Starting in Season 2:
Batch 1 Spring: Jermaine Paul, Danielle Bradbury, Josh Kaufman, Sawyer Fredricks, Alisan Porter, Chris Blue, Brynn Cartelli, Maelyn Jarmon, Todd Tilghman, Cam Anthony
Batch 2 Fall: Cassadee Pope, Tessanne Chin, Craig Wayne Boyd, Jordan Smith, Sundance Head, Chloe Kohanski, Chevel Shepherd, Jake Hoot, Carter Rubin, Girl Named Tom
Next Question: If you were to choose only one winner per year from 2012 on; who would you choose?