Elliott's S11 Lists, Maybe I'll finish this one? Options

[fedifan91]

25. George Huff. - Jeremy Rosado
24. A finalist. - Jermaine Jones
23. Also a finalist. HeeJun Han
22. Dream On. - Adam Brock
21. One of the country contestants. - Baylie Brown

[jstxanothrxstory]

ELLIOTT RANKS THE TOP 25 | 25-21


25 | BRIELLE "MY MOM RUINED MY CHANCES" VON HUGEL | 16TH
CLUE EXPLANATION: One of (imo) George Huff's best performances was Sittin' on the Dock of the Bay.

PRE-SEASON RANKING: 13 (-12)

I liked her well enough originally, but... seriously, Steven? Sitting on the Dock of the Bay was horrible and Someone Like You was even worse.


24 | JEREMY "I DON'T EVEN REMEMBER ME" ROSADO | 13TH
CLUE EXPLANATION: Pretty self explanatory.

PRE-SEASON RANKING: 21 (-3)

Meh. He was forgettable.


23 | HEEJUN "REALLY, AMERICA? " HAN | 9TH
CLUE EXPLANATION: Also self explanatory.

PRE-SEASON RANKING: 19 (-4)

Really, America? You voted for him over Erika Van Perfection? At least he left after his best week, but seriously. Erika Van Pelt? For reals?


22 | ADAM "HERSHEY'S COOKIES N CREAM" BROCK | 25TH
CLUE EXPLANATION: He was compared to Danny Gokey.

PRE-SEASON RANKING: 15 (-7)

I liked him well enough, but he's moved down since I wasn't huge over Think and my like for him was mostly to go against IDF.


21 | CHELSEA "I WAS CLEARLY FODDER" SORRELL | 25TH
CLUE EXPLANATION: Again, self explanatory.

PRE-SEASON RANKING: 25 (+4)

I'm actually not sure why she's over Adam Brock. Whatever, I'm too lazy to change it now. Since I ranked her last at the start of the season and didn't like Cowboy Casanova, she lands here.


CLUES:
Beyoncé.
Cursed song.
IDF considered them robbed.
M M.

This post has been edited by jstxanothrxstory: May 17th 2012, 5:06 PM

[hazuki]

Don't care for many of them. Heejun was funny.

[jstxanothrxstory]

I hope Jessica at least makes your Top 12. Curious to see this list, although I know your Top 4.

Clues:
25. George Huff. This better not mean Skylar (she was huffed)
24. A finalist. Jermaine?
23. Also a finalist. Jeremy?
22. Dream On. Steven I don't get this one
21. One of the country contestants. Chelsea? Chase?

You got two right.

You must have the wrong person's list then.

JK Elliott. Please don't put Jessica at #25 now. I was just joking.

brb going back in time to power vote for Joshua over Jessica.

This post has been edited by jstxanothrxstory: May 17th 2012, 5:04 PM

[jstxanothrxstory]

Don't care for many of them. Heejun was funny.

I guess. I was over it after Top 10 week though.

[totes4totes]

Beyoncé. - Jessica
Cursed song.- DeAndre
IDF considered them robbed. - That one girl that was named Jen or something
M M. - Joshua

Brielle. I am going to redo S11 and she is going to make the Top 13 or whatever
Jeremy. Whatevs
Heejun. I liked him a lot. AND PHILLIP DID TOO
Adam. WHO IS THIS?
Chelsea. She's pretty. I don't know I didn't watch really anything from her.

[jstxanothrxstory]

Beyoncé. - Jessica
Cursed song.- DeAndre
IDF considered them robbed. - That one girl that was named Jen or something
M M. - Joshua

Brielle. I am going to redo S11 and she is going to make the Top 13 or whatever
Jeremy. Whatevs
Heejun. I liked him a lot. AND PHILLIP DID TOO
Adam. WHO IS THIS?
Chelsea. She's pretty. I don't know I didn't watch really anything from her.

Interesting guesses.

Brielle - Of course she is.
Jeremy -
HeeJun -
Adam -
Chelsea - Pretty much.

[totes4totes]

Brielle - Of course she is.

She and Haley both are.

My Top 13 is going to be so interesting.

[*Wallace]

25: LOL Oh Brielle. I wanted to like her but I felt she tried too hard. I didn't like either of her performances... although sometimes I have a guilty pleasure with SLY. It was so bad but I just love watching it for some reason.

24: Aww I like Jeremy and think he has a really nice voice.

23: I love Heejun's personality. I liked him at the start before the Top 24 rounds but most of his performances were blah/forgettable/whatever... all but one of them were. He shouldn't have made it as far as he did based on his voice. So yeah he was annoying me for how long he lasted but I am over that now and like him again.

22: Meh... I liked Adam alright but his "Think"was terrible and I was over him after that.

21: Chelsea is gorgeous. I kinda liked her CC performance but meh, I was never attached to her, so whatevs.


CLUES:
Beyoncé.: Jessica Sanchez.
Cursed song.: Hmm not sure. Too lazy to think tbh. Ooh maybe Hallie Day or Haley Johnson? Going with Hallie.
IDF considered them robbed: Jen Hirsh? Aaron?
M M.: Don't know.. Joshua? Jermaine?

[jstxanothrxstory]

She and Haley both are.

My Top 13 is going to be so interesting.

I think I'll have Haley make mine too. Solely because she's singing the arrangement of Sweet Dreams she posted to YouTube. /spoiler

25: LOL Oh Brielle. I wanted to like her but I felt she tried too hard. I didn't like either of her performances... although sometimes I have a guilty pleasure with SLY. It was so bad but I just love watching it for some reason.

24: Aww I like Jeremy and think he has a really nice voice.

23: I love Heejun's personality. I liked him at the start before the Top 24 rounds but most of his performances were blah/forgettable/whatever... all but one of them were. He shouldn't have made it as far as he did based on his voice. So yeah he was annoying me for how long he lasted but I am over that now and like him again.

22: Meh... I liked Adam alright but his "Think"was terrible and I was over him after that.

21: Chelsea is gorgeous. I kinda liked her CC performance but meh, I was never attached to her, so whatevs.

CLUES:
Beyoncé.: Jessica Sanchez.
Cursed song.: Hmm not sure. Too lazy to think tbh.
IDF considered them robbed: Jen Hirsh? Aaron?
M M.: Don't know.. Joshua? Jermaine?

25. You wanted to like her? Which means you didn't actually like her? Who are you and what have you done with Wallace?

24. Meh.

23. Yeah, I liked his personality. But him lasting so long really left a sour taste in my mouth.

22. LOL at "I was over him after that." I love brutally honest Wally.

21.

Interesting guesses. LOL at the eye rolling in that first guess.

[*Wallace]

25. You wanted to like her? Which means you didn't actually like her? Who are you and what have you done with Wallace?

24. Meh.

23. Yeah, I liked his personality. But him lasting so long really left a sour taste in my mouth.

22. LOL at "I was over him after that." I love brutally honest Wally.

21.

Interesting guesses. LOL at the eye rolling in that first guess.

- LOL She was kinda annoying sometimes. And LOL you know i don't like EVERYONE.
-
- Same here. You'd be happy to know I prefer Phillip over him.
- Oh gosh, I know you do.

Ugh please don't disappoint me like this. I do think Beyonce would be TOO obvious if it was Jessica though. And there are still so many MEH/Whatever people that have yet to be posted.

[hazuki]

Jessica this low?

[jstxanothrxstory]

- LOL She was kinda annoying sometimes. And LOL you know i don't like EVERYONE.

Ugh please don't disappoint me like this. I do think Beyonce would be TOO obvious if it was Jessica though. And there are still so many MEH/Whatever people that have yet to be posted.

-True. Considering the only person you liked in S1 was Nikki.

Jessica this low?

Like you'd have Colton much higher than this. And maybe she is, maybe she isn't.

This post has been edited by jstxanothrxstory: May 17th 2012, 7:16 PM

[*Wallace]

-True. Considering the only person you liked in S1 was Nikki.

Like you'd have Colton much higher than this.

LOL that's a good one.

[jstxanothrxstory]

Stop lying. I saw your ranking:

1. Nikki McKibbin

This post has been edited by jstxanothrxstory: May 17th 2012, 8:51 PM

[Fearless]

25. Meh.
24. Meh.
23. Godjun remains unbothered.
22. I kinda liked him, but wasn't that upset that he didn't make it through really. It did make me kind of sad though, since he seemed to want it SO bad.
21. Mehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. So mediocre.

#20 is not Jessica. Too obvious.

[jstxanothrxstory]

23. Godjun remains unbothered.

#20 is not Jessica. Too obvious.

23.

[sublymonal]

25. Brielle. Yeah, I basically agree with this placement. I might have a certain someone else lower.
24. Jeremy wouldn't be this low on my list, but I wasn't really a fan either.
23. Heejun. The only endearing thing about Heejun is his videos on facebook. Some of his performances weren't terrible but I'm still basically bleh on him.
22. Adam. Adam's song was terrible but I definitely felt like he had more potential than he showed. I wanted to like him.
21. Chelsea. Meh. Skylar and Baylie are better.

Beyoncé - Jessica Sanchez.
Cursed song - Hallie Day.
IDF considered them robbed - Aaron Marcellus.
M M -Jermaine Jones.

[jstxanothrxstory]

23. Heejun. The only endearing thing about Heejun is his videos on facebook. Some of his performances weren't terrible but I'm still basically bleh on him.
22. Adam. Adam's song was terrible but I definitely felt like he had more potential than he showed. I wanted to like him.
21. Chelsea. Meh. Skylar and Baylie are better.

Beyoncé - Jessica Sanchez.
Cursed song - Hallie Day.
IDF considered them robbed - Aaron Marcellus.
M M -Jermaine Jones.

23. Same.
22. Same.
21. Pretty much.

And hmm...

[jstxanothrxstory]

Next set coming up shortly.