Best Survivor Contestant Ever., Lets see who you think the King or Queen is. Options

[Zoey0069]

Okay, so you've probably seen a few of these games around IDF. Most have to do with American Idol or So You Think You Can Dance.. not this one! I thought there should be one made for this forum since it's pretty active and it'll keep us all entertained during the week whilst Survivor isn't on TV. It's your basic + / - game and by the end of it we'll know who IDF thinks is the Best Survivor Contestant Ever.

GUIDELINES
- Vote on who you think was the best. Whether that be personality, strategy etc. Obviously people will disagree.
- No bickering in the thread. You can disagree with peoples votes, but there isn't any need to get into a huge fight over it. Debate all you want.. just don't take it too far. Remember it's the taking part that counts
- You must have over 100 posts to take part in this game. If you see a noob voting, skip their vote and carry on.
- If you see someone's missed a vote or not voted properly - try and fix it. It helps everyone out and then we don't get confused halfway through a round.
- Read the rules at the start of each round.
- The final 2 or 3 from each round will face off in the final round.
- I start the rounds.
- You guys do the voting.


THE VOTING HISTORY

SURVIVOR: BORNEO
01. Richard Hatch
02. Sue Hawk
03. Colleen Haskell
04. Kelly Wiglesworth
05. Jenna Lewis
06. Greg Buis
07. Gretchen Cordy
08. Gervase Peterson
09. Sean Kenniff
10. Dirk Been
11. Rudy Boesch
12. Joel Klug
13. Sonja Christopher
14. Ramona Gray
15. B.B. Andersen
16. Stacey Stillman

SURVIVOR: THE AUSTRALIAN OUTBACK
01. Colby Donaldson
02. Jerri Manthey
03. Elisabeth Filarski
04. Alicia Calaway
05. Amber Brkich
06. Michael Skupin
07. Jeff Varner
08. Nick Brown
09. Rodger Bingham
10. Mitchell Olson
11. Maralyn "Mad Dog" Hershey
12. Kel Gleason
13. Kimmi Kappenberg
14. Tina Wesson
15. Debb Eaton
16. Keith Famie

SURVIVOR: AFRICA
01. Kelly Goldsmith
02. Ethan Zohn
03. Kim Powers
04. Lindsey Richter
05. Teresa Cooper
06. Clarence Black
07. Lex van den Berghe
08. Frank Garrison
09. Linda Spencer
10. Brandon Quinton
11. Kim Johnson
12. Diane Ogden
13. Silas Gaither
14. Tom Buchanan
15. Jessie Camacho
16. Carl Bilancione

.
SURVIVOR: MARQUESAS
01. Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
02. Rob Mariano
03. Paschal English
04. Neleh Dennis
05. Gina Crews
06. Hunter Ellis
07. Tammy Leitner
08. Sean Rector
09. Vecepia Towery
10. Robert DeCanio
11. Patricia Jackson
12. Gabriel Cade
13. Sarah Jones
14. John Carroll
15. Peter Harkey
16. Zoe Zanidakis

SURVIVOR: THAILAND
01. Brian Heidik
02. Jan Gentry
03. Jake Billingsley
04. Shii Ann Huang
05. Erin Collins
06. Ken Stafford
07. Robb Zbacnik
08. Tanya Vance
09. Helen Glover
10. Stephanie Dill
11. Penny Ramsey
12. John Raymond
13. Jed Hildebrand
14. Ted Rogers
15. Clay Jordan
16. Ghandia Johnson

.
SURVIVOR: AMAZON
01. Rob Cesternino
02. Matthew Von Ertfelda
03. Deena Bennett
04. Heidi Strobel
05. Jenna Morasca
06. Alex Bell
07. Christy Smith
08. Dave Johnson
09. Butch Lockley
10. Shawna Mitchell
11. Jeanne Hebert
12. Janet Koth
13. Ryan Aiken
14. Daniel Lue
15. Roger Sexton
16. Joanna Ward

SURVIVOR: PEARL ISLANDS
01. Sandra Diaz-Twine
02. Darrah Johnson
03. Ryan Opray
04. Christa Hastie
05. Rupert Boneham
06. Tijuana Bradley
07. Burton Roberts
08. Michelle Tesauro
09. Andrew Savage
10. Shawn Cohen
11. Nicole Delma
12. Trish Dunn
13. Jonny Fairplay
14. Ryan Shoulders
15. Lillian Morris
16. Osten Taylor

.
SURVIVOR: ALLSTARS
01. Rob Mariano
02. Shii-Ann Huang
03. Amber Brkich
04. Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
05. Rob Cesternino
06. Ethan Zohn
07. Jerri Manthey
08. Colby Donaldson
09. Tom Buchanan
10. Jenna Morasca
11. Rupert Boneham
12. Tina Wesson
13. Sue Hawk
14. Alicia Calaway
15. Jenna Lewis
16. Richard Hatch
17. Lex van den Berghe
18. Rudy Boesch

SURVIVOR: VANUATU
01. Eliza Orlins
02. Julie Berry
03. Ami Cussack
04. Chris Daugherty
05. Chad Crittenden
06. Leann Slaby
07. Rory Freeman
08. Brady Finta
09. Lisa Keiffer
10. Twila Tanner
11. Brook Geraghty
12. John Palyok
13. Dolly Neely
14. Travis "Bubba" Sampson
15. Mia Galeotalanza
16. John Kenney
17. Lea "Sarge" Masters
18. Scout Cloud Lee

.
SURVIVOR: PALAU
01. Tom Westman
02. Jenn Lyon
03. Stephenie LaGrossa
04. Ian Rosenberger
05. Katie Gallagher
06. Bobby Jon Drinkard
07. Coby Archa
08. Angie Jakusz
09. Jeff Wilson
10. Ashlee Ashby
11. Jonathan Libby
12. Kim Mullen
13. Wanda Shirk
14. Janu Tornell
15. Ibrehem Rahman
16. Willard Smith
17. James Miller
18. Gregg Carey

SURVIVOR: GUATEMALA
01. Danni Boatwright
02. Stephenie LaGrossa
03. Gary Hogeboom
04. Cindy Hall
05. Brian Corridan
06. Rafe Judkins
07. Amy O'Hara
08. Lydia Morales
09. Margaret Bobonich
10. Bobby Jon Drinkard
11. Brooke Struck
12. Blake Towsley
13. Jamie Newton
14. Brandon Bellinger
15. Morgan McDevitt
16. Jim Lynch
17. Judd Sergeant
18. Brianna Varela

SURVIVOR: PANAMA
01. Danielle DiLorenzo
02. Sally Schumann
03. Cirie Fields
04. Aras Baskauskas
05. Terry Deitz
06. Misty Giles
07. Austin Carty
08. Courtney Marit
09. Shane Powers
10. Nick Stanbury
11. Ruth-Marie Milliman
12. Tina Scheer
13. Bruce Kanegai
14. Dan Barry
15. Melinda Hyder
16. Bobby Mason

SURVIVOR: COOK ISLANDS
01. Yul Kwon
02. Becky Lee
03. Sundra Oakley
04. Ozzy Lusth
05. Parvati Shallow
06. Brad Virata
07. Cecilia Mansilla
08. Adam Gentry
09. Jonathan Penner
10. Rebecca Borman
11. Candice Woodcock
12. J.P. Calderon
13. Cristina Coria
14. Nate Gonzalez
15. Jessica "Flica" Smith
16. Stephannie Favor
17. Jenny Guzon-Bae
18. Sekou Bunch
19. Anh-Tuan "Cao Boi" Bui
20. Billy Garcia

SURVIVOR: FIJI
01. Michelle Yi
02. Yau-Man Chan
03. Sylvia Kwan
04. Stacy Kimball
05. Boo Bernis
06. Liliana Gomez
07. Jessica deBen
08. Earl Cole
09. Mookie Lee
10. Edgardo Rivera
11. Rita Verreos
12. Erica Durousseau
13. Anthony Robinson
14. Cassandra Franklin
15. Lisi Linares
16. James "Rocky" Reid
17. Gary Stritesky
18. Andria "Dreamz" Herd
19. Alex Angarita

SURVIVOR: CHINA
01. Courtney Yates
02. Peih-Gee Law
03. Todd Herzog
04. Sherea Lloyd
05. Erik Huffman
06. Frosti
07.Aaron Reisberger
08.Jaime Dugan
09.Amanda Kimmel
10. Leslie Nease
11. James Clement
12. Denise Martin
13. Jean-Robert Bellande
14. Ashley Massaro
15. Steve "Chicken" Morris
16. Dave Cruser

SURVIVOR: MICRONESIA
01. Parvati Shallow
02. Natalie Bolton
03. Cirie Fields
04. Jason Siska
05. Ozzy Lusth
06. Alexis Jones
07. Eliza Orlins
08. Jonathan Penner
09. Tracy Hughes-Wolf
10. Ami Cusack
11. Erik Reichenbach
12. Mary Sartain
13. Yau-Man Chan
14. Jonny Fairplay
15. James Clement
16. Kathy Sleckman
17. Michael "Mikey B" Bortone
18. Joel Anderson
19. Amanda Kimmel
20. Chet Welch

SURVIVOR: GABON
01. Crystal Cox
02. Susie Smith
03. Sugar
04. Ken Hoang
05. Ace Gordon
06. Paloma Soto-Castillo
07. Charlie Herschel
08. Gillian Larson
09. Dan Kay
10. Michelle Chase
11. Marcus Lehman
12. Matty Whitmore
13. Jacquie Berg
14. Bob Crowley
15. Danny "GC" Brown
16. Kelly Czarnecki
17. Randy Bailey
18. Corinne Kaplan

This post has been edited by Zoey0069: Mar 1st 2011, 2:02 PM

[Zoey0069]

SURVIVOR: TOCANTINS
01. Stephen Fishbach
02. Tysojn Apostol
03. Tamara "Taj" Johnson-George
04. Erinn Lobdell
05. Debra Beebe
06. Spencer Duhm
07. Jerry Sims
08. Joe Dowdle
09. Sandy Burgin
10. Coach Wade
11. Sydney Wheeler
12. Carolina Eastwood
13. Brendan Synnott
14. Candace Smith
15. Sierra Reed
16.J.T Thomas

SURVIVOR: SAMOA
01. Natalie White
02. Brett Clouser
03. Laura Morett
04. John Fincher
05. Marisa Calihan
06. Elizabeth "Liz" Kim
07. Erik Cardona
08. Ashley Trainer
09. Jaison Robinson
10. Yasmin Giles
11. Russell Swan
12. Kelly Sharbaugh
13. Shannon "Shambo" Waters
14. Betsy Bolan
15. Dave Ball
16. Ben Browning
17. Monica Padilla
18. Russell Hantz
19. Mick Trimming
20. Mike Borassi

SURVIVOR: HEROES VS. VILLAINS
01. Sandra Diaz-Twine
02. Rob Mariano
03. Parvati Shallow
04. Jerri Manthey
05. Tom Westman
06. Courtney Yates
07. Danielle DiLorenzo
08. J.T. Thomas
09. Stephenie LaGrossa
10. Amanda Kimmel
11. Cirie Fields
12. Candice Woodcock
13. Benjamin "Coach" Wade
14. Colby Donaldson
15. Tyson Apostol
16. James Clement
17. Rupert Boneham
18. Russell Hantz
19. Randy Bailey
20. Jessica "Sugar" Kiper

SURVIVOR: NICARAGUA
01. Jud "Fabio" Birza
02. Ben "Benry" Henry
03. Alina Wilson
04. Holly Hoffman
05. Brenda Lowe
06. Kelly Bruno
07. Wendy DeSmidt-Kohlhoff
08. Yve Rojas
09. Kelly Shinn
10. Jill Behm
11. Marty Piombo
12. James "Jimmy T." Tarantino
13. Tyrone Davis
14. Matthew "Sash" Lenahan
15. Jimmy Johnson
16. Chase Rice
17. Shannon Elkins
18. NaOnka Mixon
19. Dan Lembo
20. Jane Bright

SEMI FINALS ROUND #1
???? vs. ???? vs. ????
Advanced: ?????

SEMI FINALS ROUND #2
???? vs. ???? vs. ????
Advanced: ?????

SEMI FINALS ROUND #3
???? vs. ???? vs. ????
Advanced: ?????

SEMI FINALS ROUND #4
???? vs. ???? vs. ????
Advanced: ?????

SEMI FINALS ROUND #5
???? vs. ???? vs. ????
Advanced: ?????

This post has been edited by Zoey0069: Aug 6th 2012, 2:36 PM

[Zoey0069]

I thought it'd be interesting

There isn't much chat during the week and thought it'd liven the place up aswell

[CassLou]

Are you going to do each season by season?

[Zoey0069]

Are you going to do each season by season?

I thought I'd do it like that because it would get people chatting about each season. There isn't much talk about alot of the early seasons and I'd love to hear what peoples thoughts were

We wouldn't have that if I grouped everyone together.



Then the winners of each round can face off in the final at the end

[CassLou]

I thought I'd do it like that because it would get people chatting about each season. There isn't much talk about alot of the early seasons and I'd love to hear what peoples thoughts were

We wouldn't have that if I grouped everyone together.

Yeah, I like that. If everyone was grouped into one, so many people would just get lost.

[Zoey0069]

B.B. Andersen - 9
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 10
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 10
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 10
Sonja Christopher - 10
Stacey Stillman - 10
Sue Hawk - 11

+ Sue
- B.B

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.

This post has been edited by Zoey0069: Apr 28th 2010, 8:11 PM

[CassLou]

1

B.B. Andersen - 9
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 10
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 11
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 10
Sonja Christopher - 10
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 11

+ Rich
- Stacey

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.

[reallyandtruly]

1

B.B. Andersen - 8
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 10
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 12
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 10
Sonja Christopher - 10
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 11

+ Rich
- B.B.

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.\

[Zoey0069]

2

B.B. Andersen - 7
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 10
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 12
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 10
Sonja Christopher - 10
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 12

+ Sue
- B.B.

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.

[lindsayanne]

1

B.B. Andersen - 7
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 12
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 10
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 12

+ Kelly
- Sonja

[Ninty]

1

B.B. Andersen - 7
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 13
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 9
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 12

+ Rich
- Sean

Minus Sean for the alphabet voting.

[Halale]

1

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 14
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 9
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 12

+ Richard
- BB

This post has been edited by Halale: Apr 28th 2010, 10:27 PM

[NYChica]

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 14
Rudy Boesch - 10
Sean Kenniff - 8
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 13

+Sue (for epic rats and snakes speech at FTC)
-Sean (for alphabet voting strategy)

[Zoey0069]

1

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 14
Rudy Boesch - 9
Sean Kenniff - 8
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 14

+ Sue
- Rudy

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.

[Zoey0069]

2

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 14
Rudy Boesch - 8
Sean Kenniff - 8
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 9
Sue Hawk - 15

+ Sue
- Rudy

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.

[dancecab]

1

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 15
Rudy Boesch - 8
Sean Kenniff - 8
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 8
Sue Hawk - 15

+ Rich
- Stacey

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.

[NYChica]

1

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 10
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 16
Rudy Boesch - 8
Sean Kenniff - 8
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 7
Sue Hawk - 15

+Richard
-Stacey

[topspinace09]

lol I only know of Hatch because he won.

[CassLou]

1

B.B. Andersen - 6
Colleen Haskell - 11
Dirk Been - 10
Gervase Peterson - 10
Greg Buis - 10
Gretchen Cordy - 10
Jenna Lewis - 10
Joel Klug - 10
Kelly Wiglesworth - 11
Ramona Gray - 10
Richard Hatch - 16
Rudy Boesch - 8
Sean Kenniff - 8
Sonja Christopher - 9
Stacey Stillman - 6
Sue Hawk - 15

+Colleen
-Stacey

RULES: You may vote up to 6 times a day, at least 30 minutes apart. Please number your posts.