Rank the almost finalists (4th placers that couldn´t make it because of Top 3 format and second highest vote getters on the Semifinals Instant Save)

[Misirlou]

Rank the people that missed the finale. I´m  counting people with the second highest votes in the semifinals IS, , S18 and S19 excluded for obvious reasons, since we don´t know who were the second highest vote getters from those seasons.,. Also, from S3, to S6, I´m including the 4th placers that couldn´t get in the finale due to the Top 3 format. In S7, I´m including TJW as the fifth placer.

[Bk1234]

I think it should be made illegal to have me choose between Amber, India, Ali, Hunter, Noah, MaKenzie, and Kat. 

[David68]

Oh dang, this is a good group.

[Hamza Tufail]

1- Amber Carrington

2- Trevin Hunte

3- Hunter Plake

4- Cole Vosbury 

5- Pryor Baird 

6- Noah Mac

7- Taylor John Williams

 

I like others too but it's so hard for me to rank them so I'll just stop here.

[Dai]

Amber is a clear #1 for me, but the other people who I liked ended up disappointing me for different reasons (India, Hunter, Noah, Ali  ). And then you have some of my least favorite contestants ever (Kat, Zach and Pryor). Overall a really weird group.

[Bk1234]

I ended up voting for King Noah.  

[ungodlyhour]

ali caldwell no competition

[lucie3]

madi should be there instead of zach 

[QueenCami]

woww this is an amazing group

[VintageVoice]

Most-to-Least Finale-Worthy (in order within each tier)

 

Actively Felt Things When They Missed The Finale

• Ali Caldwell
• Noah Mac
• MaKenzie Thomas
• Hunter Plake
• Kristen Merlin
• Amber Carrington

Could've Gone Either Way but Would've Had No Complaints If They Made It

• Cole Vosbury
• Pryor Baird
• India Carney
• Rod Stokes
• Bryan Bautista

Not Quite Ready For The Finale

• Taylor John Williams
• Trevin Hunte
• Kat Hammock
• Zach Seabaugh

 

Edited December 19, 2020 by VintageVoice
Not my flop self forgetting one of the contestants...

[Misirlou]

19 minutes ago, lucie3 said:

madi should be there instead of zach 

If I remember correctly, he got more votes than her on the IS. Mainly young girls  I assume.

[QueenMae16]

Its a tough matchup between Makenzie/Amber/Ali. But Amber had the more outstanding and consistent performances over the other two.

[deszfan88]

MaKenzie, but indya is a close second

[VoiceFan!]

Amber and Mackenzie 

[katybay]

Ali and Noah come to mind..

 

Kristen Merlin has a special place in my heart....her blind was so heartfelt.

[Feder]

MaKenzie and Noah 

[TeamAudra]

23 hours ago, Misirlou said:

Rank the people that missed the finale. I´m  counting people with the second highest votes in the semifinals IS, , S18 and S19 excluded for obvious reasons, since we don´t know who were the second highest vote getters from those seasons.,. Also, from S3, to S6, I´m including the 4th placers that couldn´t get in the finale due to the Top 3 format. In S7, I´m including TJW as the fifth placer.

I think Mary Sarah edged out Bryan Bautista in that instant save vote, if I’m not mistaken. She was probably 4th in votes too, so yeah...she was robbed by the format. Not that it matters much. 

[disney1024]

I wish they showed us the Instant Save graphs in seasons 18 and 19 as they did with previous seasons. I would've loved to see who were the almost finalists for seasons 18 and 19. Season 18 was probably Allegra Miles and season 19 was probably Cami Clune. 

Edited December 20, 2020 by disney1024