Jump to content
idolforums.com
Sign in to follow this  
FutureSurvivor

🌹Rose Short Fan Thread🌹

Recommended Posts

CTk8nWjGciM

 

A rare kind of integrity for this show. This is 100% a black vocal performance. There’s no pandering to a white audience here - the phenomenal studio version is more “polished” but doesn’t have the same impact as live. She’s doing it the way it should be done, whether it works for tv or not is irrelevant. You can tell she knows she’s not in the finale to win it so she just chose to have fun with her coach, display her personality in the original and honor her roots with the cover. I’d love to have her finish above fourth so to have some faith in the viewing audience of this show, whom is racially biased in a significant portion as we know, but if not, it was one hell of a ride and I’ll keep following her after the season for sure. (And week after week she’s glowing more and more looking so beautiful and confident)

Edited by gusta_cruz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

okay so obviously it’s upsetting to see rose’s social media/itunes numbers so low in comparison to the rest of the final 4. there’s very little hope left that she can place above 4th, let alone win. but at this point it’s no shock to me at all and we have to just accept that america is racially biased and will likely never give the win to a black woman, no matter how flawless she is. the idea of rose being the first black female winner was fun while it lasted, but was never realistic in all honesty.

 

however, when i think about it i always realize the bright sides of the situation, being that: 1. winning is usually not the best option for success outside of the show and 2. at least she made it as far on the show as she could, we got the same number of performances from her as the rest of the final 4 (+1 actually because of last week’s instant save!), and 3. since she made the finale we will be getting all of her full studios from the lives on spotify in the next few days!! :w00t: :w00t: if she hadn’t made finale we would’ve had to wait a couple months to get them according to the last few seasons.

 

so ultimately i’m happy with what we got in the end, which was a bunch of iconic performances from a queen who constantly made this season amazing and exciting to watch each week. i’m proud of rose for what she’s accomplished on the show and will definitely be following her music career after the season is over. rose is MY winner :wub::wub::wub: <3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

okay so obviously it’s upsetting to see rose’s social media/itunes numbers so low in comparison to the rest of the final 4. there’s very little hope left that she can place above 4th, let alone win. but at this point it’s no shock to me at all and we have to just accept that america is racially biased and will likely never give the win to a black woman, no matter how flawless she is. the idea of rose being the first black female winner was fun while it lasted, but was never realistic in all honesty.

 

however, when i think about it i always realize the bright sides of the situation, being that: 1. winning is usually not the best option for success outside of the show and 2. at least she made it as far on the show as she could, we got the same number of performances from her as the rest of the final 4 (+1 actually because of last week’s instant save!), and 3. since she made the finale we will be getting all of her full studios from the lives on spotify in the next few days!! :w00t: :w00t: if she hadn’t made finale we would’ve had to wait a couple months to get them according to the last few seasons.

 

so ultimately i’m happy with what we got in the end, which was a bunch of iconic performances from a queen who constantly made this season amazing and exciting to watch each week. i’m proud of rose for what she’s accomplished on the show and will definitely be following her music career after the season is over. rose is MY winner :wub::wub::wub: <3

 

This.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

okay so obviously it’s upsetting to see rose’s social media/itunes numbers so low in comparison to the rest of the final 4. there’s very little hope left that she can place above 4th, let alone win. but at this point it’s no shock to me at all and we have to just accept that america is racially biased and will likely never give the win to a black woman, no matter how flawless she is. the idea of rose being the first black female winner was fun while it lasted, but was never realistic in all honesty.

 

however, when i think about it i always realize the bright sides of the situation, being that: 1. winning is usually not the best option for success outside of the show and 2. at least she made it as far on the show as she could, we got the same number of performances from her as the rest of the final 4 (+1 actually because of last week’s instant save!), and 3. since she made the finale we will be getting all of her full studios from the lives on spotify in the next few days!! :w00t: :w00t: if she hadn’t made finale we would’ve had to wait a couple months to get them according to the last few seasons.

 

so ultimately i’m happy with what we got in the end, which was a bunch of iconic performances from a queen who constantly made this season amazing and exciting to watch each week. i’m proud of rose for what she’s accomplished on the show and will definitely be following her music career after the season is over. rose is MY winner :wub::wub::wub: <3

 

You make some really good points here. Sometimes I think fans on IDF get a little too hung up on their snowflake winning the show. It's understandable and I don't fault them, but we have to keep in mind that this is a television show and not a legitimate singing competition where the winner is likely to find any success in the industry. If you're a fan of someone on this show, about the most realistic thing you can hope for is the maximum amount of performances...and in Rose's case, we got that!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You make some really good points here. Sometimes I think fans on IDF get a little too hung up on their snowflake winning the show. It's understandable and I don't fault them, but we have to keep in mind that this is a television show and not a legitimate singing competition where the winner is likely to find any success in the industry. If you're a fan of someone on this show, about the most realistic thing you can hope for is the maximum amount of performances...and in Rose's case, we got that!

 

Absolutely, however, given the status quo, I believe having some investment in getting a black female to win is totally justified

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

okay so obviously it’s upsetting to see rose’s social media/itunes numbers so low in comparison to the rest of the final 4. there’s very little hope left that she can place above 4th, let alone win. but at this point it’s no shock to me at all and we have to just accept that america is racially biased and will likely never give the win to a black woman, no matter how flawless she is. the idea of rose being the first black female winner was fun while it lasted, but was never realistic in all honesty.

 

however, when i think about it i always realize the bright sides of the situation, being that: 1. winning is usually not the best option for success outside of the show and 2. at least she made it as far on the show as she could, we got the same number of performances from her as the rest of the final 4 (+1 actually because of last week’s instant save!), and 3. since she made the finale we will be getting all of her full studios from the lives on spotify in the next few days!! :w00t: :w00t: if she hadn’t made finale we would’ve had to wait a couple months to get them according to the last few seasons.

 

so ultimately i’m happy with what we got in the end, which was a bunch of iconic performances from a queen who constantly made this season amazing and exciting to watch each week. i’m proud of rose for what she’s accomplished on the show and will definitely be following her music career after the season is over. rose is MY winner :wub::wub::wub: <3

Love your post.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Really, thought Rose's voice would be voted to higher than 4th. Actually, personally, I felt, of the 4, she had the highest quality voice & capability, ability for what she did with that voice.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...