Jump to content

Charlie Mason Voice S19 Reviews and Grades


istersay
 Share

Recommended Posts

The Voice Season 19 Premiere Recap: Did Somebody Order Comfort Food? — Plus, Who Inspired This Reaction?

By Charlie Mason / October 19 2020, 7:00 PM PDT

 

Tamara Jade (Team Legend), “Cuz I Love You” — Grade: A 

Lauren Frihauf (Team Gwen), “Come to My Window” — Grade: C+

Joseph Soul (Team Kelly), “Is This Love?” — Grade: C 

Ian Flanigan (Team Blake), “Colder Weather” — Grade: B 

Jim Ranger (Team Blake), “Blue Ain’t Your Color” — Grade: A-

Eli Zamora (Team Kelly), “Yo Lo Se Que Tu Te Vas” — Grade: A

Payge Turner (Team Gwen), “Call Out My Name” — Grade: B+

Marisa Corvo (Team Kelly), “Perfect” — Grade: A

John Holiday (Team Legend), “Misty” — Grade: A+

 

lol don't agree with some of this

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, QueenMae16 said:

Imagine placing Payge below Jim, Marisa, Eli. LOL

personally i think that payge has far more potential then most of those on the premiere, but i think her thin high notes really took away from her otherwise great performance. if she can't use stronger high notes, i would prefer she stick to her extremely impressive lower register.

 

i ranked her near the bottom because there were several solid performances that didn't do anything super impressive, but hit all the notes as they should have. based on her battle, and if she moves on beyond that, her KO, i hope to consider her more of a frontrunner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looking at my own scores:

  • Agreed/nearly agreed (gave within a +/- letter grade): Tamara, Lauren, Ian, Jim, Payge, Marisa
  • Disagreed (bigger than one +/- gap): Joseph, Eli, John

My scores, for reference (with an explanation when my scores were different):

  • Tamara: A-
  • Lauren: C+
  • Joseph: B (I thought his take on the song was pretty and I liked his tone, but it was kinda sleepy even though it was solid otherwise - but nothing technical popped out to me that suggested lowering it beyond a B-)
  • Ian: B- (He was technically solid and interesting tonally, but I'm not a fan of his enunciation/affectations though I could still understand the majority of what he was saying)
  • Jim: B+ (He's tone-wise less interesting than Ian, but still very good and I wouldn't be surprised to see him do well in the competition)
  • Eli: B (A rich tone and seems like there's potential to pack a wallop there, and definitely deserved a second chair turn, but not as strong emotionally for me)
  • Payge: B+
  • Marisa: A- (I'm not sure how much me being a P!nk fan biases me, but I felt like she connected with the message of the song and she has a solid foundation vocally to work with - with some technique refinements she could go from "very good" up to "great" easily)
  • John: B+ (I appreciate that he's a strong vocalist with a lot of training, but I wasn't a big fan of his tone - I do think he's in capable hands with his coach, though)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My take:

 

Payge - A

Jim - B+

Eli - B+

Tamara - B

John - B

Ian - B-

Marisa - C+

Joseph - C+

Lauren - C-

 

Payge was awesome.  Eli surprised.  John is screechy.  Wanted to like Marisa but not enough there.  Lauren was pretty messy.

 

Pretty underwhelming premier...but what else is new?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As of right now Payge has moved to 4th. I think sometimes the standings are different early on and then after like 4 to 5 hours they change significantly but that wasn't the case here the top 3 are still John/Tamara/Jim. I remember here people used to put the poll results too early for s18 and said T-storm is Tvline's fav while their fav was Todd T except for PO and Who will win(after the Finale performances) poll T-storm never beat Todd head to head.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Voice Recap: Which Contestants Inspired 'King Blake' Shelton to Swivel His Throne On Night 2 of the Blinds?
By Charlie Mason / October 20 2020, 7:00 PM PDT

 

Taryn Papa (Team Blake), “Anyway” — Grade: B-

Liam St. John (Team Gwen), “Sex & Candy” — Grade: B 

Aaron Scott (Team Blake), “Hemorrhage (In My Hands)” — Grade: C 

Madeline Consoer (Team Kelly), “Girl” — Grade: B

Cami Clune (Team Legend), “Skinny Love” — Grade: A-

Ryan Gallagher (Team Kelly), “The Prayer” — Grade: A

Chloé Hogan (Team Gwen), “What the World Needs Now” — Grade: B-

Sid Kingsley (Team Legend), “Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright” — Grade: A

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, David68 said:

Currently:

Sid is leading at 37.2%, Ryan right on his heels at 36.12%

Cami has 14.73%

Taryn has 3.87%

Aaron has 2.38%

Liam has 2.08% 

Chloe has 1.93%

Madeline has 1.64%

Glad to see Sid taking the lead he did good here as well. Also he is leading on MjsBigBlog with more than 40%.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Voice Recap: A Night 3 Contestant Turns the Blinds Into Child's Play — Plus, Who Gets 'Stuck With' Gwen?
By Charlie Mason / October 26 2020, 7:00 PM PDT

https://tvline.com/2020/10/26/the-voice-recap-carter-rubin-kelsie-watts-blind-auditions/

 

Rio Souma (Team Legend), “Cruisin’” — Grade: C

 

 

Ryan Berg (Team Gwen), “Waiting On the World to Change” — Grade: C+ 

Jus Jon (Team Blake), “Talk” — Grade: C+ 

Ben Allen (Team Blake), “Red Dirt Road” — Grade: A-

Kelsie Watts (Team Kelly), “I Dare You” — Grade: A

Carter Rubin (Team Gwen), “Before You Go” — Grade: A

Casmé (Team Legend), “Baby I Love You” — Grade: A-

DeSz (Team TBD), “Unbreak My Heart” — Grade: B-

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, istersay said:

The Voice Recap: A Night 3 Contestant Turns the Blinds Into Child's Play — Plus, Who Gets 'Stuck With' Gwen?
By Charlie Mason / October 26 2020, 7:00 PM PDT

https://tvline.com/2020/10/26/the-voice-recap-carter-rubin-kelsie-watts-blind-auditions/

 

Rio Souma (Team Legend), “Cruisin’” — Grade: C

 

 

Ryan Berg (Team Gwen), “Waiting On the World to Change” — Grade: C+ 

Jus Jon (Team Blake), “Talk” — Grade: C+ 

Ben Allen (Team Blake), “Red Dirt Road” — Grade: A-

Kelsie Watts (Team Kelly), “I Dare You” — Grade: A

Carter Rubin (Team Gwen), “Before You Go” — Grade: A

Casmé (Team Legend), “Baby I Love You” — Grade: A-

DeSz (Team TBD), “Unbreak My Heart” — Grade: B-

As always perfect rankings.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, istersay said:

The Voice Recap: A Night 3 Contestant Turns the Blinds Into Child's Play — Plus, Who Gets 'Stuck With' Gwen?
By Charlie Mason / October 26 2020, 7:00 PM PDT

https://tvline.com/2020/10/26/the-voice-recap-carter-rubin-kelsie-watts-blind-auditions/

 

Rio Souma (Team Legend), “Cruisin’” — Grade: C

 

 

Ryan Berg (Team Gwen), “Waiting On the World to Change” — Grade: C+ 

Jus Jon (Team Blake), “Talk” — Grade: C+ 

Ben Allen (Team Blake), “Red Dirt Road” — Grade: A-

Kelsie Watts (Team Kelly), “I Dare You” — Grade: A

Carter Rubin (Team Gwen), “Before You Go” — Grade: A

Casmé (Team Legend), “Baby I Love You” — Grade: A-

DeSz (Team TBD), “Unbreak My Heart” — Grade: B-

taste was demonstrated with: ben, kelsie, casme (ryan, jusjon)

taste was forsaken with: rio, carter, desz

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...