Pablo's SYTYCD Lists Options

[Erestor]

Sasha isn't that great. Her Ballrooms sucked and her solos were mediocre. And she was just as much overrated by the judges (if not more) as Melanie.

This post has been edited by Erestor: Jan 29th 2012, 6:19 PM

[gabegir45]

Sasha isn't that great. Her Ballrooms sucked and her solos were mediocre. And she was just as much overrated by the judges (if not more) as Melanie.

agreed completely.

[sytycdfan123]

Sasha isn't that great. Her Ballrooms sucked and her solos were mediocre. And she was just as much overrated by the judges (if not more) as Melanie.

Oh look you got another top

I'm not the biggest Sasha fan (Megan probably is though) but I think Sasha was way better at the other styles not counting Contemporary.

[Erestor]

agreed completely.

Oh look you got another top

I'm not the biggest Sasha fan (Megan probably is though) but I think Sasha was way better at the other styles not counting Contemporary.

I just can't win with this.

Well, she may be better at Hip Hop, but I don't think her Ballrooms were good at all. I know Melanie's Ballrooms weren't that great either (or if they actually were Ballroom..), but I would have liked to see her doing a Cha Cha or a Jive and see how she would have handled that.

This post has been edited by Erestor: Jan 29th 2012, 6:30 PM

[gabegir45]

I just can't win with this.

Well, she may be better at Hip Hop, but I don't think her Ballrooms were good at all. I know Melanie's Ballrooms weren't that great either (or if they actually were Ballroom..), but I would have liked her to see doing a Cha Cha or a Jive and see how she would have handled that.

basically this.

I love how much we've agreed lately.

[totes4totes]

Sasha isn't that great. Her Ballrooms sucked and her solos were mediocre. And she was just as much overrated by the judges (if not more) as Melanie.

Her first ballroom was with the deadweight that was Alex and horrific choreography.
Her quickstep didn't suck. We all came to that conclusion.
Her cha-cha with Tadd sucked as much because of Tadd and the choreography as it did Sasha.

Flat out nobody was all that great at ballroom in season 8.

I liked her solos. And who f*cking cares about the judges. If everybody gets so f*cking up in arms about the judges then just don't watch them. I am so f*cking tired of the use of the judges overpraise as a legitimate reason not to like a dancer. Because it has the really f*cking easy solution of just not watching the judges. If they are debilitating you that much, then just skip them. Not only does it make the show more enjoyable, you can watch it more quickly.

[Erestor]

Her first ballroom was with the deadweight that was Alex and horrific choreography.
Her quickstep didn't suck. We all came to that conclusion.
Her cha-cha with Tadd sucked as much because of Tadd and the choreography as it did Sasha.

And who f*cking cares about the judges. If everybody gets so f*cking up in arms about the judges then just don't watch them. I am so f*cking tired of the use of the judges overpraise as a legitimate reason not to like a dancer. Because it has the really f*cking easy solution of just not watching the judges. If they are debilitating you that much, then just skip them. Not only does it make the show more enjoyable, you can watch it more quickly.

I actually thought both of them looked like deadweights and it looked like a dress rehearsal performance.
It didn't suck, but she wasn't too impressive either.
The fact that Tadd wasn't that great in this is another history. Sasha was the only one who could have saved that and she didn't because she wasn't sexy at all and looked terribly awkward while dancing it.

LMAO at all of this. I love when you get heated. But tbh, I always watch the judges comments, because they're supposed to be the professionalists and tell us what wasn't good. But since they aren't doing it lately, and a lot of their comments or reactions like standing ovations *coughMelissaMitrocough* do affect the voting, we at least want to know who their favorites are and predict how the public is going to vote based on the judges's comments. And unfortunately, when you hear the judges talking crap all the time, you can get annoyed. Especially when you would have actually liked them to critique that performance, since you KNOW it wasn't great, instead of hearing that it was the best performance ever since Ramalama.

This post has been edited by Erestor: Jan 29th 2012, 6:38 PM

[Zak9369]

- I am perfectly fine with Melanie going. She actually went during Top 14 week in my redo, too.
- Alexander is useless deadweight. PERFECTLY fine with him peacing out, too.
- LIGHT THROUGH THE BRANCHES.

[sytycdfan123]

Well, she may be better at Hip Hop, but I don't think her Ballrooms were good at all. I know Melanie's Ballrooms weren't that great either (or if they actually were Ballroom..), but I would have liked to see her doing a Cha Cha or a Jive and see how she would have handled that.

I think Melanie's disco indicated that she would be just as bad as Sasha was in latin.

- I am perfectly fine with Melanie going. She actually went during Top 14 week in my redo, too.
- Alexander is useless deadweight. PERFECTLY fine with him peacing out, too.
- LIGHT THROUGH THE BRANCHES.

Yay for agreement.

[poopooface]

Melanie gone already!? Her jazz skills are so under-appreciated.
And americano is just an under-appreciated routine in general, even by her fans.

But I love how your post started a Melanie vs. Sash fan-war!

[jstxanothrxstory]

Top 16:
-Alexander was irrelevant to everything and Melanie's my eighth favorite girl, so I have no complaints. Especially since the only girls I disliked are already gone.
-Yay, Sasha and Marko. This is Megan's dream come true pairing.

Flat out nobody was all that great at ballroom in season 8.

GIRL.

[poopooface]

Flat out nobody was all that great at ballroom in season 8.

Aw hellz no. You just made this Melanie vs. Sasha fan-war into a Melanie vs. Sasha vs. Clarice vs. Caitlynn fanwar.

And flat out, Clarice pwns all these hos in ballroom.

I liked her solos. And who f*cking cares about the judges. If everybody gets so f*cking up in arms about the judges then just don't watch them. I am so f*cking tired of the use of the judges overpraise as a legitimate reason not to like a dancer. Because it has the really f*cking easy solution of just not watching the judges. If they are debilitating you that much, then just skip them. Not only does it make the show more enjoyable, you can watch it more quickly.

This raises an interesting question. How do people usually watch the show? I assumed most people would watch it live, but this statement suggest most people on IDF actually watch it on DVR or download it. Is this really the most common method on IDF? And if so, does that mean most of you don't vote?

[poopooface]

GIRL.

Lol, that's right. We both forgot about Iveta.

[jstxanothrxstory]

Aw hellz no. You just made this Melanie vs. Sasha fan-war into a Melanie vs. Sasha vs. Clarice vs. Caitlynn fanwar.

And flat out, Clarice pwns all these hos in ballroom.

Let's not forget about the actual ballroom girl who, versatility issues aside, easily pwns every other girl from S8 in ballroom.

[Mackadal]

Iveta pwns every h0 on the planet in ballroom. Literally.

This post has been edited by Mackadal: Jan 30th 2012, 9:54 PM

[jstxanothrxstory]

BTW, Pablo.

[sytycdfan123]

Melanie gone already!? Her jazz skills are so under-appreciated.
And americano is just an under-appreciated routine in general, even by her fans.

But I love how your post started a Melanie vs. Sash fan-war!

I only liked Melanie during the auditions, I liked her in "Game On" but then I imagine how much better it would have been if Clarice or Jordan had danced it.

Top 16:
-Alexander was irrelevant to everything and Melanie's my eighth favorite girl, so I have no complaints. Especially since the only girls I disliked are already gone.
-Yay, Sasha and Marko. This is Megan's dream come true pairing.

GIRL.

I'm glad you don't care for either Alex or Melanie.



I love those routines.

Let's not forget about the actual ballroom girl who, versatility issues aside, easily pwns every other girl from S8 in ballroom.

[sytycdfan123]

Iveta pwns every h0 on the planet in ballroom. Literally.

Hell yeah!

BTW, Pablo.

Thank You!

[AloneInHerHeaven]

You should continue this redo and finish it before season nine ends

at Ryan getting eliminated first. YAY

I'm glad Iveta and Nick made it past that second week double elimination even though you aren't actually doing double eliminations in your redo. Good idea, they did suck - the double elimination, not Nick and Iveta

I'm surprised you eliminated Melanie pre-top ten. Pleasantly surprised

[sytycdfan123]

You should continue this redo and finish it before season nine ends

at Ryan getting eliminated first. YAY

I'm glad Iveta and Nick made it past that second week double elimination even though you aren't actually doing double eliminations in your redo. Good idea, they did suck - the double elimination, not Nick and Iveta

I'm surprised you eliminated Melanie pre-top ten. Pleasantly surprised

I got so lazy to finish it I probably won't but we'll see.

Of course I think she left first in almost every redo.

I loved both of them so I was not going to let them leave early. I hate double eliminations so much.

She was one of my least favorites of the season so I'm surprised I didn't cut her earlier.