Jump to content

Best Performance Every Season


FloorWax

Recommended Posts

On 7/23/2021 at 2:53 PM, rp3598 said:

3: Dream On - Amanda Brown

4: Heads Carolina, Tails California - Danielle Bradberry

5: I Put a Spell on You - Jacquie Lee / Cosmic Love - Matthew Schuler

6: Hold On We’re Going Home - Christina Grimmie

7: The Blower’s Daughter - Matt McAndrew

8: House of the Rising Sun - Kimberly Nichole

9: Somebody to Love - Jordan Smith / Girls Just Wanna Have Fun - Madi Davis / We Don’t Have to Take Our Clothes Off - Ellie Lawrence

10: Listen - Shalyah Fearing

11: Did I Ever Love You - Ali Caldwell

12: If I Were Your Woman - Vanessa Ferguson / Deja Vu - Lauren Duski

13: She Used to be Mine - Addison Agen

14: Here Comes Goodbye - Brynn Cartelli

15: Break Every Chain - Kymberli Joye / Space Cowboy - Chevel Shepherd

16: The Scientist - Maelyn Jarmon

17: when the party’s over - Max Boyle

18: How Will I Know - Allegra Miles and Michael Williams

19: Skinny Love - Cami Clune / Don’t Let Go (Love) - DeSz

20: pov - Ryleigh Modig and Gean Garcia / Already Gone - Corey Ward / Foolish Games - Rachel Mac

21: Wichita Lineman - Girl Named Tom

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/2/2021 at 12:11 PM, VoiceFan! said:

I have weird taste but bear with me

I’m only doing S14-S20 because that’s when I really focused when watching

S20: So far, Ryleigh vs Gean “pov”

S19: Desz “Don’t Let Go”

HM: Ryan Gallagher “The Prayer”, Cami Clune “Never Tear Us Apart”, Payge vs Lauren “If the World Was Ending”, Carter “You Say”, Carter “Rainbow Connection”

S18: Allegra vs Michael “How Will I Know”

HM: Micah “Your Song”, CammWess “Rainbow”, Thunderstorm “Blackbird”

S17: Max Boyle “when the party’s over”

HM: Katie Kaden “Without You”, Rose “God’s Country”, Rose “IWTKWLI”

S16: Beth vs Jej “Jealous”

HM: Maelyn “The Scientist”, Maelyn “Mad World”, Rod and Maelyn “Yesterday”, Rod “When a Man Loves a Woman”

S15: Sandyredd “River”

HM: Chevel Shepard “Blue”, All Mackenzie Thomas Performancws

S14: DR vs Jackie “Sign of the Times”

HM: Kyla Jade “Let it Be”

update

S21 - Wendy Moten "Ain't No Way" & OTR

also all GNT performances

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Discovolcano said:

Favorite performance each season since season 17

 

17

Katie Kaden- Always remember us this way 

 

18

Megan Danielle- Anyone

 

19

John Holiday- Fix You

 

20

Raine Stern- Electric Feel

 

21

Joshua Vacanti- Ashes

These are new

 

Personally I liked Megan's "Piece by Piece" and John H's "All by Myself" more

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...

Looking back at old threads and realized my list was pretty trash so i'm doing this again 😁

 

S1: Dia Frampton- "Heartless"

S2: Juliet Simms- "Oh Darling"

S3: Amanda Brown- "Dream On"

S4: Sasha Allen- "Alone"

S5: Jacquie Lee- "I Put A Spell On You"

S6: "Sisaundra Lewis "New York State of Mind" or "Ain't No Way"

S7: idk lmao

S8: Koryn Hawthorne- "Make It Rain" 

S9: Madi Davis- "A Case Of You"

S10: Hannah Huston- Every Breath You Take"

S11: Ali Caldwell- "No Ordinary Love"

S12: Lilli Passero- "A Love of My Own"

S13: Chloe Kohanski- "Landslide" or "Total Eclipse of the Heart"

S14: Kyla Jade- "You Don't Own Me"

S15: Kymberli Joye- "Break Every Chain"

S16: Maelyn Jarmon- "Mad World"

S17: Katie Kadan- "I'm Going Down"

S18: Megan Danielle "Piece by Piece"

S19: Cami Clune- "Skinny Love"

S20: Anna Grace- "If I Die Young"

S21: Wendy Moten- "Over the Rainbow"

S22: Kim Cruse- "Summertime"

S23: Kala Banham "My Funny Valentine"/Gina Miles "Wicked Game"

Edited by erik g
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/3/2021 at 8:48 AM, Gustavo527 said:

It took me a while, but i came to the conclusion that, for me, not always but in most of the cases, a great performance is a one that manages to move me more than a one that impress me with great vocals (that two things doesn't neccesarily exclude each other, btw). So here is my list:

 

S20: Cam Anthony - Stand Up

S19: Carter Rubin - Rainbow Connection 

S18: Thunderstorm Artis - Home 

S17: Rose Short - I Want To Know What Love It Is 

S16: Maelyn Jarmon - The Scientist 

S15: MacKenzie Thomas - Because You Loved Me 

S14: Brynn Cartelli - Fix You 

S13: Addison Agen - Both Sides Now 

S12: Lauren Duski - Ghost In This House 

S11: Billy Gilman - Anyway 

S10: Alisan Porter - Let Him Fly 

S9: Jeffery Austin - Believe 

S8: Sawyer Fredericks - A Thousand Years

S7: Matt McAndrew - The Blower's Daughter 

S6: Christina Grimmie - How To Love

S5: Tessanne Chin - Bridge Over Troubled Water 

S4: Amber Carrington - Sad (This was the easier one to pick, for real) 

S3: Cassadee Pope - Stupid Boy 

 

Note: i picked only live performances because it doesn't feel right for me to compare a performance in a pre-taped round with a performance in a live round

 

 

 

 

 

I know there are stronger performances, but i stand with my picks, this is how i felt at the moment and i don't care if my list is not "IDF friendly" enough  

 

Adding an Instant Save performance to my list 

S21: Hailey Mia - Jar of Hearts 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/24/2021 at 1:50 PM, Misirlou said:

Alright, this is from what I remember:

 

S5: Matthew Schuler - Cosmic Love

S6: Josh Kaufman - Stay with Me

S7: Matt McAndrew - The Blower´s Daughter

S8: Sawyer Fredericks - Man of Constant Sorrow

S9: Jordan Smith - Somebody to Love

S10: Laith Al Saadi - White Room

S11: Ali Caldwell - Did I Ever Love You

S12: Chris Blue - Rhythm Nation

S13: Chloe MK - Total Eclipse of the Heart (Noah Mac´s River comes a close second)

S14: Kyla Jade - One Night Only (DR and Jackie´s Sign of the Times comes a close second)

S15: Michael Lee - Whipping Post 

S16: Maelyn Jarmon - Mad World

S17: Ricky Duran - Let it Be

S18: Thunderstorm Artis - Blackbird

S19: Sid Kingsley - Make it Rain

S20: Cam Anthony - It´s So Hard To Say Goodbye to Yesterday

 

Updating it with S21: Girl Named Tom - Wichita Lineman

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Gustavo527 said:

I know there are stronger performances, but i stand with my picks, this is how i felt at the moment and i don't care if my list is not "IDF friendly" enough  

 

Adding an Instant Save performance to my list 

S21: Hailey Mia - Jar of Hearts 

 

Looks pretty IDF friendly to me :haha: It's not like you have Sugar Joans or Hello Sunday up there :dead:

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

I'm gonna only count the lives.

S1: Dia Frampton - Heartless
S2: Juliet Simms - Roxanne
S3: Amanda Brown - Dream On
S4: Amber Carrington - Sad
S5: Tessanne Chin - BOTW
S6: Christina Grimmie - HOWGH
S7: Chris Jamison - WIWYM
S8: Kimberly Nichole - HOTRS
S9: Jordan Smith - Somebody To Love :wub:
S10: Alisan Porter - Let Him Fly
S11: Ali Caldwell - Sledgehammer :wub:
S12: Hunter Plake - All I Want
S13: Chloe Kohanski - TEOTH
S14: Kyla Jade - One Night Only:wub:
S15: MaKenzie Thomas - I Believe In You And Me
S16: Maelyn Jarmon - The Scientist:wub:
S17: Rose Short - God's Country:wub:
S18: Toneisha Harris - Lovin' You
S19: Desz - Don't Let Go (Love)
S20: Cam Anthony - Stand Up
S21: Wendy Moten - Over The Rainbow :wub:
S22: Parijita Bastola - I'll Never Love Again (so far, I will change later if I see more lives on this show)

Edited by Ottoxxx
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
On 7/29/2022 at 1:15 PM, erik g said:

Looking back at old threads and realized my list was pretty trash so i'm doing this again 😁

 

S1: Dia Frampton- "Heartless"

S2: Juliet Simms- "Oh Darling"

S3: Amanda Brown- "Dream On"

S4: Sasha Allen- "Alone"

S5: Jacquie Lee- "I Put A Spell On You"

S6: "Sisaundra Lewis "New York State of Mind" or "Ain't No Way"

S7: idk lmao

S8: Koryn Hawthorne- "Make It Rain" 

S9: Madi Davis- "A Case Of You"

S10: Hannah Huston- Every Breath You Take"

S11: Ali Caldwell- "No Ordinary Love"

S12: Lilli Passero- "A Love of My Own"

S13: Chloe Kohanski- "Landslide" or "Total Eclipse of the Heart"

S14: Kyla Jade- "You Don't Own Me"

S15: Kymberli Joye- "Break Every Chain"

S16: Maelyn Jarmon- "Mad World"

S17: Katie Kadan- "I'm Going Down"

S18: Megan Danielle "Piece by Piece"

S19: Cami Clune- "Skinny Love"

S20: Anna Grace- "If I Die Young"

S21: Wendy Moten- "Over the Rainbow"

S22: Kim Cruse- "Summertime"

Added S22: Kim Cruse- "Summertime"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Haven't done this before so let me take a stab:

 

S1: Frenchie - When Love Takes Over

S2: Juliet Simms - Man's Man's Man's World / Jamar Rogers - It's My Life

S3: Amanda Brown - Dream On

S4: Michelle Chamuel - Why

S5: Jacquie Lee - I Put a Spell on You

S6: Josh Kaufman - Stay With Me

S7: Chris Jamison - WIWYM

S8: Koryn - Make It Rain / Kimberly - What's Up

S9: Jeffery Austin - Dancing On My Own

S10: Alisan - Stone Cold

S11: Wé - Feeling Good

S12: Hunter Plake - Higher Love

S13: Janice - The Story / Addison - A Case Of You
S14: Britton - WLGTDWI

S15: Kennedy - Confident

S16: Shawn Sounds - A Song For You

S17: Katie Kadan - I'm Goin Down

S18: Idk, probably something by Thunderstorm or maybe CammWess - Say Something

S19: DeSz - Don't Let Go

S20: Pia - What the World Needs Now
S21: Jershika - Rolling in the Deep

S22: Morgan Myles - Tennessee Whiskey

 

Those are my personal favorites, like other people I acknowledge there's "better" ones in many cases but those are my choices

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Carebear1999 said:

I’m disappointed that no one said Wendy Moten’s performance of “You’re All I Need To Get By” easily the best performance in 3 seasons (20, 21, and 22) 

Not that its objectively more impressive from a vocal standpoint. But I think I prefer it over her finale. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, Carebear1999 said:

I’m disappointed that no one said Wendy Moten’s performance of “You’re All I Need To Get By” easily the best performance in 3 seasons (20, 21, and 22) 

 

It's definitely up there. I personally preferred GNT but she got my attention with that one when I wasn't so convinced of her in previous weeks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 11/20/2022 at 5:50 PM, Ottoxxx said:

I'm gonna only count the lives.

S1: Dia Frampton - Heartless
S2: Juliet Simms - Roxanne
S3: Amanda Brown - Dream On
S4: Amber Carrington - Sad
S5: Tessanne Chin - BOTW
S6: Christina Grimmie - HOWGH
S7: Chris Jamison - WIWYM
S8: Kimberly Nichole - HOTRS
S9: Jordan Smith - Somebody To Love :wub:
S10: Alisan Porter - Let Him Fly
S11: Ali Caldwell - Sledgehammer :wub:
S12: Hunter Plake - All I Want
S13: Chloe Kohanski - TEOTH
S14: Kyla Jade - One Night Only:wub:
S15: MaKenzie Thomas - I Believe In You And Me
S16: Maelyn Jarmon - The Scientist:wub:
S17: Rose Short - God's Country:wub:
S18: Toneisha Harris - Lovin' You
S19: Desz - Don't Let Go (Love)
S20: Cam Anthony - Stand Up
S21: Wendy Moten - Over The Rainbow :wub:
S22: Parijita Bastola - I'll Never Love Again (so far, I will change later if I see more lives on this show)

Ok S22 changed, either Morgan's ARUTH or Omar's STL/ITNOL

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 months later...

Last time I made my list, I based it on who was technically better. This time I'm gonna name my sentimental favs or you can say, those performances that I just like the most..

 

1. Javier Colon - Angel

 

2. Juliet Simms - Roxanne 

 

3. Cassadee Pope - Over You

 

4. Amber Carrington - Sad

 

5. Tessanne Chin - Brigde Over Troubled Water

 

6. Christina Grimmie - Can't Help Falling In Love

 

7. Craig Wayne Boyd - I Walk The Line

 

8. Sawyer Fredericks - Old Man

 

9. Jordan Smith - Somebody To Love

 

10. Adam Wakefield - Love Has No Pride

 

11. Wé McDonald - No More Drama

 

12. Chris Blue - Superstition

 

13. Chloe MK / Kohanski - Landslide

 

14. Kyla Jade - You Don't Own Me

 

15. Reagan Strange vs. Emily Hough - Photograph

 

16. Maelyn - Hallelujah 

 

17. Kyndal Inskeep - Elastic Heart

 

18. Todd Tilghman - I Can Only Imagine

 

19. Cami Clune - Never Tear Us Apart

 

20. Rachel Mac - Rainbow

 

21. Lana Scott - Wildest Dreams

 

So many great performances this season. GNT's KO and Top 13 are really close. Hailey's BA and IS are close as well. And of course Wendy's BA and Finale performance too. Also, I forgot to mention, but I like Lana's performance more than Taylor's.

 

 

22. Omar Cardona - IWKWLI & Morgan Myles - ARUTW.

 

Omar mentioned that this was his fav moment on the show. IWKWLI will always have a special place in my heart. That's the performance that took his insta followers from 15k to 35k. This was the first time when he had the most likes on insta out of all the contestants. This was his best received performance on FB. Not mention that he closed the night with it. This made him a contender for the finale.

 

Morgan also mentioned that this was her fav performance. She sang this for her cousin, whom she lost a few years ago. She was so emotional during the performance, and at the same time, very strong vocally as well. Perfect song choice.

 

 

23. Sorelle vs. Manasseh - Someone Like You

 

Thank god this performance exists; otherwise, it would've been impossible for me to choose. All of Sorelle's other performances + I Told You So & Love Is Alive are really really close.

Edited by Hamza Tufail
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/7/2023 at 6:49 PM, nytsch said:

Haven't done this before so let me take a stab:

 

S1: Frenchie - When Love Takes Over

S2: Juliet Simms - Man's Man's Man's World / Jamar Rogers - It's My Life

S3: Amanda Brown - Dream On

S4: Michelle Chamuel - Why

S5: Jacquie Lee - I Put a Spell on You

S6: Josh Kaufman - Stay With Me

S7: Chris Jamison - WIWYM

S8: Koryn - Make It Rain / Kimberly - What's Up

S9: Jeffery Austin - Dancing On My Own

S10: Alisan - Stone Cold

S11: Wé - Feeling Good

S12: Hunter Plake - Higher Love

S13: Janice - The Story / Addison - A Case Of You
S14: Britton - WLGTDWI

S15: Kennedy - Confident

S16: Shawn Sounds - A Song For You

S17: Katie Kadan - I'm Goin Down

S18: Idk, probably something by Thunderstorm or maybe CammWess - Say Something

S19: DeSz - Don't Let Go

S20: Pia - What the World Needs Now
S21: Jershika - Rolling in the Deep

S22: Morgan Myles - Tennessee Whiskey

 

Those are my personal favorites, like other people I acknowledge there's "better" ones in many cases but those are my choices


Ok let’s see (this is actually a more accurate list than I expected)

 

I would only change S11 (probably Sundance’s At Last), S14 (Britton’s The Rising or Kyla’s Let It Be), S16 (Maelyn’s Hallelujah)

 

Maybe Cam’s Stand Up for S20 but I maintain that KO is one of my favorites ever.

 

Idk why I put that for S21 lol if I was choosing Jershika now I would pick either her SF or What is Love, but now I’d probably say GNT - River or Wendy - You’re All I Need

 

Edit: S23 is Gina Miles - Nothing Compares 2 U

Edited by nytsch
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Hamza Tufail said:

Last time I made my list, I based it on who was technically better. This time I'm gonna name my sentimental favs or you can say, those performances that I just like the most..

 

1. Javier Colon - Angel

 

2. Juliet Simms - Roxanne 

 

3. Cassadee Pope - Over You

 

4. Amber Carrington - Sad

 

5. Tessanne Chin - Brigde Over Troubled Water

 

6. Christina Grimmie - Can't Help Falling In Love

 

7. Craig Wayne Boyd - I Walk The Line

 

8. Sawyer Fredericks - Old Man

 

9. Jordan Smith - Somebody To Love

 

10. Adam Wakefield - Love Has No Pride

 

11. Wé McDonald - No More Drama

 

12. Chris Blue - Superstition

 

13. Chloe MK / Kohanski - Landslide

 

14. Kyla Jade - You Don't Own Me

 

15. Reagan Strange - Photograph

 

16. Maelyn - Hallelujah 

 

17. Kyndal Inskeep - Elastic Heart

 

18. Todd Tilghman - I Can Only Imagine

 

19. Cami Clune - Never Tear Us Apart

 

20. Rachel Mac - Rainbow

 

21. Lana Scott - Wildest Dreams

 

So many great performances this season. GNT's KO and Top 13 are really close. Hailey's BA and IS are close as well. And of course Wendy's BA and Finale performance too. Also, I forgot to mention, but I like Lana's performance more than Taylor's.

 

 

22. Omar Cardona - IWKWLI & Morgan Myles - ARUTW.

 

Omar mentioned that this was his fav moment on the show. IWKWLI will always have a special place in my heart. That's the performance that took his insta followers from 15k to 35k. This was the first time when he had the most likes on insta out of all the contestants. This was his best received performance on FB. Not mention that he closed the night with it. This made him a contender for the finale.

 

Morgan also mentioned that this was her fav performance. She sang this for her cousin, whom she lost a few years ago. She was so emotional during the performance, and at the same time, very strong vocally as well. Perfect song choice.

 

 

23. Sorelle vs. Manasseh - Someone Like You

 

Thank god this performance exists; otherwise, it would've been impossible for me to choose. All of Sorelle's other performances + I Told You So & Love Is Alive are really really close.

Great list :yes:

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

only doing 21-23

(doing my fav, not the vocally best)

 

21 - Arcade (Hailey Mia)

22 - I Cant Stand The Rain (Kim Cruse)

23 - Wicked Game (Gina Miles)

 

Honorable Mentions!

 

21 - Anything GNT or Wendy and some of Jershikas

22 - Morgans and some more of Kims

23 - Caits KO and Kalas Playoff and Gina and Kalas battle

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’ll make my updated list now that I’ve somewhat familiarized myself with the older seasons, but I’ll limit my options to live performances to make things more interesting.

 

S1: Javier Colon - Angel

S2: (i still have to watch Juliet’s run)

S3: Cassadee Pope - Over You 

S4: Michelle Chamuel - Why

S5: Tessanne Chin - Redemption Song

S6: Josh Kaufman - All Of Me

S7: Craig Wayne Boyd - I Walk The Line

S8: Sawyer Fredericks - Imagine

S9: Jordan Smith - Somebody To Love

S10: Alisan Porter - Cry Baby

S11: Sundance Head - At Last

S12: Lauren Duski - Deja Vu

S13: Addison Agen - Both Sides Now

S14: Kyla Jade - One Night Only

S15: Kymberli Joye - Break Every Chain

S16: Maelyn Jarmon - The Scientist

S17: Rose Short - God’s Country

S18: Zan Fiskum - Blowin’ In The Wind

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, FloorWax said:

I’ll make my updated list now that I’ve somewhat familiarized myself with the older seasons, but I’ll limit my options to live performances to make things more interesting.

 

S1: Javier Colon - Angel

S2: (i still have to watch Juliet’s run)

S3: Cassadee Pope - Over You 

S4: Michelle Chamuel - Why

S5: Tessanne Chin - Redemption Song

S6: Josh Kaufman - All Of Me

S7: Craig Wayne Boyd - I Walk The Line

S8: Sawyer Fredericks - Imagine

S9: Jordan Smith - Somebody To Love

S10: Alisan Porter - Cry Baby

S11: Sundance Head - At Last

S12: Lauren Duski - Deja Vu

S13: Addison Agen - Both Sides Now

S14: Kyla Jade - One Night Only

S15: Kymberli Joye - Break Every Chain

S16: Maelyn Jarmon - The Scientist

S17: Rose Short - God’s Country

S18: Zan Fiskum - Blowin’ In The Wind

Sawyer's Imagine and Josh's All Of Me are so underrated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/23/2021 at 2:53 PM, rp3598 said:

3: Dream On - Amanda Brown

4: Heads Carolina, Tails California - Danielle Bradberry

5: I Put a Spell on You - Jacquie Lee / Cosmic Love - Matthew Schuler

6: Hold On We’re Going Home - Christina Grimmie

7: The Blower’s Daughter - Matt McAndrew

8: House of the Rising Sun - Kimberly Nichole

9: Somebody to Love - Jordan Smith / Girls Just Wanna Have Fun - Madi Davis / We Don’t Have to Take Our Clothes Off - Ellie Lawrence

10: Listen - Shalyah Fearing

11: Did I Ever Love You - Ali Caldwell

12: If I Were Your Woman - Vanessa Ferguson / Deja Vu - Lauren Duski

13: She Used to be Mine - Addison Agen

14: Here Comes Goodbye - Brynn Cartelli

15: Break Every Chain - Kymberli Joye / Space Cowboy - Chevel Shepherd

16: The Scientist - Maelyn Jarmon

17: when the party’s over - Max Boyle

18: How Will I Know - Allegra Miles and Michael Williams

19: Skinny Love - Cami Clune / Don’t Let Go (Love) - DeSz

20: pov - Ryleigh Modig and Gean Garcia / Already Gone - Corey Ward / Foolish Games - Rachel Mac

21. Wichita Lineman - GNT

22. In the Name of Love - Omar Jose Cardona

23. Mississippi Girl - Holly Brand / Here You Come Again - Grace West

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...