Jump to content
idolforums.com
Sign in to follow this  
Agenator333

Rank the winners (finale spoilers)

Recommended Posts

Oh look, another here's my Stan list :bleh: shouldn't you also put what grade you are in school :haha:

 

Its okay that you are in 2nd grade, nothing to be ashamed of <3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm only ranking the seasons I watched. Seasons 1-5 omitted. I'd probably give Danielle and Cassadee the edge there, just based on genre preference. This is nothing set in stone. I like all of the top 8 to some degree.

 

1. Chevel

2. Sawyer

3. Maelyn

4. Brynn

5. Alisan

6. Chloe

7. Sundance

8. Jordan

9. CWB

10. Jake

11. Josh

12. Chris

Edited by TeamAudra

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh look, another here's my Stan list :bleh: shouldn't you also put what grade you are in school :haha:

 

MBA in International Business

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

God tier: (in order of greatness)

1. Tessanne Chin

2. Alisan Porter

3. Jordan Smith

4. Cassadee Pope

5. Maelyn Jarmon

 

Top tier: (no particular order)

Josh Kaufman

Chloe Kohanski

 

Better tier: (no particular order)

Javier Colon

Danielle Bradbery

Sawyer Fredericks

Chris Blue

Brynn Cartelli

 

Okay tier: (no particular order)

Craig Wayne Boyd

Chevel Shepherd

Jake Hoot

 

Bottom tier: (no particular order)

Jermaine Paul

Sundance Head

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's my ranking.

 

1. Chloe Kohanski - Season 13

2. Danielle Bradbery - Season 4

3. Cassadee Pope - Season 3

4. Maelyn Jarmon - Season 16

5. Tessane Chin - Season 5

6. Josh Kaufman - Season 6

7. Sundance Head - Season 11

8. Alisan Porter - Season 10

9. Jordan Smith - Season 9

10. Brynn Cartelli - Season 14

11. Sawyer Fredericks - Season 8

12. Craig Wayne Boyd - Season 7

13. Javier Colon - Season 1

14. Chris Blue - Season 12

15. Jermaine Paul - Season 2

16. Chevel Shepherd - Season 15

17. Jake Hoot - Season 17

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Chloe Kohanski

2, Sawyer Fredericks

3. Danielle Bradbury

4. Brynn Cartelli

 

5. Alisan Porter

6. Tessanne Chin

7. Josh Kaufman

8. Maelyn Jarmon

 

 

9. Craig Wayne Boyd

10. Cassadee Pope

11. Jordan Smith

12. Chris Blue

13. Chevel Shepherd

14. Sundance Head

 

15. Jake Hoot

16. Javier Colon

17. Jermaine Paul

 

 

Top 4... would rank in my favorites of all time. I keep up with their off show music. Not to mention the improvement in Danielle and Brynn since the show is astounding. 

Next 4...I genuinely like them, some of them are my favorites of the season (TBH, depending on the day the order of these four could change)..they are also some of the best contestants of all time. (IF I was to rank with my head instead of my heart..they would probably beat most of the top 4..) 

 

Next 6 are meh for me. Generally people whom I either thought was overhyped (Cassadee, Jordan, Chris) or people who benefited off of a contestant being robbed. (With the exception of CWB - who did a good job on his season, but wasn't the best. Winner was about preference between CWB, Matt, and Chris) 

 

Last 3..not my cup of tea. I don't even remember Jake Hoot and he won last year. Javier isn't bad but the technical issues in his singing get to me, and Jermaine..yeah..

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Cassadee Pope

3. Alisan Porter

4. Brynn Cartelli

5. Danielle Bradbury

6. Chloe Kohanski

7. Javier Colon

8. Sundance Head

9. Chevel Shepherd

10. Josh Kaufman

11. Jordan Smith

12. Tessanne Chin

13. Jermaine Paul

14. Jake Hoot

15. Sawyer Fredericks

16. Craig Wayne Boyd

17. Chris Blue

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No season 1&2 either way they will be lowest.

 

Favorites because of Blind Audition and Consistency and Well-Deserve Winner

1. Alisan Porter S10 Team Xtina

2. Josh Kaufman S6 Team Usher

3. Maelyn Jarmon S16 Team Legend

4. Jordan Smith S9 Team Adam

5. Chevel Sheperd S15 Team Kelly

 

Have at least good Breakout Performance/s and glad they won

6. Chris Blue S12 Team Alicia

7. Tessanne Chin S5 Team Adam

8. Chloe Kohanski S13 Team Blake

9. Brynn Cartelli S14 Team Kelly

 

Don't like winning but not bad

10. Danielle Bradbery S4 Team Blake

11. Sawyer Fredericks S8 Team Pharrell

12. Cassadee Pope S3 Team Blake

13. Sundance Head S11 Team Blake

 

Country that I don't like and I hate that they won

14. Craig Wayne Boyd S7 Team Blake

15. Jake Hoot S17 Team Kelly

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Every time this kind of thread is posted, my ranking shift slightly, so here's the current version lol:

~Rarely have I been pleased by the show's winner - my favorite's only won twice lol~

:wub:

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Chloe Kohanski

:thumbs:

3. Cassadee Pope

4. Alisan Porter

5. Jordan Smith

6. Tessanne Chin

😐

7. Brynn Cartelli

8. Chris Blue

9. Chevel Shepherd

10. Danielle Bradbery

11. Sawyer Fredericks

🤢

12. Jake Hoot

13. Sundance Head

14. Josh Kaufman

15. Craig Wayne Boyd

16. Javier Colon

17. Jermaine Paul

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Someone648 said:

Every time this kind of thread is posted, my ranking shift slightly, so here's the current version lol:

~Rarely have I been pleased by the show's winner - my favorite's only won twice lol~

:wub:

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Chloe Kohanski

:thumbs:

3. Cassadee Pope

4. Alisan Porter

5. Jordan Smith

6. Tessanne Chin

😐

7. Brynn Cartelli

8. Chris Blue

9. Chevel Shepherd

10. Danielle Bradbery

11. Sawyer Fredericks

🤢

12. Jake Hoot

13. Sundance Head

14. Josh Kaufman

15. Craig Wayne Boyd

16. Javier Colon

17. Jermaine Paul

 

 

 

I agree with pretty much al of this list, except I would more Chris blue up

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Alisan Porter

3. Brynn Cartelli

4. Chloe Kohanski

5. Lauren Duski

6. Tessanne Chin

7. Jordan Smith

8. Danielle Bradbery

9. Cassaddee Pope

 

10. Sawyer Fredericks

11. Javier Colon

12. Chevel Shepherd

 

13. Josh Kaufman

14. Sundance Head

15. Craig Wayne Boyd

16. Jake Hoot

 

17. Jermaine Paul

Edited by indii

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Javier Colon

3. Chloe Kohanski

 

4. Josh Kaufman

5. Jordan Smith

6. Chris Blue

7. Alisan Porter

 

8. Sawyer Fredericks

9. Tessanne Chin

 

 

10. Sundance Head

11. Craig Wayne Boyd

 

12. Jermaine Paul

 

13. Jake Hoot

14. Chevel Shepherd

 

 

 

15. Cassadee Pope

16. Brynn Cartelli

17. Danielle Bradbery

 

Edited by Dov

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me

 

Winners:

Tops of the top

Chloe Kohanski, Tessanne Chin

 

Then

Sawyer Fredericks
Alison Porter

Maelyn Jaron

Chris Blue

Jordan Smith

Javier Colon (managed to find quite a bit on YouTube a while ago...)
 

 I accept

Josh Kaufman
Danielle Bradbury
 

And also

Cassadee Pope

Sundance Head — look, not my pick at all, but, he totally went for it.

 

Whatever

Brynn Cartelli

Chevel Shepherd

 

I don’t care to list the others

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Only watched consistenly since S13

 

13: Addison-The only other teen with such maturity and emotion in their performances was Allison from AI

14.  I've been really impressed with Brynn post show but on the show she was too green. I'll go with Jackie from team Alicia as I prefer her stylistically to Kyla

15.  McKenzie- probably the best vocalist I've seen on the show though she does overdo it

16.  Maelyn- I dont really get the emotion when she sings but obv...

17. I dunno Katie is great at her thing but kinda gimmicky. I suppose Rose

 

I think this season is shaping up to be a lot better than last.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, sneaky said:

Only watched consistenly since S13

 

13: Addison-The only other teen with such maturity and emotion in their performances was Allison from AI

14.  I've been really impressed with Brynn post show but on the show she was too green. I'll go with Jackie from team Alicia as I prefer her stylistically to Kyla

15.  McKenzie- probably the best vocalist I've seen on the show though she does overdo it

16.  Maelyn- I dont really get the emotion when she sings but obv...

17. I dunno Katie is great at her thing but kinda gimmicky. I suppose Rose

 

I think this season is shaping up to be a lot better than last.

Wrong thread

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/18/2019 at 1:14 AM, Agenator333 said:

Winners:

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbury

Tessanne Chin

Josh Kaufman

Craig Wayne Boyd

Sawyer Fredericks

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe Kohanski

Brynn Cartelli

Chevel Shepherd

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

 

 

My Rankings:

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Chris Blue

3. Chloe Kohanski

4. Sundance Head

5. Brynn Cartelli

6. Josh Kaufman

7. Jermaine Paul

8. Cassadee Pope

9. Danielle Bradbery

10. Jordan Smith

11. Chevel Shepherd

12. Tessanne Chin

13. Alisan Porter

14. Sawyer Fredericks

15. Javier Colon

16. Craig Wayne Boyd

17. Jake Hoot

1. Chloe 

2. Alisan Porter

 

the rest

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1a. Matt McAndrew (because he is the real

season 7 winner 😘)

1b. Cassadee Pope
2. Brynn Cartelli

3. Maelyn Jarmon 

 

^those were all my top fave of their seasons

 

4. Chloe Kohanski

5. Jordan Smith
6. Danielle Bradbery

7. Alison Porter

8. Chevel Shepherd

9. Josh Kaufman 

 

^liked all of these as well 

 

10. Tessanne Chin 

11. Javier Colon

12. Sawyer Fredricks

13. Chris Blue 

 

^all decent even if not always my style 

 

14. Jake Hoot (by default. I missed last season so have no clue who he is)

 

15. Jermaine Paul

16. Sundance Head 
 

^gross 

 

17. Craig Wayne Boyd 🤢🤢🤢


^absolutely revolting/worst winner 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...