Do u prefer Katy Perry or Jennifer Lopez as judge?

[JONNYSBRO]

Jennifer Lopez was an IDOL judge for five seasons and I loved what she brought to the show. She knew great talent and brought great criticism. Katy Perry is now in fourth season of judging and while she is fun I feel she would sometimes her critiques could be a little more constructive. Since World of Dance is cancelled do u think ABC should bring back Jennifer Lopez? 

[Carrie_On]

I love Katy. Jennifer was good in Seasons 10 & 11 but when she came back for Season 13, I didn’t feel like she really wanted to be there. And the whole “we have to cut to her every ten seconds in the middle of someone performing” got old. 

[Bk1234]

23 minutes ago, JONNYSBRO said:

Katy Perry is now in fourth season of judging and while she is fun I feel she would sometimes her critiques could be a little more constructive.

Have you watched any of the auditions this season? 

[Guest]

Katy easily. 

[iloveadam]

Both are boring, Katy is a tad better. 

 

TV coaches are much more entertaining, it's fun to see them bickering with each others.

[KelseyW]

I like both of them. But Katy more as a whole.

[Angeles]

Both are fine, but I prefer Katy. 

[blackfield]

neither. paula was still better than both. so that tells how bad they are. they don't feel authentic and objective in their criticism. the only thing they care is they are been paid million to be on TV and do nothing. 

 

[Weedy_Speedy]

Katy by a mile, I actually think she's probably the best judge the show has had since Simon left. Just the right amount of constructive with an entertaining television personality. I couldn't stand JLo as an Idol judge and hope she never comes back.

Edited March 18, 2021 by Weedy_Speedy

[1234567890]

[kamil24]

I like both, but will have to go with Katy on this one.

[frederick]

I liked both but Paula was better. I think I prefer Katy.

[redwood79]

Katy

[joe14]

On 3/16/2021 at 6:20 PM, iloveadam said:

Both are boring, Katy is a tad better. 

 

TV coaches are much more entertaining, it's fun to see them bickering with each others.

That's because "The Voice" makes it about the judges which isn't a good thing in my opinion. The show should be about the contestants, not how entertaining the judges are lol.

 

They are both "okay" too me. I think I like Katy better though. They can both give good critiques when they want to. I'll say Katy is more consistent w/ the constructive criticism. You could tell Jen went along with the majority (aka Randy) a lot.