Jump to content

joe14

Members
  • Posts

    1,314
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by joe14

  1. Hey if Louis makes it, I would have been totally current in my top 7 prediction...finding the silver lining.
  2. Louis is gonna somehow slither his way into the top 7 isn't he.
  3. For real? I only see it for Todd and Thunderstorm, none of the others stand a chance. Now there's an argument for several of the other contestants joining them in the finale.
  4. My sentiments exactly. It was not terrible but about 3/5 stars is where it should be. Julia at a 79. Just Sam at a 69. Makayla in the 60's now. Francisco falls a bit (Jonny is higher than him now for 4th. Don't know if it was like that before). Grace now has the highest standard deviation
  5. Oh okay. Did you read that somewhere. I haven't seen that. Everyone said they would cut 10 --> 5 without proof and look what happened.
  6. I'm pretty sure we are talking about normal length season in the context of American Idol on ABC (so the last two seasons). Reread the post I quoted.
  7. joe14

    Semifinals

    This is what I think will happen except swap Toneisha and Joanna.
  8. Other than Todd and Thunderstorm, I cannot really tell. I thought we would have it figured out by knockouts but here we are. Third PV is up for grabs. Gun to my head I would say Micah. CamWess instant save win. You could probably switch him for Allegra idk. I don't see next week going well for Allegra for some reason. Zan, Toneisha, Megan are out in my opinion. I wanna say Joanna will probably make the middle three but that's about it.
  9. Am I the only one who thought Grace just didn't sing it well. She might be the only person I thought had a better performance last week. Her and Makayla would have benefited from a song switch. I doubt anyone is thinking back to katherine's version from like 15 years ago while making the prediction. Lionel's "stay in your lane" comment was just a polite way of saying "you are not a belter. Let's not start now." Her score is not that shocking.
  10. Her standard deviation shows just this lmao. Some thought it was the best while others thought it was terrible lol.
  11. No offense but this post is really dramatic. I like Toneisha but she had zero chance of winning, especially with Todd on the same team. It just wasn't/isn't happening. I really don't know what to believe. Every time I give the show the benefit of the doubt in terms of letting the contestants choose their song choices, it comes out that they are an active participant in picking songs for the contestant. Giving them a short list and letting them choose is not what I mean by choice. I feel like Idol is much better at letting contestants pick their own songs. There is rarely a time I question songs on Idol. You can tell cause a lot of them pick obscure songs that actually coincide with their style.
  12. Either way...acting like Tate just had an off day and Roderick got lucky is pretty laughable.
  13. Awful take. His knockout was pretty great. Let's not act like Tate ever stood a chance lmao. Lol luck
  14. I think Michael could beat Joanna in a WC scenario
  15. Not tryna jump to any conclusions cause it could still be Zan but I called CamWess getting the public vote over Zan about two weeks ago. Nothing has shown me Zan has any significant support. John stealing him is probably the best thing that could have happened to him.
  16. huh either way they aren't fully picking their songs...at least if they were we could blame them for poor song choices. You couldn't convince me that half of the contestants wanted to sing the songs they ended up singing tonight.
  17. It's pretty much known they don't pick their songs. I think Todd had her beat no matter what. She is gonna struggle with the at home format cause her voice fits the big stage. I do not get intimacy from her voice
  18. I missed the discussion tonight but was the obvious autotuning talked about on here.. I watched Megan's performance first and although nice, it was obvious. Then CamWess and Micah's performances basically gave it away to me. The performances seem very processed.
  19. Honestly thinking about it Makayla and Grace should have switched songs
  20. She could probably pass like one other person but there is no way she is jumping 4 people
  21. It's cute you think she is making it past the top 10
  22. There should be a poll but 1. Julia 2. Jovin 3. Makalya 4. Just Sam 5. Arthur 6. Francesico 7. Jonny 8. Louis 9. Gracee 10. Sophia 11. Dillon I genuinely enjoyed 1-7. A lot of those performances are probably interchangeable. That would be my ideal 7. The rest were okay but someone has to be at the bottom.
×
×
  • Create New...