Jump to content

Top 11 Power Ranking - Buy, Sell, or Hold


TeamAudra
 Share

Recommended Posts

If Voice contestants were stocks....

 

1. Hoot - The only country singer, stream bonus, sings well enough live. HOLD

2. Katie - She could easily win it all. Great personality, and clearly talented. The audience has taken to her. HOLD

3. Marybeth - She's in a precarious position. She might have peaked too soon, and may bite off more than she can chew with future song choices. SELL

4. Rose - I'm not convinced she can get into the finale via PV, but they will likely set her up to sing her way in. BUY

5. Ricky Duran - He doesn't seem to be catching on with the audience, but Team Blake has only been shut out of the finale once in 16 seasons. HOLD

6. Kat - I want her to do well, but I honestly don't think she's very good. However, she seems to have a decent amount of support, and she's Blake's bae. She'll have to step it up a lot to have a shot at the finale. HOLD

7. Hello Sunday - I didn't think they'd make it this far, but here we are. HOLD

8. Joana - I'm chalking up her appearance in the B3 to the terrible song choice. Her save performance was very good. BUY

9. Myracle - Another victim of a bad song choice, but I don't think she has as much upside as Joana SELL

10. Will - I think he's teetering on the edge of elimination SELL

11. Shane - I'm just gonna keep putting him on the bottom until he goes home. SELL

Edited by TeamAudra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's the difference between Buy and Hold?

 

So, typically when buy/sell/holds are done, either prices or odds or given. So would you buy the stock (if you think they are undervalued), sell the stock (if you think it is overvalued) or hold the stock (if you think it is appropriately valued). Instead, I'd suggest using the rankings TA gave. If you think the contestant will do better than the placement they're given, you'd buy. If you think it's accurate/close to accurate, you'd hold. If you think they'll do worse, you'd sell

Edited by Djsoke
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's the difference between Buy and Hold?

 

Buy:

 

If I think someone is on the rise, I'm buying more. For example, I'm buying more Joana stock, because I think she's undervalued, due to the poor song choice. There's definitely some risk there, because Gwen might give her another bad song next week.

 

Hold:

 

If I already own stock in a contestant who seems to be holding steady, I'm just going to hold onto it for now. For example, Ricky seems to be middling, and I can probably buy his stock at a reasonable price, but he needs to do more to stand out first. I'm definitely not selling, because he's consistent and he's on Blake's team.

 

Sell:

 

Self explanatory. Example...I'm cashing out of Marybeth stock while her value is high. Taking my profit and running as fast as I can. If she remains high on the ranking in future weeks, that's fine, because I already sold high. I'm selling all of my Shane Q stock in a fire sale. He's a penny stock.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The hell does "penny stock" mean?

 

pen·ny stock

noun

a common stock valued at less than one dollar, and therefore highly speculative.

 

--

 

Sometimes you can make a lot of money on penny stocks, but Shane Q likely isn't one of those. If you disagree, go all in on Shane Q stock, and he ends up winning, you might be able to retire at a young age.

Edited by TeamAudra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Katie- BUY

2. Jake Hoot -SELL (Heck why not, he’s likely getting second or winning anyways but I just wanna do this for a risk taker thing)

3. Kat Hammock-BUY

4. Rose Short-BUY

5. MaryBeth-HOLD

6. Hello Sunday-HOLD

7. Ricky Duran-HOLD

8. Myracle Holloway- BUY

9. Joana Martinez-SELL

10. Will Breman-HOLD

11. Shane Q-SELL

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Katie- BUY

2. Jake Hoot -SELL (Heck why not, he’s likely getting second or winning anyways but I just wanna do this for a risk taker thing)

3. Kat Hammock-BUY

4. Rose Short-BUY

5. MaryBeth-HOLD

6. Hello Sunday-HOLD

7. Ricky Duran-HOLD

8. Myracle Holloway- BUY

9. Joana Martinez-SELL

10. Will Breman-HOLD

11. Shane Q-SELL

 

Actually, that’s not a risky play. You’re selling Jake high. If he wins, all that means is you left a little money on the table, but now you can take those profits and buy even more shares of Myracle on the cheap. :)

 

What it really means is you’re not convinced Jake will win or finish in 2nd. I actually changed my Jake play from Buy to Hold.

Edited by TeamAudra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually, that’s not a risky play. You’re selling Jake high. If he wins, all that means is you left a little money on the table, but now you can take those profits and buy even more shares of Myracle on the cheap. :)

 

What it really means is you’re not convinced Jake will win or finish in 2nd. I actually changed my Jake play from Buy to Hold.

Yeah that’s true. I mean it seems like he has the finale on lock but I’m not sure about how far in the finale. I mean what’s really making me doubt he’s winning is IDF is predicting him to win. Bar last season, IDF has usually been wrong about it since S11 or S12

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if I want to Short Shane?

Short?

 

You can, but it’s a good thing you didn’t do it last week!

 

In all seriousness, what if we have a Chris Kroeze situation here? He could squeak by for another week or two if he isn’t terrible.

I mean comparing Chris Kroeze to Shane is like comparing Bruce Springsteen to Justin Beiber

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Short?

I mean comparing Chris Kroeze to Shane is like comparing Bruce Springsteen to Justin Beiber

 

I’ll concede that Chris is much better than Shane. I was only comparing their low social media numbers and mystery voters. If Shane gets the streaming bonus next week, it will be time to start worrying. :teehee:

Edited by TeamAudra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Power ranking...not my personal preference.

1. Katie Kaden (buy) - She's the one TPTB want to win imo. To Katie's credit, she hasn't done anything to not warrant it. It won't be cheap, but I'm buying all the Katie I can get.

2. Jake Hoot (sell) - Ranked here bc he's the last country act, but some things this season might indicate the country mafia is slipping. I think its more like he slips to 3 or 4 than climbs to 1...so I'm cashing out.

3. Marybeth Byrd (sell) - I like her...her SM numbers are good...but for me, she the most likely of the real contenders to flop any given week. Too risky.

4. Ricky Duran (hold) - Holding seems like the only option here. Ricky is solid as rock, but forgettable imo. Safe investment.

5. Kat Hammock (hold) - Blake's fav, which is usually a ticket to the finale, but this is a weird season so I'll hold until later.

6. Rose Short (buy) - Ranked here bc of the disadvantages she faces on the show (AA female, Gwen) but I'm betting if anyone can break the curse, it's her. Potential huge earnings here.

7. Joana (buy) - She has the potential for a showstopper performance imo. With a few above her kinda stuck in neutral...im buying Joana

8. HS (buy) - I'm forced to buy here...but not aggressively.

9. Myracle Hollaway (sell) - Capable vocalist...but I'm not taking any chances. Anyways...I have to pay for Katie and Rose somehow.

10.Will Breman (sell) - I understand Will's appeal...and I think he could last another week...but no more easy outs after that.

11. Shane Q (hold) - Might as well hold this stock bc I ain't getting anything for it anyway, amirite? If he somehow lasts another week or two I make a few bucks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Power ranking...not my personal preference.

1. Katie Kaden (buy) - She's the one TPTB want to win imo. To Katie's credit, she hasn't done anything to not warrant it. It won't be cheap, but I'm buying all the Katie I can get.

2. Jake Hoot (sell) - Ranked here bc he's the last country act, but some things this season might indicate the country mafia is slipping. I think its more like he slips to 3 or 4 than climbs to 1...so I'm cashing out.

3. Marybeth Byrd (sell) - I like her...her SM numbers are good...but for me, she the most likely of the real contenders to flop any given week. Too risky.

4. Ricky Duran (hold) - Holding seems like the only option here. Ricky is solid as rock, but forgettable imo. Safe investment.

5. Kat Hammock (hold) - Blake's fav, which is usually a ticket to the finale, but this is a weird season so I'll hold until later.

6. Rose Short (buy) - Ranked here bc of the disadvantages she faces on the show (AA female, Gwen) but I'm betting if anyone can break the curse, it's her. Potential huge earnings here.

7. Joana (buy) - She has the potential for a showstopper performance imo. With a few above her kinda stuck in neutral...im buying Joana

8. HS (buy) - I'm forced to buy here...but not aggressively.

9. Myracle Hollaway (sell) - Capable vocalist...but I'm not taking any chances. Anyways...I have to pay for Katie and Rose somehow.

10.Will Breman (sell) - I understand Will's appeal...and I think he could last another week...but no more easy outs after that.

11. Shane Q (hold) - Might as well hold this stock bc I ain't getting anything for it anyway, amirite? If he somehow lasts another week or two I make a few bucks.

 

Slightly different than mine, but I can’t really argue with any of it. It’s a crapshoot!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

If Voice contestants were stocks....

 

1. Hoot - The only country singer, stream bonus, sings well enough live. HOLD

2. Katie - She could easily win it all. Great personality, and clearly talented. The audience has taken to her. HOLD

3. Marybeth - She's in a precarious position. She might have peaked too soon, and may bite off more than she can chew with future song choices. SELL

4. Rose - I'm not convinced she can get into the finale via PV, but they will likely set her up to sing her way in. BUY

5. Ricky Duran - He doesn't seem to be catching on with the audience, but Team Blake has only been shut out of the finale once in 16 seasons. HOLD

6. Kat - I want her to do well, but I honestly don't think she's very good. However, she seems to have a decent amount of support, and she's Blake's bae. She'll have to step it up a lot to have a shot at the finale. HOLD

7. Hello Sunday - I didn't think they'd make it this far, but here we are. HOLD

8. Joana - I'm chalking up her appearance in the B3 to the terrible song choice. Her save performance was very good. BUY

9. Myracle - Another victim of a bad song choice, but I don't think she has as much upside as Joana SELL

10. Will - I think he's teetering on the edge of elimination SELL

11. Shane - I'm just gonna keep putting him on the bottom until he goes home. SELL

 

Bumping this. I feel pretty good about my decision to hold Katie, Ricky and Jake, buy Rose, and sell Marybeth. My only big flop was buying Joana, even though she did make it another week. I'll take it.

Edited by TeamAudra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bumping this. I feel pretty good about my decision to hold Katie, Ricky and Jake, buy Rose, and sell Marybeth. My only big flop was buying Joana, even though she did make it another week. I'll take it.

 

Looks good. In Joana's case, she probably should have lasted at least one more week, but that's the voters for ya.

 

As all signs point toward him finishing no worse than 2nd, now is about the time I would be regretting selling Jake.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...