Jump to content

Rank the Performances - S18, Top 7


Recommended Posts

Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid)

Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella)

Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog)

Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King)

Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast)

Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan)

Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars)

Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver)

Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera)

Jonny West - “Amazing Grace”

Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King)

Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele)

Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges)

Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney:

1. Sam

2. Dillon

3. Francisco

4. Louis

5. Julia

6. Jonny

7. Arthur

 

Mother’s Day:

1. Sam

2. Francisco

3. Dillon

4. Julia

5. Arthur

6. Louis

7. Jonny

 

Overall:

1. Sam

2. Francisco

3. Dillon

4. Julia

5. Louis

6. Arthur

7. Jonny

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Francisco Martin: River

2. Julia Gargano: Sweetest Devotion

3. Dillon James: Hang On, Hang On

 

Thats it. Im not going to give effort to the rest of the performances because they were all either avergae, forgettable, or bad.

Link to post
Share on other sites

First song:

Dillon
Jonny
Julia
Arthur

Just Sam
Louis

Francisco

 

Second song:

Dillon

Julia

Jonny

Just Sam

Francisco
Louis
Arthur

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney

01.) Dillon James

02.) Jonny West

03.) Just Sam

04.) Francisco Martin

05.) Arthur Gunn

06.) Julia Gargano

07.) Louis Knight

 

Dedications

01.) Francisco Martin

02.) Julia Gargano

03.) Louis Knight

04.) Arthur Gunn

05.) Dillon James

06.) Just Sam

07.) Jonny West

 

Overall

01.) Dillon James

02.) Francisco Martin

03.) Just Sam

04.) Julia Gargano

05.) Arthur Gunn

06.) Jonny West

07.) Louis Knight

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele)

2. Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges)

3. Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera)

4. Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella)

5. Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars)

6. Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee)

7. Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan)

8. Louis Knight - “You've Got a Friend” (Carole King)

9. Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King)

10. Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast)

11. Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid)

12. Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog)

13. Jonny West - “Amazing Grace”

14. Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges)

Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee)

Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan)

Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars)

 

Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera)

Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele)

Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella)

 

Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King)

Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast)

Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog)

Jonny West - “Amazing Grace”

 

Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King)

 

Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid)

Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm just going to list my Top 7 Perforances

 

Julia - Sweetest Devotion

Sam - A Dream Is A Wish Your Heart Makes

Dillon - Our Town

Sam - I Turn To You

Dillon - Hang On, Hang On

Francisco - River

Julia - Beauty And The Beast

Link to post
Share on other sites

By performance:

 

1. Dillon James - "Hang On, Hang On"

2. Dillon James - "Our Town"

3. Francisco Martin - "River"

4. Julia Gargano - "Sweetest Devotion"

5. Louis Knight - "Can You Feel the Love Tonight?"

6. Arthur Gunn - "Hey Ma"

7. Jonny West - "Almost There"

8. Francisco Martin - "You'll Be In My Heart"

9. Julia Gargano - "Beauty and the Beast"

10. Jonny West - "Amazing Grace"

11. Just Sam - "I Turn To You"

12. Arthur Gunn - "Kiss the Girl"

13. Just Sam - "A Dream Is a Wish Your Heart Makes"

14. Louis Knight - "You've Got a Friend"

 

Overall:

 

1. Dillon James

2. Francisco Martin

3. Julia Gargano

4. Jonny West

5. Arthur Gunn

6. Just Sam

7. Louis Knight

 

Yes, Louis's second performance was that far behind every other performance that Sam still narrowly edges him out on average with her two mediocre performances.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney:

  1. Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars)
  2. Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan)
  3. Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog)
  4. Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella)
  5. Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King)
  6. Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid)
  7. Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast)

Mother's Day:

  1. Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges)
  2. Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee)
  3. Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King)
  4. Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera)
  5. Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver)
  6. Jonny West - “Amazing Grace”
  7. Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele)

 

Overall, I much preferred the second one to the first one. I didn't really dislike any of the round 2 performances, but didn't care for most of the round 1 performances.

Link to post
Share on other sites

i generally wasn't happy with many of the performances today:

 

Disney :

 

1) Dillon

2) Samantha

3) Francisco 

4) Arthur

5) Johnny

6) Julia

7) Louis

 

Mother's Day:

 

1) Francisco

2) Julia

3) Samantha

4) Dillon

5) Louis

6) Arthur

7) Johnny

 

 

Overall (not exactly the average of the two performances):

 

1) Samantha

2) Francisco

3) Dillon

4) Julia

5) Arthur

6) Louis

7) Johnny

 

I don't know what it is about Johnny, his tone sounds slightly grating to my ears...

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney: 

1. Sam 

2. Arthur 

3. Dillon 

4. Julia

5. Louis 

6. Jonny 

7. Fransisco 

Dedications:

1. Julia 

2. Sam 

3. Dillon 

4. Arthur

5. Jonny 

6. Fransisco 

7. Louis

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mother's Day:

Francisco

Jonny (I'm indifferent, his voice is like butter in that song)

Julia

Dillon

 

Arthur

Louis

Sam

 

 

Can't be bothered to rank the Disney songs

 

Overall: 

Francisco

Dillon

Jonny

Julia

 

Arthur

Sam

Louis

 

 

Seriously, Sam is very mediocre this episode. She sings like she's in the subway 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

EXCELLENT:

1. Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele)

 

VERY GOOD:

2. Jonny West - “Amazing Grace”

3. Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee)

4. Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog)

5. Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges)

 

GOOD:

6. Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella)

7. Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver)

 

GOOD ENOUGH:

8. Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid)

 

ALMOST GOOD ENOUGH:

9. Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera)

10. Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars)

 

MEH...DECENT, I GUESS:

11. Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King)

 

WASN'T FEELIN' IT:

12. Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan)

13. Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast)

 

WHIFF:

14. Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King)

 

 

 

 

UPDATED PERSONAL PREFERENCE BASED ON BODY OF WORK:

1. Julia Gargano

2. Jonny West

 

3. Just Sam

4. Dillon James

5. Arthur Gunn

 

6. Francisco Martin

 

7. Louis Knight 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

6/10 Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” - I fking hate Disney theme, but he sounded pretty fine tbh.

6/10 Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes”  - A typical Fking boring Disney song. However , a great vocal performance by Sam.

4/10 Jonny West - “Almost There”  - I wasn't feeling anything with Jonny taking on this song.

4/10 Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight”  - It was a downright forgettable performance. I srsly miss ITWWE Louis.

0/10 Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” - This is the most awful version I've ever heard.

2/10 Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” - I love Francisco, but this was not good at all.

6/10 Dillon James - “Our Town” - Dillon has been showing me that he's already a polished artist, he did steady as always. 

 

 

7/10 Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” - A great song choice for Arthur, this is the style that he should sing in his future.

2/10 Just Sam - “I Turn to You” - Oh no Sam, not this song. It's too big for you not to make it bad karaoke.

6/10 Jonny West - “Amazing Grace” - A very heartfelt performance, his style won me over here.

3/10 Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” - I'm speechless. The song choices for Louis are the big mistakes of the century.

4/10 Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” - Uh, her mom is so cute. 

5/10 Francisco Martin - “River”  - Franciscute is back.  He held back a little bit, I hope he went for big notes more.

6/10 Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” - Watch out. He's coming for the crown.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney

01. Jonny - It didn’t sound like a Disney song. He was great on this performance.

02. Arthur - Perfect song and a great performance.

03. Dillon - I didn’t care about him before this week but he had a fantastic week for him.

04. Sam - No thank you.

05. Francisco - Meh.

06. Julia - Changing a classic song like that was silly. I think this was her worst yet? and she covered “Human”.

07. Louis - This was terrible. 

 

Mothers Day

01. Jonny - The only performance this season that I’ll remember next year. It was stunning.

02. Dillon - He's fire.

03. Julia - I didn’t love it and I didn’t hate it. It was probably her best so far? There’s still a huge gap between Dillon and her.

04. Arthur - It was good but didn’t go anywhere.

05. Francisco - It was just there.

06. Louis - Urgh, he’s just bad.

07. Sam - Why is she the only one who sounds like she’s singing from her bedroom? This was atrocious. I’d say it’s up there with the worst of the finals so far.

 

Overall

01. Jonny

02. Dillon

03. Arthur

04. Julia
05. Francisco

06. Sam

07. Louis

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Here are the rankings for Disney night:

 

1.  Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan) — his best performance yet.  I loved it!
2.  Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella) — she could have done a little more with it but she was still very good.
3.  Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog) — this was quite enjoyable for me.
4.  Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid) — this was better than Cade’s version from Season 16, but it wasn’t great.  Just very good.
5.  Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars) — he sang it well.  It just wasn’t my cup of tea, that’s all.
6.  Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast) — this should have had a straight arrangement.
7.  Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King) — in theory, this should have been very good at least.  It wasn’t.

 

And here are the rankings for the Mother's Day Dedications:

 

1.  Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges) -- this intimate setting is really helping him avoid stage fright.

2.  Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele) -- much better than her first performance.  Unfortunately, it's too little, too late for her.

3.  Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera) -- she's still my favorite but she needs to let loose in the finale in order to have any shot of winning!

4.  Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee) -- I liked this a little better, and he did it quite well.

5.  Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King) -- this was better than his last song, but I heard Maddie and Caleb do this better on the tour.

6.  Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver) -- I didn't really like the song.  Just wasn't my cup of tea, maybe.

7.  Jonny West - “Amazing Grace” -- he sang it well but it was a little boring for me.

 

Overall:

 

1.  Francisco -- he did the best with both performances.

2.  Just Sam -- I still love her.

3.  Julia -- her first performance was awful, but she improved with her second song.

4.  Dillon -- he did well enough that I would have put him in the Top 10.

5. (tie) Arthur -- did okay, but he isn't my cup of tea anymore.

6. (tie) Jonny -- he probably should have been the one going home instead of Julia.

7.  Louis -- he did well to get this far, but it's time for him to go home.

Edited by CarmenSandiego
Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee)

2. Jonny West - “Amazing Grace”

3. Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele)

4. Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver)

5. Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars)

6. Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges)

7. Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog)

8. Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella)

9. Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid)

10. Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera)

11. Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King)

12. Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast)

13. Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan)

14. Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King)

Link to post
Share on other sites

1.  Francisco Martin - "River"
2.  Jonny West - "Amazing Grace"
3.  Arthur Gunn - "Hey, Ma"
4.  Dillon James - "Hang On, Hang On"
5.  Jonny West - "Almost There"
6.  Dillon James - "Our Town"
7.  Arthur Gunn - "Kiss The Girl"
8.  Julia Gargano - "Sweetest Devotion"
9.  Louis Knight - "You've Got A Friend"
10.  Just Sam - "I Turn To You"
11.  Francisco Martin - "You'll Be In My Heart"
12.  Just Sam - "A Dream Is A Wish Your Heart Makes"
13.  Louis Knight - "Can You Feel The Love Tonight"
14.  Julia Gargano - "Beauty and the Beast"

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Dillon James - “Hang On, Hang On” (Amos Lee) 7.5/10

Jonny West - “Amazing Grace” 7/10

Francisco Martin - “You’ll Be in My Heart” (from Tarzan) 6.5/10

Francisco Martin - “River” (Leon Bridges) 6.5/10

Louis Knight - “You’ve Got a Friend” (Carole King) 6/10

Julia Gargano - “Sweetest Devotion” (Adele) 6/10

Arthur Gunn - “Hey, Ma” (Bon Iver) 6/10

Dillon James - “Our Town” (from Cars) 6/10

Jonny West - “Almost There” (from The Princess and the Frog) 5.5/10

Just Sam - “A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (from Cinderella) 5.5/10

Arthur Gunn - “Kiss the Girl” (from The Little Mermaid) 5/10

Just Sam - “I Turn to You” (Christina Aguilera) 4/10

Julia Gargano - “Beauty and the Beast” (from Beauty and the Beast) 2.5/10

Louis Knight - “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” (from The Lion King) 2/10

Edited by BrokenHearted
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...