KelseyW

IF Caleb is eliminated no F bombs tonight.  I'll just be in shock...

MINUTES.

WHY. Has no one sung songs from this??? Like. It's Disney. It's good music. IDK.  

Sing Sweet Nightingale is so underrated... It's a really beautiful song!

NOOOO. I WANTED HERCULES...  lol

She going to make me cry... :') 

3 hours ago, MargoK said:

Arthur Gunn could crap on stage and still be praised and get lots of votes.

To be fair. Talent always seems to be a good leading controller with ABC Idols. Like. It's Casey's to lose but anyone's game if that makes sense?

Casey!! I am determined to get Idol's first rocker girl. To be fair... My AI at ABC track record so far...

1. Maddie Poppe (Cade was my early favorite...) - WINNER.

2. Alejandro Aranda- Runner Up

3. Arthur Gunn- Runner Up

So far so good...  

I actually feel for Makayla and Louis... Sigh.

Bumping because I love your art!

1 minute ago, MargoK said:

Crap!!! Anything about who is singing what songs?

I haven't seen song spoilers yet! Is tomorrow live or pre-taped? Anyone know? 

Another new music video!! 
 

Just now, laumopera said:

I also have a feeling that Casey will win anyway. It would be interesting if Arthur Gunn ends up as a runner up again!

 

 

 

I kinda hope he's a shock boot... He was already runner up. Shouldn't have been allowed back. IMO And I'm a FAN.  

3 hours ago, MargoK said:

No posts from MJs blog.

???

They just posted it on Twitter. Idol TIP. 

It's Arthur Gunn...

Great...

Now everyone shut up about it and watch Casey win anyway... lol

Please be singing the Cinderella or Hercules songs... PLEASE. lol

On 4/19/2021 at 12:33 AM, augustgrl82 said:

They were my favorite boy band growing up. I still have all my magazine articles. I follow them of facebook but don't keep up what they are up to. I finally saw them live for the first time a few years ago. 

Awesome welcome!  

So excited to see her on my T.V. this weekend!

Happy 29th Allison!!

2 hours ago, redwood79 said:

Oh, does the comeback contestant not get to go?

My guess is nope.

5 hours ago, Elliott said:

I'm the Only One was good. But regardless, she was still liked by the judges which was what the question was asking.

 

And nah, Allison was definitely not a judges' favourite. Though they liked her more than Kris, Simon in particular nitpicked her for the most mundane things. They pretty much only started to give her half-hearted compliments when it got midway through the finals and the only women left were her and Lil.

I guess what I mean by judges fave applies to all the girls I liked on Idol not named Melinda. lol Siobhan, Haley, Allison, Carly. Ect.

I see the younger rockers are rare. Carly wasn't that old at the time. Mid 20's? Allison was a freshly turned 17 and Haley was 20...Siobhan? 19-20 I think.

My point being? Casey has something that the judges really think she can sail through with and maybe even be successful with post-show. I agree with that.

I guess yinz answered my question. lol Thanks.

I still demand my Kradison Top 3 on a magazine but that will never happen again in my lifetime...  

Not necessarily an unpopular opinion but...

Is Casey the first rocker girl to actually be liked by the judges/get support from them?

I loved Allison in season 8 and if she had just a little bit of what Casey must have (And no I'm not talking about likability. lol) I think she would've made Top 3 over Gokey...

I still think that's why T.V. Guide didn't cover the top 3 on their magazine cover that year. Season 7 was the last time we got this...