Jump to content

The Voice 17 ● Live Top 13 Performances ● Discussion


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 586
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

My stream cut out before Rose started singing :angry: so I missed the start where I'm reading something went wrong? Guess I'll have to watch the vid, but the 80% I did catch was superb. Some of the technical stuff in the middle section was vocally astounding. Off the chain stuff. Not "Big White Room" great, but she doesn't need that yet till we get to the Top 8 bloodbath. Performances like this should see her through to that stage comfortably. Her personality is endearing and infectious. You just want to like her, and I do, very much. Wasn't she supposed to wear a different dress, a gold-ish baroque one? Katie and Rose are the indisputable powerhouses of this season. Katie is sort of a half-rock vocalist, if that makes sense, so more raw/less technical compared to Rose (that's not a bad thing). Rose is the best pure technical vocalist in the competition. The best technical vocalist doesn't always win, but if she puts her big heart and personality out there with them vocals, who knows...

 

1. Rose/Katie

3. Marybeth

4. Kat/Joana

6. Cali

7. Jake

8. Ricky/Myracle

10. Max

11. Hello Sunday

12. Will/Shane

 

Should be bottom 3: Hello Sunday, Will, Shane.

Probable bottom 3: Myracle, Hello Sunday, Will.

 

Reshuffle at the top after re-watching Rose and Marybeth:

 

1. Rose/Katie

3. Marybeth

4. Kat/Joana

6. Cali

7. Jake

8. Ricky/Myracle

10. Max

11. Hello Sunday

12. Will/Shane

 

Should be bottom 3: Hello Sunday, Will, Shane.

Probable bottom 3: Myracle, Hello Sunday, Will.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I was following the thread without the stream, and there's a serious disconnect between the comments and the performances I watched lol.

 

MB's performance was affected by her emotions, but if anything it'll get her more votes. She's 100% safe.

this is IDF what did you expect about the comments, good judgements? IPB Image

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I have listened to that song in particular a ton and she is not in Kacey's league at all. People are either just happy that it wasn't a complete train wreck like last week or they aren't familiar enough with Kacey like they should be.

 

Or...they aren't comparing Cali to Kasey, which no one should. It's a little harsh to drag Cali bc she wasn't as good as the superstar, original artist imo. We'd have to drag everybody if that's the criteria...including Marybeth.

Edited by ATX29
Link to post
Share on other sites

Or...they aren't comparing Cali to Kasey, which no one should. It's a little harsh to drag Cali bc she wasn't as good as the superstar, original artist imo. We'd have to drag everybody if that's the criteria...including Marybeth.

 

Those are the risks you take when you sing songs like this though. It's a risk / reward situation. She will be fine this week though since so many people were way worse than her.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Those are the risks you take when you sing songs like this though. It's a risk / reward situation. She will be fine this week though since so many people were way worse than her.

Kacey Musgraves is good but it’s not like her songs are untouchable like you’re making them out to be. It’s as if you’re thinking Kacey is the next Whitney Houston or Prince

Link to post
Share on other sites

Those are the risks you take when you sing songs like this though. It's a risk / reward situation. She will be fine this week though since so many people were way worse than her.

 

True and as already stated...I do think it's deceptively hard to pull off a Kasey song. Looking back objectively, I'd say there were at the very least 5 acts that were much worse than Cali...so yeah, she should be ok this week.

Link to post
Share on other sites

True and as already stated...I do think it's deceptively hard to pull off a Kasey song. Looking back objectively, I'd say there were at the very least 5 acts that were much worse than Cali...so yeah, she should be ok this week.

 

Yeah I agree with all of this it's a lot harder to pull off then one would think especially that song. Shane, HS, Will, Joanna, Myracle were all worse than her so yeah shes fine for now.

Link to post
Share on other sites

True and as already stated...I do think it's deceptively hard to pull off a Kasey song. Looking back objectively, I'd say there were at the very least 5 acts that were much worse than Cali...so yeah, she should be ok this week.

 

This is true. I went in expecting it to not be good, so the bar wasn’t high for me in the first place. I just don’t think she has the vocal control to pull off that song. She should be singing Fleetwood Mac and similar, like a lot of us expected. Stay away from songs that require her to dip in and out of her head voice, at the very least.

Edited by TeamAudra
Link to post
Share on other sites

This is true. I went in expecting it to not be good, so the bar wasn’t high for me in the first place. I just don’t think she has the vocal control to pull off that song. She should be singing Fleetwood Mac and similar, like a lot of us expected. Stay away from songs that require her to dip in and out of her head voice, at the very least.

 

Def agree on what she should be singing. Guess it's unpop but I liked Cali more than most of the others last night...but to be fair that could be due to the song bc I just adore everything about Kasey.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...