WNTS Redux, Top 35 Group D & E page 9 Options

[Weedy Speedy]

I voted in the poll in this post above mine. Why did you list some of the guys twice?

[druth8x]

On accident. Some? I though it was just Matt Giraud/Matty G.

I would have deleted his duplicate entry and removed James (already selected) but until just now I didn't realize that I could hide the choices.

Other than those 2 mistakes. I don't see anymore duplicates or already selected.

Thanks for your vote. So glad I got another vote.

Survey Link

I'm working on the new poll right now. But feel free to still vote.

[druth8x]

The producers have just came up with a twist instead of 48 for the first round we are going with 52.

Which means no more producer voting. They looked at the voting and figured this is close enough to what you all want.

So, who all is ready for a contestant reveal?

Top 52 Contestant Reveal

This post has been edited by druth8x: Jan 31st 2012, 6:10 PM

[druth8x]

Top 52 Contestant Reveal

This post has been edited by druth8x: Jan 31st 2012, 6:11 PM

[druth8x]

Top 52 Contestant Reveal

This post has been edited by druth8x: Jan 31st 2012, 6:55 PM

[druth8x]

Top 52 Contestant Reveal

This post has been edited by druth8x: Jan 31st 2012, 6:16 PM

[druth8x]

Top 52 Contestant Reveal

As far as seasons where these contestants come from:
1: Kelly / Tamyra / Christina
2: Clay / K-Lo / Ruben / Trenyce / Caldwell
3: Latoya / Tasia / Diana / George / J-Hud
4: Bo / Nadia / Carrie / Anthony / Nikko / Baby V
5: Katherine / Daughtry / Mandisa / Elliott / Taylor / Paris / Kellie
6: Melinda / Jordin / Lakisha / Phil
7: Cook / Brooke / Johns / Archie / Carly / Castro / Syesha
8: Adam / Allison / Kris / Matty G / Alexis
9: Crystal / Casey / Siobhan
10: Haley / Pia / James / Lauren / Jacob / Thia / Scotty

31 Girls, 21 Guys

[*Wallace]

YAYAY TOP 52 Reveal.

Who is this though?

And looking through the list, I noticed a lot of Idols pictures weren't posted which really scared me because some of my favorites weren't shown. Here they are:
2: K-Lo / Caldwell
3: Diana
4: Bo / Anthony
6: Melinda / Jordin / Phil
7: Johns / Syesha
8: Adam / Allison
9: Casey
10: Scotty

But I'm thinking maybe one of your posts with their pictures didn't go through? If so that has been happening a lot to me lately. It just did as I posted this the first time.

[druth8x]

YAYAY TOP 52 Reveal.
Who is this though?

And looking through the list, I noticed a lot of Idols pictures weren't posted which really scared me because some of my favorites weren't shown. Here they are:
2: K-Lo / Caldwell
3: Diana
4: Bo / Anthony
6: Melinda / Jordin / Phil
7: Johns / Syesha
8: Adam / Allison
9: Casey
10: Scotty

But I'm thinking maybe one of your posts with their pictures didn't go through? If so that has been happening a lot to me lately. It just did as I posted this the first time.

G'd dammit all.

Now it's all going to be messed up.

That guy is Bo.


Can you change subbie to:

Top 52 Reveal

[druth8x]

Updated. Just moved each post up 1. Scratch that now I lost one.

This post has been edited by druth8x: Jan 31st 2012, 6:20 PM

[*Wallace]

G'd dammit all.

Now it's all going to be messed up.

That guy is Bo.
Can you change subbie to:

Top 52 Reveal

Aww, I hate when that happens. Been happening to me so much lately.

WHOA, I would have never guessed that. He cut his hair? Wow.

ok will do!

[druth8x]

Wally can you please figure out which 13 I messed up on my moving posts up? You did so well with the non post that I feel it should only take you a couple minutes where as with me it will take 30min to an hour.

He cut his hair quite recently. That's why it's not the best pic, not much out there yet.

It appears as if everytime I do a add reply post esp if I preview it instead of my normal fast reply that's what happens, no post goes through so I have to hit backspace on my browser and try again.


This post has been edited by druth8x: Jan 31st 2012, 7:05 PM

[druth8x]

Guess not I figured it out. Reupdating now.

2: Trenyce
3: J-Hud
4: Nadia / Carrie / Nikko
5: Paris / Kellie
8: Kris
10: Haley / James / Lauren / Jacob / Thia

[druth8x]

Ok, I believe that all is good. All 52 contestants pictures are up now.

Please comment on who you love, like, dislike, hate, wish was apart of this etc.

Also, I tried finding personality type pictures that was close to 300pixels wide. However, if you don't like a pic, I am willing to change it if you can offer a better one.

[*Wallace]

I suppose i can do some quick comments.


Siobhan: Really like her. Used to love her but not as much anymore.
Brooke: Really like her.
Tamyra: One of my all-time favorites. FLOVE..
Elliott: One of my all-time favorite males ever. LOVE him.
Mandisa: Really like her a lot.
Christina: My first Idol crush. She's faded for me over the years but I do like her.
LaKisha: I like her well enough but not a huge fan.
Katharine: FLOVE her and one of my all-time faves.
Vonzell: FLOVE her and one of my all-time faves.
Taylor: I like him but don't care much for him anymore.
La Toya: Love her a ton.
Fantasia: Love her a lot too!
Ruben: Used to love him a lot but he's faded for me over the years. Really like him.
Alexis: Really like her. So robbed.
Jason: He's cool and chill.
Pia: Love her a ton!
Crystal: Really like her but don't love her like most people.
Clay: Really like him. Great vocalist.
David C: One of my favorite guys ever. Love him!
David A: Like him a little less than Cook but he's great and really like him a lot.
Carly: Really like her.
George: He's faded a bit for me over the years but still like him a lot.
Chris: Really liked him on the show but liked him much more post-Idol/over the years.
Matt G: One of my favorite guys ever. Love him!
Kelly: Amazing Goddess. FLOVE her.
Bo: Really like him although he's kind of faded for me over the years.
Nadia: Really like her although used to love her back in the day.
Jennifer H: Love her!
James: Used to not like him but he grew on me during the season. I like him.
Treynce: Fierce. Really like her a lot.
Jacob: Kind of faded for me lately but he's really good and I really like him.
Kellie: She's grown on me over the years. I like her. Adorable.
Nikko: He's great and underrated. Really like him a lot!
Carrie: FLOVE her.
Haley: Love her a lot too!
Lauren A: Really like to love her.
Thia: I like her. Quite underrated and good. Adorable.
Paris: Yes, Love her a lot!
Kris: Love him too!
Kimberley: Really like / love her.
Allison: She's awesome. Love her.
Anthony: Like to really like him.
Kimberly C: She's fierce. Like her a lot.
Adam: Oh gosh. Had a Like/Dislike relationship during Idol but I love his post-Idol music.... so yeah I like him right now.
Melinda: Amazing! Love her a ton.
Diana: She's faded a bit for me over the years but I do really like her a lot.
Michael: I like him. Kind of too inconsistent for me and was a bit of a letdown but he's cool.
Jordin: FLOVE her. One of my favorites ever.
Scotty: Eh. Don't care for him but he's good at what he does.
Syesha: FLOVE her. One of my favorites ever.
Casey: Eh, he's alrigt but don't care for him.
Phil: He's really good. Really like him.

[druth8x]

Wally, even Scotty and Casey are not dislikes, just meh's. You really do like most everyone. Or at least those who made this Top 52. You didn't tell me who you are missing from this that you would like included.

Let me count your really like - love - flove now: close to approx 40.

Every elimination show is going to be hard on you.

[*Wallace]

Wally, even Scotty and Casey are not dislikes, just meh's. You really do like most everyone. Or at least those who made this Top 52. You didn't tell me who you are missing from this that you would like included.

Let me count your really like - love - flove now: close to approx 40.

Every elimination show is going to be hard on you.

Yeah thankfully the Idols I do dislike didn't make it through. There are a good 10-20 finalists I don't like so I'm glad none of them advanced through. Well depending on how the groups are organized, some will be difficult but hopefully it won't be THAT difficult.

As for whose missing that I would have wanted to be included, the main one is Stefano. He was my favorite guy of Season 10 so it's a bummer he didn't make it. Blake and Chris R are some other ones I wished who had made it. Then also Michael and David H. Most of my favorite girls made it through, except Katie and Lisa. I think that's all I can remember for now.

[hayden98]

I will try my best to review the Top 52 tomorrow at some point.

I noticed the lack of Paige Oh well...at least I like a lot of the others.

[druth8x]

Sorry Hayden, I should have given her the courtesy of being on the poll. But I really didn't think RE would have voted her through. Needed at min 4 votes...preferably 5. Glad you can vote through your IPhone.

Wally, yeah you do dislike some. Glad most of your girls made it. Yeah I'm bummed about Katie...but I was bummed by about 15 but felt I best just cut my losses. It's not my favs but RE's favs with 36/52 already preselected by WNTS. These 52 are all likes for me or higher, or at least respect. Which Michael (Sarver or Lynche)? I don't think any that you mentioned would have made it out of the semifinals, maybe not even the quarter finals. I can tell you that some of very final spots were judgement calls. And as such, some had the same amount of votes as those that made it through.

[hayden98]

Siobhan: I like her. She'd make my top 5 based on the real Top 12.
Brooke: She's pretty awesome
Tamyra: She's good, I'm not a fan ATM but I haven't rewatched the whole season yet so she'll likely grow on me.
Elliott:
Mandisa:
Christina: At least based on the actual Top 10 that year, she makes it to 2nd place just behind Kelly.
LaKisha: She's pretty good.
Katharine: She is amazing. Definitely my fav of that year
Vonzell: Carrie-Baby V finale FTW
Taylor: Meh
La Toya: She has a great voice.
Fantasia: She and Diana and Jasmine are tied for 1st in my book.
Ruben: Pretty nice.
Alexis: Robbed
Jason: He's alright.
Pia: She's so talented. I can't describe how I feel about her not even making the Top 5
Crystal: 2nd fav that year of the semifinalists
Clay: Eh, not my cup of tea.
David C:
David A:
Carly:
George: Amazing.
Chris:
Matt G:
Kelly:
Bo: He's pretty good.
Nadia:
Jennifer H:
James: I like him currently, not enough to buy his album but I like him. Easily in my Top 3 guys.
Treynce:
Jacob:
Kellie:
Nikko: Awesome
Carrie:
Haley: I am proud to say that I was among her first fans. (Since the promos started showing her)
Lauren A:
Thia: Cool
Paris: Epic
Kris: Fav guy winner
Kimberley: I love her
Allison: She's really good
Anthony: I like him
Kimberly C: I really like her voice
Adam: He's alright. A little overated though
Melinda: She's great!
Diana: See Fantasia
Michael: Awesome
Jordin:
Scotty: I think he's really good. Not my pick to win but he's really good.
Syesha: I remember calling her "Overunderated" once. I still think she's great.
Casey: He's pretty good.
Phil: He's okay.