Jump to content
idolforums.com
Sign in to follow this  
holinessss

Rank the Top 40 Performances - Night 2!

Final Judgement - Night 2!  

21 members have voted

  1. 1. Best Performance by a Guy?

    • Arthur Gunn - Is This Love? (Bob Marley)
      16
    • Franklin Boone - Daughters (John Mayer)
      4
    • Robert Taylor - Take Me To The Pilot (Elton John)
      1
  2. 2. Best Performance by a Girl?

    • Amelia Jester - This Is Me (Keala Settle)
      0
    • Cyniah Elise - Lady Marmalade (Patti LaBelle)
      0
    • Demi Rae - Lonely (Noah Cyrus)
      0
    • Genavieve Linkowski - You Say (Lauren Daigle)
      1
    • Grace Leer - (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman (Aretha Franklin)
      3
    • Julia Gargano - Glitter In The Air (P!nk)
      2
    • Kimmy Gabriella - You Don't Do It For Me Anymore (Demi Lovato)
      3
    • Lauren Mascitti - Two More Bottles Of Wine (Emmylou Harris)
      1
    • Lauren Spencer-Smith - Respect (Aretha Franklin)
      0
    • Makayla Phillips - Sorry Not Sorry (Demi Lovato)
      1
    • Olivia Ximines - Proud Mary (Tina Turner)
      2
    • Shannon Gibbons - Send My Love (To Your New Lover) (Adele)
      1
    • Sophia Wackerman - Levels (Nick Jonas)
      7
  3. 3. Did the Judges get it right!?

    • My Faves are IN!
      10
    • Half and Half
      11
    • My Faves are OUT...
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Arthur Gunn - Is This Love? (Bob Marley)
Franklin Boone - Daughters (John Mayer)

Robert Taylor - Take Me To The Pilot (Elton John)
 

Aliana** Jester - This Is Me (Keala Settle)
Cyniah Elise - Lady Marmalade (Patti LaBelle)
Demi Rae - Lonely (Noah Cyrus)

Genavieve Linkowski - You Say (Lauren Daigle)
Grace Leer - (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman (Aretha Franklin)
Julia Gargano - Glitter In The Air (P!nk)
Kimmy Gabriella - You Don't Do It For Me Anymore (Demi Lovato)
Lauren Mascitti - Two More Bottles Of Wine (Emmylou Harris)

Lauren Spencer-Smith - Respect (Aretha Franklin)

Makayla Phillips - Sorry Not Sorry (Demi Lovato)

Olivia Ximines - Proud Mary (Tina Turner)
Shannon Gibbons - Send My Love (To Your New Lover) (Adele)
Sophia Wackerman - Levels (Nick Jonas)

 

 

Edited by holinessss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Grace Leer - (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman (Aretha Franklin)
Makayla Phillips - Sorry Not Sorry (Demi Lovato)

Olivia Ximines - Proud Mary (Tina Turner)
 

Sophia Wackerman - Levels (Nick Jonas)

Julia Gargano - Glitter In The Air (P!nk)

Cyniah Elise - Lady Marmalade (Patti LaBelle)

Demi Rae - Lonely (Noah Cyrus)

Kimmy Gabriella - You Don't Do It For Me Anymore (Demi Lovato)

 

Lauren Mascitti - Two More Bottles Of Wine (Emmylou Harris)

Lauren Spencer-Smith - Respect (Aretha Franklin)

Arthur Gunn - Is This Love? (Bob Marley)
Genavieve Linkowski - You Say (Lauren Daigle)
Shannon Gibbons - Send My Love (To Your New Lover) (Adele)

 

Franklin Boone - Daughters (John Mayer)

Aliana Jester - This Is Me (Keala Settle)

Robert Taylor - Take Me To The Pilot (Elton John)

Edited by holinessss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Sophia Wackerman

2. Grace Leer

3. Shannon Gibbons

4. Makayla Phillips

5. Cyniah Elise

6. Julia Gargano

7. Olivia Ximines

8. Lauren Manscitti

9. Franklin Boone

10. Lauren Spencer-Smith

11. Kimmy Gabriella

12. Demi Rae

13. Arthur Gunn

14. Genevieve Linkowski

15. Aliana Jester

16. Robert Taylor

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kimmy Gabriella - You Don't Do It For Me Anymore (Demi Lovato)

2. Cyniah Elise - Lady Marmalade (Patti LaBelle)
3. Olivia Ximines - Proud Mary (Tina Turner)

4. Grace Leer - (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman (Aretha Franklin)

5. Julia Gargano - Glitter In The Air (P!nk)

6. Lauren Mascitti - Two More Bottles Of Wine (Emmylou Harris)

7. Sophia Wackerman - Levels (Nick Jonas)

8. Franklin Boone - Daughters (John Mayer)

9. Lauren Spencer-Smith - Respect (Aretha Franklin)

10. Aliana Jester - This Is Me (Keala Settle)

11. Arthur Gunn - Is This Love? (Bob Marley)

12. Demi Rae - Lonely (Noah Cyrus)

13. Genavieve Linkowski - You Say (Lauren Daigle)

14. Makayla Phillips - Sorry Not Sorry (Demi Lovato)

15. Shannon Gibbons - Send My Love (To Your New Lover) (Adele)

16. Robert Taylor - Take Me To The Pilot (Elton John)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here’s how I ranked the 16 contestants after watching them twice:

 

1.  Olivia — she not only brought her voice but also her dance moves, putting on the best show, in my opinion.
2.  Grace — she was the better of the two female country singers.
3.  Sophia — she showed a new, sassy side to her and the risk paid off.
4.  Aliana — this was her best performance yet.
5.  Lauren Spencer-Smith — she killed “Respect”!
6.  Arthur — the best of the guys in this segment.
7.  Makayla — she really sang the heck out of that song!
8.  Lauren Mascitti — she was very good but Grace was better.
9.  Cyniah — not my favorite song from her but she did well enough to move on.
10.  Kimmy — she did well enough to move on but the judges want more from her.  I hope she can deliver.
11.  Franklin — he did well enough to move on but it was just very good.
12.  Julia — her voice was a little hoarse but she did well enough to move on.
13.  Demi Rae — I have to wonder if the judges cut her because they wanted her to become more confident as a performer.
14.  Genavieve — she sang it quite well but her song choice might have been too predictable and that might explain the apparent lack of connection.
15.  Shannon — this just wasn’t good enough at this point in the competition.
16.  Robert — he put on a show, but sometimes too much is really too much!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Top guys:

1. Arthur Gunn

2. Franklin Boone

 

Top Females:

1. Grace Leer

2. Lauren Spencer Smith

3. Julia Gregano

4. Lauren Massicity 

5. Sophia Wackerman

6. Mackayla 

7. Oilivia 

8. Chyniah

9. Kimmy 

10. Aliana

11. Genavaive

12. Demi Rae 

Worst of the night:

1. Shannon 

2. Rob Taylor

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...