Jump to content

Rate the Performances (Top 9)


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Same thing as last week. Rate each performance on a scale from 0 to 10 and I'll average the scores for each performance in the OP as people add more ratings.

 

Current Ratings

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" 8.59

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" 7.82

CammWess - "Rainbow" 7.50

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" 7.27

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" 7.18

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" 6.30

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" 5.86

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" 5.44

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" 5.32

 

Edited by steverx
Link to post
Share on other sites

CammWess - "Rainbow" (9/10)

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" (9/10)

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts the Most" (7/10)

Toneisha Harris - 'Because You Loved Me" (7/10)

Joanna Serenko - "Lean on Me" (6.5/10)

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be the Same" (5.5/10)

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" (5/10)

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" (4/10)

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into the Dark" (3.5/10)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" 7

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" 10

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" 10

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" 4

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" 7

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" 5

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" 7

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" 8

CammWess - "Rainbow" 9

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" - 7

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" - 8.5

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" - 8

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" - 6

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" - 9

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" - 9

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" - 7.5

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" - 8

CammWess - "Rainbow" - 8.5

 
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko 6

Micah Iverson 8

Todd Tilghman 5

Zan Fiskum 6

Thunderstorm Artis 10

Megan Danielle 10

Allegra Miles 5

Toneisha Harris 7

CammWess 9

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" - 6

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" - 6

Todd Tilghman - "Love Me" - 9.5

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" - 4

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" - 7.5

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" - 6.5

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" - 7

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" - 7

CammWess - "Rainbow" - 6

Edited by mjdolorico
Link to post
Share on other sites

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home"    7.5
Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me"    7
Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me"    7
Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same"    6.5
CammWess - "Rainbow"    6
Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark"    4
Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most"    4
Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me"    3.5
Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed"    3

Link to post
Share on other sites

Being extra critical to provide some separation.

 

Joanna Serenko - 7.5

Micah Iverson - 7.5

Todd Tilghman - 9.0

Zan Fiskum - 6.5

Thunderstorm Artis - 9.0

Megan Danielle - 7.0

Allegra Miles - 7.0

Toneisha Harris - 8.5

CammWess - 7.5

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko "Lean On Me" - 3.5

Micah Iverson "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" - 8

Todd Tilghman "Love, Me" - 6.5

Zan Fiskum "Never Be The Same" - 3

Thunderstorm Artis "Home" - 9

Megan Danielle "What Hurts The Most" - 4

Allegra Miles "Overjoyed" - 6.5

Toneisha Harris "Because You Loved Me" - 7.5

CammWess "Rainbow" - 6

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  1. Thunderstorm Artis - 9/10, I loved last week and this didn't quite live up to it but this was a different side to his voice that I don't remember hearing before and it was really soothing which I needed tonight.
  2. Micah Iverson - 8/10, that's some dramatic-ass staging but his vocals delivered and it was super pretty (especially on the higher notes)
  3. Todd Tilghman - 8/10, the rasp is back but this wasn't as good (in my personal opinion) as some of his other performances. I still love Todd's voice though. MJ don't kill me for putting Todd this low 
  4. Toneisha Harris - 7/10, Khalea and MaKenzie's versions weren't blown away but she's the only one this season who could've pulled this off and she did well considering the lofty standards of other versions from previous seasons. 
  5. Joanna Serenko - 7/10, this was pretty good but I still preferred AfM over this week.
  6. CammWess - 7/10, honestly this is the last song + artist combo I would've expected but he made it work better than I expected; also, appealing to crossover/country voters that are just casual fans at this point in the competition is strategically a good move, and CammWess has arguably got the hang of the strategy more clearly than most of his competitors. 
  7. Allegra Miles - 6/10, I love Stevie Wonder so it kills me to put his song this low on the list but this was just okay, and Allegra needs more than "just okay" to get people to keep her in mind for tomorrow if she needs it (and as she's unlikely getting that PV over T-storm, well...)
  8. Zan Fiskum - 5/10, there was some bits that sounded pitchy (to my untrained ears, anyway) but I give her credit for going outside the folk-pop/folk-rock lane.
  9. Megan Danielle - 5/10, Keisha Renee was not shook but being more country than she's been otherwise should still net her some of the casual votes. Also, that high note towards the end was really nice.
  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, VintageVoice said:
  1.  
  2. Todd Tilghman - 8/10, the rasp is back but this wasn't as good (in my personal opinion) as some of his other performances. I still love Todd's voice though. MJ don't kill me for putting Todd this low 

 

LOL why would I? I also thought his performance tonight was less impressive than last week's. 🤭 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" - 6

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" - 7.5

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" - 8.5

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" - 7

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" - 8

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" - 6

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" - 6

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" - 8

CammWess - "Rainbow" - 7

 
Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, mjdolorico said:

 

LOL why would I? I also thought his performance tonight was less impressive than last week's. 🤭 

Being the Todd stan you are, I'd rather be safe than sorry 😅

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, VintageVoice said:

Being the Todd stan you are, I'd rather be safe than sorry 😅

Nahh.... I may be a stan, but I am also critical of my faves. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

CammWess - "Rainbow" - 7

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" - 8

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts the Most" - 4

Toneisha Harris - 'Because You Loved Me" - 7

Joanna Serenko - "Lean on Me" - 6

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be the Same" - 8

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" - 8

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" - 4

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into the Dark" - 3

Link to post
Share on other sites

Highlight Of The Night

1. Allegra Miles-This is great. I enjoyed this from her, Yes it went slightly off the rails at the end, but since it reminded me of Will a little, Ill forgive that. 

 

 

2.Megan-She did great, but i feel like Kelly was trying to pimp Meagan, but accidentally bussed her, considering she loves RF, but does not know this song is a kiss of death

 

 Decent, bonus points for covering Camila even if the song doesn't fit

3.  Zan Fiskum-If i was a Voicespiracy theorist, id call this a bus. Her version was nice enoug, but some parts of it , i couldn't hear her pronunciations.

 

The Rest Very Good Vocally, but Kind OF Boring IN No Order

Thunderstorm Artis-My least favorite performance from him If we're going to have Michael Buble be sung, can we please limit them to being done by crooners/jazz singers and have on of them make the top 13 once?

 

Todd Tlighman- :rofl::rofl::rofl: with the stage set up. I doubt daycare students need to learn about romance, and the pimpage seems kind of overboard, cause does Todd even need it? The performance was nice, but not as great as last week, besides I need Todd to do a Beyonce song...FINALE WEEK  BEYONCE SONG PLS TODD!!! 

Joana Serenko-Love this song, but it does'n fit her voice, not to mention it isn't a good song for this late in the game

 

.Toneisha-This song is so boring. Toneisha deserves better

 Micah Iverson-Started off good, but then dragged on and was kind of boring 

 

CammWess-I appreciate his creativity and he has a great voice, but something is  missing. Maybe it's that his tone just seems average to me, or it might just be his musical style  isn't my cup of tea, or just that i don't connect to his performances. He's talented though. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" - 8

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" - 8

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" - 9

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" - 4

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" - 5

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" - 2

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" - 7

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" - 3

CammWess - "Rainbow" - 10

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" 6

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" 8

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" 8

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" 5

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" 8

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" 5

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" 6

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" 5

CammWess - "Rainbow" 9

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" 9.5

Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" 8.5

Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me" 6.5

Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into The Dark" 8

CammWess - "Rainbow" 7

Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" 6

Megan Danielle - "What Hurts The Most" 3.5

Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" 4.75

Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" 5.5

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...