The Voice S17 Poll: Worst Elimination So Far, Best Save/Steal, Worst Save/Steal

[dirActing]

Two more eliminations last night, at least one a surprise, a controversial bottom 3 to say the least, and the first Instant Save winner of the season ... time to update this poll! (Btw, since next week is a single elimination week, I'll skip that and revisit this poll after the Top 10 double elimination.)

 

So, who do you think could or should have made the Top 11, instead of the ones we have? What would your ultimate or dream Top 11 be, if we had a S17 re-do? Also, who do you think WILL be eliminated next? And who do you think SHOULD by eliminated next week who isn't Shane Q?

[Thoughts and Sounds]

For me, even though the results were surprising/not ideal, none of these choices change.

 

Marina is still the most undeserved elimination

Shane is still the most undeserved save

 

So, who do you think could or should have made the Top 11, instead of the ones we have? What would your ultimate or dream Top 11 be, if we had a S17 re-do? Also, who do you think WILL be eliminated next? And who do you think SHOULD by eliminated next week who isn't Shane Q?

 

All of these could be threads on their own Answers pending...

 

IMO, the appropriate eliminations would have been Shane Q and... Will

 

The dream top 11 is difficult for sure.

I'd keep all of team Gwen, + Katie, Marybeth, Ricky. I guess I'd then add Marina, Kyndal, Khalea, Kiara, and Elise Azkoul. Probably in that order too.

 

Shane has to be the answer to both of the last questions. I'd be dumbfounded if he makes it through again. Though because only one person is eliminated next week, it's possible he can sneak through depending on how bad some songchoices are.

Edited November 21, 2019 by Djsoke

[purpleprairiedog]

1. Dane & Stephanie / Gracee - D&S were really solid, same with their blind, so I wish they could have gotten saved/stolen

 

Gracee wasn't her best that night, but she was one of my favorites, so I would still pick her in the WC vote

 

2. Joana, she was amazing and if she went home that early, that would be stupid :*

 

3. Shane was bad

[echoap]

Easiest poll of my life.

 

Worst elimination: Mendeleyev.

John Legend only had one job this season, and he failed us.

 

Best save/steal: Joana

She's got potential to save Gwen's ass. Isn't going to happen though, TPTB hate her.

 

Worst Save/Steal: Shane Q

This guy is not prepared for this show. At all.

[Rodney]

Worst Elimination: Injoy Fountain. She owned that Battle, but Kelly decides to save Alex, who was clearly, heavily inferior. Even he was confused by it, which shows how awful that choice was. (I mean, I guess she was trying to play Pharrell's stupid game of dropping the stronger one so he or she can be stolen, but that carries risk, and she learned that the hard way. Why play that game when Gwen already had Rose and Myracle, and John hate Katie, Khalea, Zoe, and Destiny? Blake . . . was also weird for not going for her since he had no one like her, but still, Kelly was an idiot.)

 

Best Steal: Joana Martinez for her Knockout. She edged Ricky Duran out to me, and I'm sorry that Blake couldn't see it. I appreciated Gwen giving her a second chance.

 

Worst Save: Melinda Rodriguez. The source who spilled her save said that he didn't know why she had been, and I agreed after watching the Battle. She was all right, but nothing special to deserve a save.