-
Posts
1,323 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
1
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Articles
Everything posted by Carrie_On
-
I’m guessing she was their first alternate. Her audition was very well-received by viewers so maybe that’s why she was chosen as his replacement. The show just edited things like she had never gotten eliminated during the showcase round. Her edit was very similar to Elleigh’s from this season. None of her HW performances were aired and she was announced as a semifinalist in a montage (they did show a clip of her Showstoppers performance but no footage of her actually being told by the judges that she’d made the Top 24, since she originally hadn’t.)
-
Season 19 was pretty crazy. - This was the season Benson Boone “Booner’d” after making the Top 24 and was replaced by Anilee List. The show tried to edit things like Benson had never made the Top 24 but IdolManiac had evidence that he did. - Cecil was arrested for domestic violence after he got eliminated. - Caleb Kennedy was disqualified at Top 5 after a short video of him and a friend wearing white sheets over their heads with eyeholes cut in them surfaced. His mom claimed it had nothing to do with the KKK and it was actually a ‘The Strangers’ mask but he was removed anyway (thank God.) - Wyatt Pyke dropped out for personal reasons during the live shows. - Hannah Everhart used racial slurs online and defended herself by saying she was mixed races? (I can’t remember the exact details about this one.) - Arthur Gunn from S18 being voted back into the competition and then his Sheryl Crow trailer drama. There’s probably more that I’m forgetting. This was the season that aired in 2021 so Covid was still a pretty big deal.
-
Thank you for sharing your story. I have no sympathy for child abusers and even if this guy has changed, he still needs to pay the price for the trauma he has caused you. Like I said before, I don’t think this is anything Will can be disqualified for but I will not be able to support him if he continues to associate with a known pedophile.
-
Yeah TBH if this Will stuff was the tea that IdolManiac had to spill, I was gonna be like "That sucks to hear but it's pretty lame and won't really hurt Will's chances at all." I mean if Will knowingly associates with a pedophile, it'll make me look at him differently but I don't think it's grounds for disqualification or anything. The fact that we have something even crazier coming is insane.
-
American Idol Unpopular Opinions Thread
Carrie_On replied to countrynineteen's topic in American Idol
I also like Jelly Roll and I hope that he’s one of the judges they go with if they decide to get all new judges next season.