Shasta357

I looooved the arrangement but then again I used to do karaoke 3-4 times a week for years and heard that song so often that I will accept ANY other rendition hahaha.

GRACE'S VOCAL WAS SPINE TINGLING SIR.

Round 1: Grace - I LOVED it. Hunter Chayce Willie Arthur Caleb

Wow Grace. The vulnerability was incredible. Legit my favorite of the Coldplay round.

Girl why you giving A- for performances you don't like! Haha

I'm glad Grace switched her song. "Hymn for the Weekend" doesn't go anywhere.

Um Caleb was literally horrible.

Agreed. Some of his vocal choices didn't fit the song very well imo.

Wow, I actually really enjoyed Chayce's performance. Casey was very meh.

I mean.. have you heard most Coldplay songs? They don't go many places.. LOL

GRACE PLEASE BE GOOD THANK YOU.

Grace is gonna slaaaaay "When We Were Young." I'm a little apprehensive about her Coldplay song choice.. but I'm equally concerned about Casey's Coldplay song choice as well. All of the guys song choices are fine, but slightly uninspired. I'm all for original songs but it could be a mistake to do an original when the first theme is narrow like singing songs from one particular group.

What in the world is this theme. I like Coldplay but an entire theme around it? Good lord. Grace NEEDS to do "The Scientist." That would slay. She could do great on "Fix You" as well. I don't want anyone touching "Yellow" that was one of my favorite performances by Alejandro!

1. Grace 2. Casey 3. Hunter 4. Willie 5. Chayce 6. Arthur 7. Caleb Grace and Casey are probably the two strongest female vocalists we've had since the ABC reboot. Sad to see Cassandra go because she was finally coming into her own.. I like Arthur more than Caleb, but don't think Arthur should be in the competition at. all.

YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Based off the spoilers the only song exciting me is Grace.. so.. if this doesn't pan out in my favor.. DRACARYS.

Arthur: Good but I don't think it is fair you are here.. Cassandra: Okay Florence! I think she has pitch issues BUT I appreciate that she is doing something different.

YES.

Agree! One of the best parts of Idol is the growth of contestants.

Oh no Cassandra

PREACH. I tried watching Rise of Skywalker at least 5 times and still can't bring myself to finish it.

So maybe tonight is just not the best. BUT for a pretty icky theme.. I'll accept an off week. I still think this group is overall the most talented we've had since the "reincarnation."

Get a bottle of tequila, a box of chocolate and watch them back to back. You will be a new man!

I love that you quoted yourself. #icon