Who Sang IWTKWLI The Best?

[David68]

Please tell me somebody hasn't done this. Also please don't tell me I missed one. Discuss, links are below:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited June 2, 2020 by David68
Edited to add a single word, lol

[QueenMae16]

While Hunter did a phenomenal job, he has to rank 2nd behind: THE Rose Short.

But great work to these 2 for burying the song to never be sung again....(looks at Chloe and Toneisha with a cold stare)

[Someone648]

Hunter/Chloe/Rose all gave 10/10 performances that are unique and equally phenomenal in my eyes.

I voted Hunter, as his is the version I listen to the most - but definitely a three way tie for me.

[IAN27TAY]

BEST OF THE BEST

1.Rose

2.Hunter

3.Chloe

4.Toneisha

5.Terry

6-7 Keith and Jamar

 

 

[David68]

4 hours ago, IAN27TAY said:

BEST OF THE BEST

1.Rose

2.Hunter

3.Chloe

4.Toneisha

5.Terry

6-7 Keith and Jamar

 

 

This is the official ranking.

[VintageVoice]

A tiered ranking bc some of them are on the same levels as other versions

1. Hunter/Rose
2. Chloe/Toneisha
3. Terry
4. Jamar/Keith

The biggest problem with tier 2 is that they came in the seasons immediately following tier 1's absolutely stellar versions; tier 2 is very good, just weak in comparison. 

 

(Side note, I voted for Rose because it's completely ridiculous she had to go into the Instant Save for the finale after that performance.) 

Edited June 2, 2020 by VintageVoice

[ATX29]

Rose and Hunter would be at the top of my list.  Chloe third.

 

The rest are interchangeable.