mytake1

With all her success, Mandisa never got the recognition from Idol that she deserved. It was sad to learn that she's had mental health struggles.

Why do you feel the need to pick on someone each season and then relentlessly go after them? I don’t know why anyone would spend all their time and energy on someone they don’t like. I am not even a fan of Country music, but the way Colin was treated was horrible - to the point where violence being suggested.

And no one should be bothered with my comment that Quantavious is the best singer in the competition and that he could sing circles around the Pageant Queens, white girls.

Oh please. People here do that all the time.

It's the same thing every year - a certain type of performer (white, bland female) gets pimped here, but end up going nowhere after the show.

But did you vote for any guys this season? It's very telling when someone's signature of favorites are just all white privilege girls and 1 white gay guy. No diversity. No representation.

Of course, Quatavious is the best singer in the competition. He can sing circles around the Pageant Queens, the white girls.

You hate with every guy, including Alejandro. Last season you went after Colin Stough with a vengeance. He ended up getting the first to be signed.

Pink has said she doesn't want to be a judge and had previously turned it done. Lady Gaga has the big Joker sequel in Oct. She will be too busy promoting the film and campaigning for the Oscars. Adele is too big of a name for Idol.

Well, she is supposed to be on track to be the next Carrie Underwood, and we know IDF is never wrong, lol.

So what if he made it to a certain point on the show. It's not like he had any kind of success after the show. Whereas Catie Turner did. The reality is that most of them will be forgotten when they are no longer on TV. It happens every season. The Idol fan base is notorious for moving on - very quickly.

He didn't last much longer. He didn't do that much after the show. Whereas Catie Turner got herself eliminated. She focused on her song writing as an indie artist, eventually got signed to a major label. We saw her come back last season as a mentor.

Some are better than others with originals - and it has worked for them. I don't know what happened with KB? Catie Turner messed up her lyrics, but she handled it like a pro. She said she should be eliminated over Michael J. Hunter Metts messed up, but he was crying and crying where he had to be consoled by the judges. He didn't last much longer after that.

I don't follow him, but he could be doing that on the side. He has a young kid. Not sure how his music career is going. Just Sam who won Season 17 - was forced to go back to busking and working at Starbucks at one point.