me Something Good

9. Wyatt & Ben Rector - Brand New

10. Alana & Brian McKnight - Back at One

11. Graham & Ben Rector - Love Like This

12. Cecil & Jimmie Allen - Freedom Was a Highway

[hayden98]

Solos

1.) Anilee

2.) Grace

3.) Cassandra

4.) Alana

5.) Wyatt

6.) Andrea

7.) Willie

8.) Alanis

9.) Alyssa

10.) Deshawn

11.) Graham

12.) Cecil

 

Duets

1.) Grace

2.) Anilee

3.) Alana

4.) Alyssa

5.) Willie

6.) Andrea

7.) Alanis

8.) Cassandra

9.) Wyatt

10.) Deshawn

11.) Graham

12.) Cecil

[wgm]

Solo's:

1. Grace 

2. Willie 

3. Cassandra 

4. Alyssa 

5. Graham

6. DeShawn

7. Wyatt 

8. Alana 

9. Alanis 

10. Andrea 

11. Anilee

12. Cecil 

 

Duets:

1. Grace and Joss Stone

2. Alyssa and Kat McPhee

3. Willie and Kat

4. Cassandra and Ryan Tedder

5. Wyatt and Ben Rector 

6. Graham and Ben Rector

7. Andrea and Bryan Mcknight

8.  Deshawn and ryan tedder

9. Alana and Brian McKnight

10. Cecil and Jimmie Allen

11. Alanis and Jimmie Allen

12. Anilee and Joss Stone

[Daillon]

I'll only rank the solos:

 

1. Andrea (I didn't even remember who she was but dang she killed it)

2. Grace

3. Anilee

4. Willie

5. Alyssa

6. Wyatt

7. Cassandra (from a vocal standpoint she was one of the worst but #bias)

8. Alana

9. Graham

10. DeShawn

11. Alanis

12. Cecil

Edited April 5, 2021 by Daillon

[redwood79]

Solos

Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia)

Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia)

Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa)

Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae)

Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff)

Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish)

Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J)

Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie)

Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood)

Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler)

DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan)

Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence)

 

 

Duets

Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector)

Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael)

Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Cèline Dion)

Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector)

Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic)

Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradey Cooper & Lady Gaga)

Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan)

Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips

Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston)

Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight)

Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley)

DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic)

Edited April 5, 2021 by redwood79

[jazzontherocks]

Solos

Alanis

Wyatt

Willie

Grace

Cassandra

Alyssa

Anilee

Deshawn

Graham

Andrea

Alana

Cecil Ray

 

Duets

Alanis

Grace

Willie

Wyatt

Cassandra

Alyssa

Anilee

Graham

Alana

Deshawn

Andrea

Cecil Ray

[jjeem]

My favorites from last night:

 

Alanis - i love her voice, clean and crisp, she sounds like a pro, but she will probably be eliminated after performing first - NOT SAFE

Willie - he sounds soothing and strong at the same time, needs some work on stage presence, his voice is the best among the guys - SAFE

Wyatt - I like his awkwardness on stage, he might have to work on that though. But his voice is clean and on pitch - NOT SAFE

Grace - big strong voice, thankfully she has more control of it this time - SAFE

 

i really honestly don't remember the rest

 

 

 

 

Edited April 5, 2021 by jjeem

[sublymonal]

Solos:

1. Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia) - A-

2. Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae) - A-

3. Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia) - A-

4. Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa) - B+

5. Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish) - B

6. Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie) - B-

7. Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J) - B-

8. Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff) - B-

9. DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan) - C

10. Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler) - C

11. Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood) - D

12. Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence) - F

 

Duets:

1. Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan) - A-

4. Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips - A-

5. Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradey Cooper & Lady Gaga) - A-

3. Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector) - A-

2. Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector) - B+

6. Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Cèline Dion) - B

7. Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael) - B-

8. Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley - B-

9. Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston) - C+

10. Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic) - C

11. DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic) - C-

12. Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight) - D

Edited April 5, 2021 by sublymonal

[Weedy_Speedy]

Too many performances to rank, but I thought Alanis, Andrea, Willie and Grace were the best.

[Bonga]

1 hour ago, jjeem said:

My favorites from last night:

 

Alanis - i love her voice, clean and crisp, she sounds like a pro, but she will probably be eliminated after performing first - NOT SAFE

Willie - he sounds soothing and strong at the same time, needs some work on stage presence, his voice is the best among the guys - SAFE

Wyatt - I like his awkwardness on stage, he might have to work on that though. But his voice is clean and on pitch - NOT SAFE

Grace - big strong voice, thankfully she has more control of it this time - SAFE

 

i really honestly don't remember the rest

 

 

 

 

All of them are locks to go through  

Edited April 5, 2021 by Bonga

[CarmenSandiego]

I’ll rank solos and duets together since I’m watching both on YouTube:

 

1.  Willie & Katherine:  his song choice might be overdone but he sang it well.  And his duet was great too.
2.  Alyssa & Katherine — the first singer to not be overshadowed by her duet partner.  Great job.
3.  Grace & Joss — I wasn’t so fond of her solo although she sang it well but I loved her duet.
4.  Andrea & Brian — her best performance yet.  I really hope that it’s good enough for her to move on.
5.  Anilee & Joss — really powerful solo and she managed to hold her own with Joss, at least performance-wise.
6.  Cassandra & Ryan — Cassandra shone on her solo but I believe that Ryan outshone her, maybe on purpose.
7.  Wyatt & Ben — I prefer Alanis but I believe that Wyatt was better.
8.  Alanis & Jimmie — she did fine in her solo but I think that nerves got the best of her in her duet.
9.  Alana & Brian — loved her duet song but her solo song was more of a performer’s song.
10.  Graham & Ben — pleasant but somewhat forgettable
11.  DeShawn & Ryan — he’s got a powerful voice but he was outshone by Ryan in the duet as well.
12.  Cecil & Jimmie:  as I said earlier, this was a train wreck.  There’s no way that Cecil’s moving on.

[iloveadam]

6/10 Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia)

6/10 Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradey Cooper & Lady Gaga)

6/10 Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie)

6/10 Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic)

7/10 Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood)

6/10 Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston)

7/10 Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae)

7/10 Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector)

5/10 Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa)

5/10 Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight) -

7/10 Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish)

6/10 Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan)

5/10 DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan)

5/10 DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic)

5/10 Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff)

5/10 Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector)

6/10 Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia)

5/10 Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael)

1/10 Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence)

4/10 Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley)

5/10 Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler)

5/10 Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Cèline Dion)

6/10 Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J)

6/10 Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips

 

[Elliott]

Solos:

Wyatt Pike - “rubberband” (Tate McRae)
Willie Spence - “Wind Beneath My Wings” (Bette Midler)
Andrea Valles - “La Vos A Olvidar” (Billie Eilish & Rosalia)
Alana - “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” (Dua Lipa)
Anilee List - “my future” (Billie Eilish)
Alanis Sophia - “Alive” (Sia)
Grace Kinstler - “Queen” (Jessie J)
Graham DeFranco - “Raye” (John Splithoff)
Cassandra Coleman - “Find Me” (Sigma feat. Birdie)
DeShawn Goncalves - “Forever Young” (Bob Dylan)
Alyssa Wray - “Something in the Water” (Carrie Underwood)
Cecil Ray - “Paint Me a Birmingham” (Tracy Lawrence)

 

Duets:

Anilee List & Joss Stone - “Tell Me Something Good” (Rufus & Chaka Khan)
Grace Kinstler & Joss Stone - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight & The Pips
Wyatt Pike & Ben Rector - “Brand New” (Ben Rector)
Willie Spence - “The Prayer” (Andrea Bocelli & Cèline Dion)
Alanis Sophia & Jimmie Allen - “Shallow” (Bradey Cooper & Lady Gaga)
Alana & Brian McKnight - “Back at One” (Brian McKnight)
Andrea Valles & Brian McKnight - “Careless Whisper” (George Michael)
Cassandra Coleman & Ryan Tedder - “Apologize” (OneRepublic)
DeShawn Goncalves & Ryan Tedder - “I Lived” (OneRepublic)
Cecil Ray & Jimmie Allen - “Freedom Was a Highway” (Jimmie Allen & Brad Paisley)
Alyssa Wray & Katharine McPhee - “I’m Your Baby Tonight” (Whitney Houston)
Graham DeFranco & Ben Rector - “Love Like This” (Ben Rector)

 

[Niki]

Finally just saw these episodes!

 

solos:

 

1. Alanis

2. Wyatt 

3. Alyssa 

4. Anilee

5. Willie 

6. Cassandra 

7. Grace

8. Alana

9. Cecil (like him but he was off  )

10. DeShawn

11. Graham 

12. Andrea 

 

Duets:

 

1. Cassandra & Ryan Tedder

2. Wyatt & Ben Rector

3. Alanis & Jimmie Allen

4. Grace & Joss Stone

5. Alyssa & Katharine McPhee

6. Alana & Brian McKnight

7. Anilee & Joss Stone

8. Willie & Katharine McPhee

9. DeShawn & Ryan Tedder 

10. Graham & Ben Rector

11. Cecil & Jimmie Allen

12. Andrea & Brian McKnight