Jump to content

Top 9  

49 members have voted

  1. 1. Who gave the best performance

    • Joanna Serenko - Lean On Me
      0
    • Micah Iverson - I Will Follow You into the Dark
      7
    • Todd Tilghman - Love, Me
      9
    • Zan Fiskum - Never Be The Same
      1
    • Thunderstorm Artis - Home
      12
    • Megan Danielle - What Hurts the Most
      6
    • Allegra Miles - Overjoyed
      3
    • Toneisha Harris - Because You Loved Me
      3
    • CammWess - Rainbow
      8
  2. 2. Who gave the worst performance

    • Joanna Serenko - Lean On Me
      8
    • Micah Iverson - I Will Follow You into the Dark
      1
    • Todd Tilghman - Love, Me
      4
    • Zan Fiskum - Never Be The Same
      8
    • Thunderstorm Artis - Home
      1
    • Megan Danielle - What Hurts The Most
      11
    • Allegra Miles - Overjoyed
      15
    • Toneisha Harris - Because You Loved Me
      1
    • CammWess - Rainbow
      0
  3. 3. Who will be the 5 to move on

    • Megan Danielle
      13
    • Micah Iverson
      38
    • Allegra Miles
      12
    • Thunderstorm Artis
      47
    • CammWess
      43
    • Zan Fiskum
      3
    • Joanna Serenko
      12
    • Todd Tilghman
      44
    • Toneisha Harris
      20


Recommended Posts

lmao, we were sure Allegra would have snatched that 3rd PV or Joanna even, if given the normal format. They weren't going anywhere near that PV with what happened tonight.

tragic but TPTB stays manipulating.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, QueenMae16 said:

lmao, we were sure Allegra would have snatched that 3rd PV or Joanna even, if given the normal format. They weren't going anywhere near that PV with what happened tonight.

tragic but TPTB stays manipulating.

I'm confused, she did well on the song. I don't get how that is a "manipulation "...they're trying to win all of America's votes, not just IDF's. Also, nobody, not Allegra, not CammWess, etc. is/would've been guarenteed safe regardless of format. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I can't manage the Poll but, I can state who or how many, I had from tonight, Monday... 2 out of 9.  And they were Megan & Zan OR Zan & Megan. And that's where I stop.  (FOR ME)  I'll take those 2 & leave the rest. These 2 were excellent, impressive & most appealing, IMO.

Edited by Drew1903
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

1. CammWess: What a delightful surprise, worthy of the pimp spot.

2. Todd Tilghman: That was such a cheesy song but I really felt it in the moment.

3. Micah Iverson: He might have oversung it a bit but still good overall. The big moon though, yikes.

4. Joanna Serenko: I didn’t watch live but did people really find this bad?? The taste of some people, or the lack thereof.

5. Allegra Miles: Not her best, but I still like her. It did look like she was wrestling with the song towards the end though. 

 

————GAP————

 

6. Thunderstorm Artis: His performance got dull and boring about 30 seconds in. 

7. Zan Fiskum: I never noticed her head voice was so wonky. It certainly did not make for an easy listen.

8. Toneisha Harris: The problem with her is that given her vocal ability, she doesn’t seem to give the song as much as she could have. Otyer divas have a tendency to oversing, while she just undersings. 

9. Megan Danielle: Not a good song, and slowing it down makes it tedious to listen to. This is one of those performances that just wouldn’t end.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

King

1. Thunderstorm (by far the best, deserving winner)

 

Good

2. Todd (Cheesy af but really solid)

3. Micah (One of my fav songs and he did good, but something was missing) 

 

Passable

4. CammWess (love this song, didn’t love some of his vocal choices)

5. Toneisha (Boring but the end was good)

6. Joanna (Kinda decent, but it’s a bad song choice and she was boring as usual)

 

Yikes

7. Zan (😔)

8. Allegra (Oof)

9. Megan (technically not the worst, but her tone is very annoying)

 

Lol at my T4 being the guys, who would have thought 

Edited by Daillon
Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Someone648 said:

I've gotta disagree here. What's pandery with the song he chose?

A beloved song that many people connect to isn't necessarily pandering unless the song is overwhelmingly pandering to something (as is God Bless the USA)

 

 

This. And honestly the stage set up was the opposite of pandery. The performance was so cheesy, that with the set up, anyone else not named Todd or Thunderstorm would’ve been in danger of going home.

 

also note an ACTUAL pandering song doesn’t guarantee an advancement

 


 

Link to post
Share on other sites

4/10 Joanna Serenko - "Lean On Me" - Corny song, boring arrangement, absolutely forgettable.

5/10 Micah Iverson - "I Will Follow You Into the Dark" - I liked this performance when he went for powerful notes but his falsetto parts kind of distracted me. And the big note in"to"~~ in the end was shaky too obviously.  

5/10 Todd Tilghman - "Love, Me" - He's a traditionally TV solid singer . I just don't find him unique or marketable at all.

1/10 Zan Fiskum - "Never Be The Same" - HORRIBLE. It's crazy like from the heaven last week to the hell this week 

8/10 Thunderstorm Artis - "Home" - He must win. Period.

1/10 Megan Danielle - "What Hurts the Most" - Mostly unlistenable, I can't stand her heavily throaty voice here. 

5/10 Allegra Miles - "Overjoyed" - Every human needs to beg her for stopping choosing boring old songs srsly.

2/10 Toneisha Harris - "Because You Loved Me"  - So outdated, so karaoke.

5/10 CammWess - "Rainbow" - I just don't feel the emotion that people get in his voice. Pretty decent though.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Micah apparently has allergies and had problems hitting some his notes. 

 

1- Tstorm, again.

2- Micah

3- Toneisha

4- Joanna

5- CammWess

6- Todd

7- Zan

8- Allegra (shame, her worst performance, she should win the IS)

9- Megan, sorry. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1.  Tstorm

2.  Todd

3.  Joanna

4.  Megan

5.  Cammwess

6.  Allegra

7.  Toneisha 

8.  Micah

9.  Zan

 

Mostly a forgettable night.  The ladies picked a bad time to flop, but the songs they were saddled with certainly had something to do with that.  

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...