Jump to content

Rank the finale performances!


Gmm99
 Share

Recommended Posts

Covers

  1. Desz (Love the song, loved her take on it)
  2. Jim (surprisingly good, just wanted more dynamics)
  3. Carter (age-appropriate but not an original enough choice and his voice sounded thinner than normal on parts)
  4. Ian (loved the song, but it was kinda sleepy)
  5. John (it wasn't bad, it just wasn't great)

Originals

  1. Desz (great fit for her style and voice)
  2. Carter (good fit, but felt too big for him in spots)
  3. Jim (liked the lyrics, but that's about it)
  4. Ian (see Jim)
  5. John (...I'm pretending he wasn't tanked as hard as he was with this)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Covers

1. Desz (Props to her for doing something different. It was solid but somewhat boring)

2. Jim (Considering how weak his live rounds have been, this was a huge improvement)

3. Carter (Meh)

4. Ian (Boring)

5. John (Trainwreck)

 

Originals

1. Desz (Only here for her great second half)

2. Carter (Ok, but pretty boring)

3. Jim (:yawn:)

4. Ian (^^^)

5. John (What the hell was that)

 

Finales are usually mediocre but this one was specially weak imo. None of these were great performances.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Desz was my favorite going into the finale tonight, but her performances were underwhelming. Carter did ok. John Holiday is guaranteed 5th. Jim did pretty well. And it seems to be unpopular here, but I really enjoyed Ian's performances. He was my least favorite going into the finale because I disliked his tone, but I thought his tone sounded gorgeous on his song picks tonight.

 

Cover

1. Jim Ranger

2. Ian Flanigan

3. Carter Rubin

4. Desz (I'm so sorry......)

5. John Holiday

 

Original

1. Ian Flanigan

2. Desz

3. Jim Ramger

4. Carter Rubin

5. John Holiday

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Covers

1. Jim Ranger

2. Ian Flanigan

3. Carter Rubin

4 .Desz

5. John Holiday

 

Originals

1. Ian Flanigan

2. Carter Rubin

3. Desz

4. Jim Ranger

5. John Holiday

 

Had Jim done what he did last night on the past few rounds, he would have a legitimate chance to win. I obviously love Ian´s tone, and last night was a major improvement from his semifinals stumble. Carter had by far his weakest night, but he still did decent. Desz was decent as well, but she didn´t do (or wasn´t allowed to) anything to make her case for winning. John had an all around terrible night, by far the weakest of the T5, and it sucks, because if we´re vocally speaking, he can run circles around all of them in his comfort zone.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

Covers

1. Jim Ranger

2. Ian Flanigan

3. Carter Rubin

4 .Desz

5. John Holiday

 

Originals

1. Ian Flanigan

2. Carter Rubin

3. Desz

4. Jim Ranger

5. John Holiday

 

Had Jim done what he did last night on the past few rounds, he would have a legitimate chance to win. I obviously love Ian´s tone, and last night was a major improvement from his semifinals stumble. Carter had by far his weakest night, but he still did decent. Desz was decent as well, but she didn´t do (or wasn´t allowed to) anything to make her case for winning. John had an all around terrible night, by far the weakest of the T5, and it sucks, because if we´re vocally speaking, he can run circles around all of them in his comfort zone.

We have the exact same ranking for covers! I was surprised no one else had Ian as high as I ranked him on both categories.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, FloorWax said:

We have the exact same ranking for covers! I was surprised no one else had Ian as high as I ranked him on both categories.

It´s either because they already went in to the finale hating him, or fans of the original song, which is a high order. I personally love that song as well, and while Ian obviously didn´t reach the original, he did pretty good with it, especially on an underwhelming night.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Covers:

1. Jim (and I don't usually like that guy)

2. Desz 

3. Ian

4. Carter (i really don't like this song)

5. John 💔

 

Originals:
1. Desz

2. Ian

3. the rest? 

 

My heart wants Desz to win but I think it's gonna be Carter :( .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Covers

1. Jim - With a Little Help From My Friends

2. DeSz - Landslide

3. John - Halo

4. Carter - The Climb

5. Ian - In Color

 

 

Originals

1. Carter - Up From Here

2. Jim - Last

3. DeSz - Holy Ground

4. John - Where Do We Go

5. Ian  - Never Learn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...