The X Factor Rankdown

[Elliott 4,249]

1 minute ago, *Chris said:

So, X contestant ranked higher from Y contestant 6 out of 9 then they win the tie? 

 

Or X contestant highest rank is a #2 so X contestant place higher?

The second option is my preference. 

[~Tom~ 603]

3 minutes ago, *Chris said:

So, X contestant ranked higher from Y contestant 6 out of 9 then they win the tie? 

 

Or X contestant highest rank is a #2 so X contestant place higher?

I like the second option, that's how it's been done in rankdowns before I think.  

[*Chris 1,538]

And if the second option doesn't break the tie - should I take their 2nd highest ranking into consideration? 

[~Tom~ 603]

2 minutes ago, *Chris said:

And if the second option doesn't break the tie - should I take their 2nd highest ranking into consideration? 

Fine by me.  

[Elliott 4,249]

Just do whatever gets Leona and Dami a lower placement.  

[~Tom~ 603]

7 minutes ago, Elliott said:

Just do whatever gets Leona and Dami a lower placement.  

We need a dislike option for such as this. 

[Elliott 4,249]

Just now, ~Tom~ said:

We need a dislike option for such as this. 

I agree, a dislike option for Leona and Dami would come in handy.

[Elliott 4,249]

Me waiting for this list to start:

 

[*Chris 1,538]

I’m waiting on some write ups  

 

I’m starting on the format so it’ll go faster once I have them. 

[1234567890 4,407]

4 hours ago, Elliott said:

We saw enough questionable decisions by the public in the actual show to keep it from being revived here.

...half of them were made by you.

[1234567890 4,407]

31 minutes ago, Elliott said:

Just do whatever gets Leona and Dami a lower placement.  

Just do whatever gets Amelia and Samantha a lower placement.  

[1234567890 4,407]

45 minutes ago, ~Tom~ said:

I like the second option, that's how it's been done in rankdowns before I think.  

I thought @Alex95 always used to go by the public ranking when ties happened.

[Elliott 4,249]

1 minute ago, 1234567890 said:

...half of them were made by you.

Half of the questionable public decisions on XFUK were made by me when I can't even vote on the show?  

[Elliott 4,249]

Just now, 1234567890 said:

I thought @Alex95 always used to go by the public ranking when ties happened.

Different hosts have different methods.

[~Tom~ 603]

1 minute ago, 1234567890 said:

I thought @Alex95 always used to go by the public ranking when ties happened.

I have never been involved in one of his rankdowns, I'm referring to other hosts.  

[1234567890 4,407]

Just now, Elliott said:

Different hosts have different methods.

@~Tom~ stated that's how it's been done in rankdowns but it wasn't. @Alex95 started breaking ties with public votes and other started doing it differently.

[1234567890 4,407]

1 minute ago, ~Tom~ said:

I have never been involved in one of his rankdowns, I'm referring to other hosts.  

Oh. That would explain the comments because I was like what? Just like some people let the nominator swoop in for a cut/save when 24 hours have passed and some let the the non-nominating rankers swoop in for a cut/save when 24 hours have passed. Different ways, I guess.

[Elliott 4,249]

1 minute ago, 1234567890 said:

 

@~Tom~ stated that's how it's been done in rankdowns but it wasn't. @Alex95 started breaking ties with public votes and other started doing it differently.

???

 

It’s been done in rankdowns before like Tom said. Just not Alex’s. Tom didn’t say it’s been done in all rankdowns.

[Elliott 4,249]

1 minute ago, 1234567890 said:

Oh. That would explain the comments because I was like what? Just like some people let the nominator swoop in for a cut/save when 24 hours have passed and some let the the non-nominating rankers swoop in for a cut/save when 24 hours have passed. Different ways, I guess.

And i don’t bother breaking ties because i wanted to have the gag of a double rankdown winner  #extra

[1234567890 4,407]

@*Chris, I'm fine with whatever method you use. It's your rankdown and you're the host. I support your choice no matter what!

[1234567890 4,407]

1 minute ago, Elliott said:

???

 

It’s been done in rankdowns before like Tom said. Just not Alex’s. Tom didn’t say it’s been done in all rankdowns.

I meant initially. I guess I haven't paid attention and the only format I really remember is @Alex95's because it was the first rankdown and we were learning all the rules.

[1234567890 4,407]

2 minutes ago, Elliott said:

And i don’t bother breaking ties because i wanted to have the gag of a double rankdown winner  #extra

[1234567890 4,407]

3 minutes ago, Elliott said:

???

 

It’s been done in rankdowns before like Tom said. Just not Alex’s. Tom didn’t say it’s been done in all rankdowns.

...and I just said others started doing it differently.

[Steven_ 783]

1 hour ago, *Chris said:

So, X contestant ranked higher from Y contestant 6 out of 9 then they win the tie? 

I like this method, but I’m fine with whatever is easiest for Chris.

[*Wallace 1,695]

9 minutes ago, Steven_ said:

I like this method, but I’m fine with whatever is easiest for Chris.

I tend to prefer this method too. But I'm fine with whatever is decided.